Harris defense: State failed to disprove hot car death was accident


Everything Justin Ross Harris did and said was suspicious on the day his 22-month-old son died after being left strapped in his car seat for seven hours, lead defense lawyer Maddox Kilgore said Monday in his closing argument.

“He screamed too loud at the scene. He didn’t cry in front of us,” Kilgore said.

“The Cobb police made a decision right there on the scene,” he said. “There was never, ever a consideration that this was an accident.”

Following law enforcement’s lead, prosecutors have maintained a singular focus throughout the trial.

“This entire trial has been about count one. Malice,” Kilgore said. “That’s been the state’s theory from the beginning. He meant to do it. He intended to do it.”

That theory has numerous holes, he argued. There’s no evidence Harris had any hatred for his son, Cooper.

Testimony from the defendant’s former wife Leanna Taylor, should be evidence enough to acquit, as she had no reason to say anything positive about Harris, Kilgore said.

“Ross ruined that woman’s life,” he said. “He humiliated her in front of the world. He took her son away.”

Kilgore, seeking to prevent the juror from reaching a so-called compromise, convicting Harris on felony murder, tied to criminal negligence, while acquitting him on the malice charge.

“Murder is murder is murder, whether he’s convicted of count 1, 2 or 3,” Kilgore said. “They’re all the same in Georgia. You need to know that when you’re considering his fate. Each count is just a different theory of murder.”

None of which are applicable, he said.

“Responsible is not the same thing as criminal,” Kilgore told jurors. “The state has not disproven that this was an accident.”

He urged them to consider the evidence, that Harris was planning a family cruise and looking for a home in a good school district — behavior inconsistent with someone who planned to kill his child.

The state’s motive, that Harris wanted to live a child-free life, is also hard to swallow, Kilgore said.

“Ross was already doing whatever he wanted to do,” he said.

Return for updates.



Next Up in Local

Thanksgiving Day shooting in DeKalb County; 1 man dead
Thanksgiving Day shooting in DeKalb County; 1 man dead

Thanksgiving in Atlanta began with a fatal shooting at a DeKalb County Chevron station. DeKalb County Police said a 32-year-old man was shot and killed inside the gas station at 2691 Bouldercrest Rd. at about 1 a.m. Thursday after an argument with his assailant that began outside. The victim, who police have not yet identified, stopped to put air in...
Turkey, mashed potatoes, and the re-birth of an idea for commuter rail
Turkey, mashed potatoes, and the re-birth of an idea for commuter rail

The Dunwoody MARTA station. The station is across the street from the High Street property that is a possible location for Amazon’s second headquarters — should the company choose Atlanta for its new home away from home. CASEY SYKES / CASEY.SYKES@AJC.COM A happy Thanksgiving Day to you and yours this morning. We at the Political...
Source: Mugabe granted immunity; safety in Zimbabwe ensured
Source: Mugabe granted immunity; safety in Zimbabwe ensured

Former President Robert Mugabe was granted immunity from prosecution and was assured that his safety in Zimbabwe would be protected, Reuters reported. The announcement was part of a deal that led to the 93-year-old’s resignation, sources told Reuters. Mugabe, who had led Zimbabwe since its independence from Great Britain in 1980, resigned...
Poll: Americans wary about talking politics on Thanksgiving
Poll: Americans wary about talking politics on Thanksgiving

It’s OK to talk turkey during today’s Thanksgiving dinner, but a new poll reveals that more than a third of all Americans do not want to discuss politics. According to The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research poll, only two out of 10 people said they were eager to talk politics. Four out of 10 do not feel strongly...
Mississippi alderman charged with procuring prostitution
Mississippi alderman charged with procuring prostitution

An alderman from a north Mississippi county was arrested and charged Wednesday with procuring prostitution, police said. Ronald Wayne Hale was booked into the DeSoto County jail with a $1,000 bond, according to the sheriff's office. He was released Wednesday afternoon. Hale had no comment as he left the jail. Hale is the alderman of Ward 2 in Southaven...
More Stories