Greg McElroy explains why Justin Fields ‘isn’t ready for primetime just yet’


Justin Fields-Greg McElroy-Jake Fromm-Georgia quarterbacks

Welcome to Good Day, UGA, your one-stop shop for Georgia football news and takes. Check us out every weekday morning for everything you need to know about Georgia football, recruiting, basketball and more.

Greg McElroy explains why Georgia shouldn’t turn to Justin Fields just yet

A lot of Georgia fans want to see Justin Fields play more. Part of that is due to sophomore quarterback Jake Fromm struggling on Saturday against LSU, as he completed less than 50 percent of his passes and tossed two interceptions. But another reason why some fans want to see Fields takeover is because of the promise he potentially offers.

Related: Kirby Smart facing tough questions about his QBs

Clemson and Alabama both turned their offenses over to younger quarterbacks despite having an established winner on the roster. As of right now, Alabama and Clemson seem to be better with Tua Tagovailoa and Trevor Lawerence at quarterback. But just because it has worked for those two programs doesn’t mean a switch would be in the best interest for Georgia. And if Georgia fans are being honest, Fromm was a better passer than both Jalen Hurts and Kelly Bryant. One bad game shouldn’t undo all that Fromm has accomplished.

Former Alabama quarterback and ESPN analyst Greg McElroy still happens to think that Fromm is the guy who gives Georgia the best chance to win, as he explained on the Paul Finebaum show on Monday.

“I’ve watched Jake Fromm for two years now and I’ve been very impressed by everything that he’s done,” McElroy said. “And I still feel quite strongly that he gives them the best chance to be successful.”

But McElroy didn’t just say he was picking Fromm because of what he’s done. He gave some pretty strong analysis on why Fields, so far, hasn’t proven that he’s a better option for the Georgia offense than Fromm.

“I went back and I watched Justin Fields and I watched him go through his progressions. And he’s just a step late on just about every throw,” McElroy said. “It takes him just a half second too long before he cuts it loose. Now he’s very accurate when he does throw the ball but he’s not quite ready for primetime just yet.

“He’s a great athlete and he will have an opportunity whether it be this season or in the spring and show that he’s capable of handling that job,” McElroy said of Fields. “But based on the seven game sample size that we have so and all the plays and throws and the decisions that he’s made, he is not yet capable of running this team as efficiently as Jake Fromm has.”

In the first seven games of the season, Fields completed 18 of his 25 pass attempts for 200 yards and thrown two touchdowns. But almost none of those attempts have come in competitive games. In SEC play, he’s completed just 5 of his 9 pass attempts. The freshman quarterback obviously brings more to the table as runner than Fromm—Fields has averaged 7.36 yards per carry and scored three touchdowns on the ground—and more of that element could open up holes for Elijah Holyfield and D’Andre Swift. But if Fields is going to be given a chance, as many Georgia fans want to see, he’ll need to show that he’s competent, or at least better than what Fromm was on Saturday if he’s going to earn the full time job.

Prior to the LSU game, Georgia scored 38 points in every game with Fromm at the helm. The sophomore quarterback has shown that he’s a very good quarterback. To McElroy’s point, Fields would need to show that he’s a great quarterback against great teams to beat out Fromm. And that seems like a high order for any freshman quarterback, even one as gifted as Fields.

Related: LSU defensive wizard outschemed Georgia’s multifaceted offense

Top Dawg Todd

For the second week in a row, Todd Gurley was the no-brainer Top Dawg of the Week, which we give to the best former Bulldog in the NFL. We’ll expound more on Gurley in a little bit, but first let’s look at some of the other Bulldogs who had big weeks.

A pair of former Georgia linebackers had strong performances, as Roquan Smith led the Bears in tackles with 13 while Thomas Davis had six tackles and two pass breakups for the Carolina Panthers. This was Davis’ first game of the season, as he was suspended for the first four games.

And for the third week in a row, New England Patriots running back Sony Michel proved he’s a very capable NFL running back. He played a key role in the Patriots’ 43-40 win over the Kansas City Chiefs. Michel ran for 106 yards and two touchdowns on Sunday, making it his third straight week with a touchdown and 95-plus yards. In the last three weeks, Michel has rushed for 316 yards and four touchdowns. New England is 3-0 in those games. In the first three weeks, Michel ran for 84 yards and did not find the endzone. New England was 1-2 in those games. Safe to say Michel plays well, the Patriots play really well.

But of course, Gurley once again had a monster week. He ended the game with a career-high 208 rushing yards and found the endzone twice. The Rams once again needed everything Gurley could give, as they squeezed out a victory over the Broncos in freezing cold weather. With the Kansas City loss, the Rams are now the only unbeaten team in the NFL and Gurley is a big reason why.

Through the first six games of the season, Gurley has 11 touchdowns, the most by any player since Shaun Alexander scored 12 in the first six games of the 2005 season. Alexander ended up winning the NFL MVP that season and Gurley looks like the clear favorite to do so this season. So once again, he is our Top Dawg of the NFL.

Past Top Dawg winners:
Week 1: ReShad Jones DB, Miami Dolphins
Week 2: Shawn Williams DB, Cincinnati Bengals
Week 3: Matthew Stafford QB, Detroit Lions
Week 4: AJ Green WR, Cincinnati Bengals
Week 5: Todd Gurley RB, Los Angeles Rams

Top Stories from around DawgNation

Dawgs on Twitter

Good Dog of the Day

Miss a previous edition of Good Day, UGA? Get caught up here.

The post Greg McElroy explains why Justin Fields ‘isn’t ready for primetime just yet’ appeared first on DawgNation.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

Braves’ Mike Foltynewicz finishes 8th in Cy Young voting
Braves’ Mike Foltynewicz finishes 8th in Cy Young voting

It isn’t the same as the Braves’ Ronald Acuna Jr. winning rookie of the year or Brian Snitker receiving the manager of the year award, but pitcher Mike Foltynewicz had an impressive result in voting for the National League Cy Young Award, which recognizes the best pitcher in each league. Foltynewicz finished eighth in the voting in the...
Georgia Bulldogs finding success in two-minute offense
Georgia Bulldogs finding success in two-minute offense

Although the Georgia offense has had its challenges inside its opponents’ 5-yard line, the Bulldogs have proved to be quite potent with two minutes remaining in the first half.  Against Florida on Oct. 27, Georgia moved 75 yards in seven plays – four of which were passes from Jake Fromm to tight end Isaac Nauta for 66 yards &ndash...
Collins nearing return, status upgraded
Collins nearing return, status upgraded

John Collins is not back yet. But he is getting close. The Hawks power forward, who has not played this season due to a left ankle injury, has been upgraded to doubtful for Thursday’s game the Nuggets. He has been listed as out all season. Collins suffered the injury during the preseason and has missed all 14 games for the 3-11 Hawks. The second-year...
Georgia football podcast: Reaction to 4-star RB Kenny McIntosh’s commitment
Georgia football podcast: Reaction to 4-star RB Kenny McIntosh’s commitment

Georgia football is the No. 1 topic every day on DawgNation Daily — the daily podcast for Georgia Bulldogs fans. Catch up on everything happening with UGA athletics with host Brandon Adams and the cast of DawgNation experts as they break down the latest Georgia football recruiting news and discuss UGA coach Kirby...
Injury report: Bryant, Shelby held out of practice
Injury report: Bryant, Shelby held out of practice

Falcons kicker Matt Bryant (right hamstring) and defensive end Derrick Shelby (groin) did not practice on Wednesday, according to the team’s official injury report in advance of Sunday’s game against the Cowboys. Linebacker De’Vondre Campbell (calf), linebacker Bruce Carter (knee), linebacker Deion Jones (right foot), free safety...
More Stories