Suspect asks for ‘lawyer dog’ — gets neither


Without a comma, the request for a “lawyer dog” was a bit confusing. With a comma, it made all the sense in the world.

In a recent 6-1 decision, the Louisiana Supreme Court rejected an appeal by Warren Demesme, who awaits trial on sexual assault charges. Demesme contends that his police interview improperly continued after he invoked his right to a lawyer.

In a concurring opinion, Justice Scott Crichton explained that because Demesme was “ambiguous and equivocal,” the interrogation did not have to be terminated because he had not clearly invoked his right to counsel. According to Crichton, Demesme said this: “(T)his is how I feel, if y’all think I did it, I know that I didn’t do it, so why don’t you just give me a lawyer dog ‘cause this is not what’s up.”

If you use a comma, Demesme said it this way – “so why don’t you give me a lawyer, dog.” Or more colloquially: “so why don’t you give me a laywer, dawg.”

Atlanta criminal defense attorney Don Samuel responded with disbelief at the court’s decision.

“It’s just ludicrous,” said Samuel, who has written books on appellate case law. “Nobody reading that, except someone who doesn’t deserve to be a judge, can possibly doubt what the defendant meant by that.”

Even though the charges against Demesme are extremely serious, that shouldn’t matter, Samuel said.

“Constitutional rights matter for every case, from being charged with littering on Peachtree Street or committing an act of terrorism,” Samuel said. “They shouldn’t be denigrated by insisting on grammatical perfection when invoking those rights. When you start getting that picayune about something like that, you’re just denying someone’s constitutional rights altogether.”

Without comment, Justice Jefferson Hughes III issued the only dissent in the case.

Crichton said he wrote his concurring opinion “to spotlight the very important constitutional issue regarding the invocation of counsel during a law enforcement interview.”

By saying “lawyer dog,” Demesme “ambiguously referenced a lawyer,” Crichton wrote.

Stephen Bright, a professor at Georgetown University and Georgia State University law schools, said Demesme was denied justice.

“The court found ambiguity where none existed in order to rule against Warren Demesme,” he said. “It should have enforced the right to a lawyer instead of finding a way to avoid it.”

Atlanta lawyer Amanda Clark-Palmer also disagreed with Crichton’s take on Demesme’s request.

Tongue in cheek, she added, “What’s so odd about this, the suspect obviously wanted a lawyer who graduated from UGA.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation & World

Man with tattooed face wanted for climbing in unlocked window, assaulting woman
Man with tattooed face wanted for climbing in unlocked window, assaulting woman

Ohio authorities are searching for a man with distinctive tattoos covering his face and neck, who is  accused of climbing through an unlocked window at a Cincinnati home and assaulting a woman. >> Read more trending news  Michael Mann, 34, is wanted for aggravated burglary and domestic violence. According to police reports...
Disney handing out $1,000 bonuses to 125,000 US employees
Disney handing out $1,000 bonuses to 125,000 US employees

The Walt Disney Company is handing out $1,000 bonuses to all U.S. employees and creating a new $50 million education fund for its hourly workers, according to a statement released Tuesday. >> Read more trending news  The Burbank, Calif.-based entertainment giant announced all U.S.-based hourly and part-time employees with the company...
12 camels booted from beauty contest at Middle East festival over Botox use
12 camels booted from beauty contest at Middle East festival over Botox use

Camels were once prized across the Middle East for transportation, for use in war, for food and even as companions, as guides and partners. Now they’re prized for a whole different set of reasons, including their beauty and racing abilities, and are celebrated at annual camel festivals across the region. >> Read more trending news ...
Want a better memory and a happier life? Eat more curry, study says
Want a better memory and a happier life? Eat more curry, study says

Want to improve your memory and live a happier life? Try adding more curry to your diet, a new report suggests.  Researchers from the University of California Los Angeles recently conducted an experiment, published in the American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, to determine how curcumin, the chemical substance that gives Indian curry its...
Meryl Streep, Jordan Peele, Guillermo del Toro and more react to 2018 Oscar nominations
Meryl Streep, Jordan Peele, Guillermo del Toro and more react to 2018 Oscar nominations

Tiffany Haddish and Andy Serkis were at the Samuel Goldwyn Theater in Los Angeles Tuesday to announce the nominees for the 90th Academy Awards. “The Shape of Water,” “Get Out,” “Dunkirk” and “Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri” were among the films receiving multiple nominations...
More Stories