New targets needed for immigration enforcement

We are seeing deeper divides in the streets, in protests which are getting more filled with clashes, hate and violence. Much of the division seems to involve skin color, ethnicity and how “American” they are; who is really “American,” and who is allowed to be an “American.” 

Over the last decade, the issue of illegal immigration and what to do with the “illegals” in our country has been front and center in our political debate. Currently, we have approximately 11.4 million undocumented immigrants living and working in the United States. 

Whether the illegal immigrant is a law-abiding person or a gang member is of no consequence under our immigration laws. Both classes of people have committed a federal crime by entering the U.S. without authority. The penalties for illegal entry may include years in jail as well as deportation. 

America’s undocumented immigrant problem is based on the simple economic principle of supply and demand, coupled with a lack of enforcement of existing laws. American businesses demand low-cost labor and that promotes an influx of undocumented workers to our country. For example, American agriculture relies heavily on illegal immigrants to keep the industry cost-effective and sustainable. Fifty percent of hired crop farmworkers are not legally authorized to work in the United States , and almost 70 percent of hired crop farmworkers are from Mexico. 

Employers have ignored, or even looked the other way when it comes to adhering to our immigration laws. Couple that with the fact that government enforcement of employers has been spotty. According to The Washington Times, “Through the first five months of this [2015] fiscal year, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement conducted just 181 workplace audits and brought charges against only 27 employers, putting it on pace for fewer than 500 audits and just 65 arrests this year. That’s less than 15 percent of the total audits conducted in 2013.” The downward trend is alarming.

In the 1990s, there was a lower number of audits than today; but the government issued more final orders against employers who engaged in these illegal hiring practices. While the political rhetoric is pervasive, the backbone to deal with the root of the problem is lacking. Locking up individuals misses the mark and puts a Band-Aid on a problem requiring surgery. While throwing on handcuffs helps satisfy the populist base, this policy is nothing more than a show of immediate authority lacking a long-term solution. 

As expected, President Donald Trump hit the ground running with his enforcement regime by utilizing raids to round up illegal immigrants. As quickly as February of this year, there were 678 people arrested in 12 states. Only seventy-four percent of those arrested had criminal convictions. 

President Trump still intends to build a wall to secure our southern border and control the influx of undocumented immigrants. While controlling our borders is critical, the solution is not to round up all the “bad hombres.” That would be a logistical, legal and financial nightmare. It costs $126.46 per day to house a person in an immigration detention center. Over the course of a typical month-long detention, this comes out to almost $3,800.

That is just for housing the people that we catch. What about the cost of investigation, arrest, court, appeal, etc. The American Action Forum estimated that it would cost American taxpayers between $100 billion and $300 billion to remove all of our undocumented immigrants. The cost gets closer to half a trillion dollars when taking into account the increased enforcement costs to ensure that the deported immigrants cannot re-enter the United States. This is all in addition to the cost of the “wall.”

Instead, we need to spend our resources to combat the source of why so many come to the U.S. illegally.

Government needs to vigorously investigate and prosecute employers who hire illegals. If there are decreased prospects for employment, undocumented immigrants will have less incentive to enter the U.S. without authority.

Manubir “Manny” Arora is an Atlanta defense attorney, a former Lieutenant Colonel in the U.S. Air Force Reserve and a former Assistant District Attorney in Fulton County.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Why is the left ditching the DACA compromise?
Why is the left ditching the DACA compromise?

It looks like a plan that would have allowed “Dreamers” to stay in the United States is off the table for the moment. Why are Democrats backing away from a compromise that would help those under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program? A roundup of editorials Thursday takes a look at the issue. 1. Here’s why...
Will Democratic ideals get in the way of a fair decision for ‘Dreamers’?
Will Democratic ideals get in the way of a fair decision for ‘Dreamers’?

As the threat of a government shutdown looms, will the left stick with their vision for immigration, or compromise with Trump for the “Dreamers” sake? A roundup of editorials Thursday takes a look at the choice the left faces. 1. Democrats hitch their party to immigrants From Bloomberg: The commitment to the issue of immigration is...
Opinion: A year in, Americans are of two minds about Trump, both of them wrong

This week brought an update on President Donald Trump’s health from the White House physician. Trump is up 3 pounds from his last check-up but his “overall health is excellent,” said Navy doctor Ronny Jackson. He added that, at Trump’s request, he’d administered a cognitive screening test and confirmed, contrary to perceptions...
Readers Write: Jan. 18

“Junk mail” serves purpose at U.S. Post Office The letter “Stop subsidizing junk mail industry,” Readers Write, Jan. 10, claims that junk mail is subsidized. Perhaps junk mail may not completely pay its own way, but this mail is valued by the U.S. Post Office. This “junk mail” is given a low priority by the post...
The left just wants a DACA deal done and finished
The left just wants a DACA deal done and finished

The fate of thousands of Dreamers should not depend on the political whims of the members of Congress and the president. From the Orlando Sentinel: Both parties need to step up their game on DACA and avert a government shutdown. From Message to party leaders – both Democrats and Republicans will be blamed if there is no DACA deal...
More Stories