Most of state’s 23 NFL draft picks weren’t elite high school prospects

Mims was the only 5-star recruit; four were not rated out of high school.
Marietta's Kimani Vidal runs the ball down field toward Rome's Trey Lawrence during the second quarter of Thursday's 2020 game at Barron Stadium in Rome. Vidal was a three-star prospect ranked as the consensus No. 949 prospect out of high school after he rushed for more than 1,000 yards for a Class 7A championship team. The Los Angeles Chargers selected him in the sixth round, No. 181 overall, in the 2024 NFL Draft. (Jeremy Stewart/Special)

Marietta's Kimani Vidal runs the ball down field toward Rome's Trey Lawrence during the second quarter of Thursday's 2020 game at Barron Stadium in Rome. Vidal was a three-star prospect ranked as the consensus No. 949 prospect out of high school after he rushed for more than 1,000 yards for a Class 7A championship team. The Los Angeles Chargers selected him in the sixth round, No. 181 overall, in the 2024 NFL Draft. (Jeremy Stewart/Special)

The 23 former Georgia high school players taken in the NFL draft proved again that it’s where one finishes that counts.

While the NFL drafts 257 players, only six of Georgia’s 23 were rated that highly as high school players. The 23 had a median national prospect ranking of No. 669 entering college.

In fact, four of the 23 got no ratings in the 247Sports Composite, the most commonly sited source for consensus player evaluations.

One unrated player was former Walker offensive lineman Hunter Nourzad, a fifth-round pick of the Chiefs. Nourzad was a first-team all-state player in 2017, but he was what coaches refer to as ‘’an academic kid” at his Marietta private high school. Nourzad played in the Ivy League at Cornell, graduated with an engineering degree, then played his final two seasons at Penn State, where he earned Big Ten honors.

The most unlikely NFL draft pick from Georgia was Qwan’tez Stiggers, who played on a 27-player high school team at Atlanta’s B.E.S.T. Academy. Unrated as a prospect, Stiggers dropped out of Tennessee’s Lane College as a 2020 freshman without playing a game. On his mother’s advice, he joined an indoor football league, then became the Canadian Football League’s rookie of the year in 2023 as a cornerback. The Jets drafted him in the fifth round.

Offensive linemen Travis Glover of Dooly County and Tylan Grable of Wilkinson County were overlooked while playing for Class A programs in south Georgia. Each unrated prospect went in the sixth round, Grable to the Bills and Glover to the Packers.

The rest of Georgia’s 23 were rated three-star recruits or higher, but North Murray’s Ladd McConkey, Troup’s Jamari Thrash and Lovejoy’s Bub Means — all wide receivers — were pegged outside the top 1,000 nationally coming out of high school.

Georgia’s best high school prospect drafted was Bleckley County tackle Amarius Mims, the lone five-star. The Bengals took Mims with the No. 18 overall pick after his three seasons at Georgia. Mims was an AJC preseason Super 11 choice in 2020. No other former Super 11 players were drafted.

Two other five-star prospects and Super 11 players who would be eligible — Cedar Grove’s Jadon Haselwood and Marietta’s Arik Gilbert — have never been drafted. Each was an AJC all-classification player of the year after leading their high school teams to state championships.

Gilbert’s Marietta teammate, running back Kimani Vidal, was the No. 949 overall player in the 2020 recruiting class and was drafted in the sixth round by the Chargers. Vidal, measured at 5 feet, 7 7/8 inches at the NFL Combine, was overshadowed on a great Marietta high school team despite rushing for more than 1,500 yards. He rushed for 1,661 yards last season at Troy.

Georgia’s two second-round picks were just three-star recruits out of high schools. Both were safeties. Baldwin’s Javon Bullard went to the Packers, and Starr’s Mill’s Cole Bishop went to the Bills.

The final Georgia player taken Saturday was Michigan linebacker Michael Barrett of Lowndes. Barrett was a three-star prospect and a decorated high school player — but as a quarterback with more than 4,500 yards passing and 2,500 rushing. The Panthers drafted him No. 240 overall after he won a national championship as Michigan’s defensive captain.

Georgia’s 23 picks are roughly the average number for the past decade. The record is 30, set in 2022. Georgia ranked third among states this year in total picks this year behind Florida (30) and Texas (24), according to High School Football America.

Below are Georgia’s 23 players with their high school star rating and individual national ranking as college prospects.