What does the Supreme Court mean for the midterm elections? Here are 2 hints


President Donald Trump’s selection of Judge Brett M. Kavanaugh as his second Supreme Court nominee could be a consequential moment for the midterm elections. Republicans hope a confirmation battle will galvanize voters on the right, while Democrats are balancing their own energized liberal base against the political pressure on some red-state Democrats to side with Trump. 

Here is how the elections in November could affect the nomination process — and vice versa. 

 

The Clock Is Running 

With 12 years on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit and stints as a White House staff secretary, under President George W. Bush, and as an assistant to Ken Starr, the independent counsel who investigated President Bill Clinton, Kavanaugh has quite the résumé in government. 

And that could create complications for Trump and Senate Republicans. 

When Sen. Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., the majority leader, offered his guidance about the court pick to Trump last week, he cautioned the president that the sheer volume of Kavanaugh’s paperwork from a career in law and politics could hand Democrats the chance to stall a vote. 

That could mean that Kavanaugh would not be seated by the time the next court session begins in October and, if controversial matters arise from his background, perhaps even push a vote until after the November elections. And that is not what McConnell, who because of Sen. John McCain’s, R-Ariz., absence has just 50 Senate Republicans available, would prefer. 

Holding the vote before the midterms would allow McConnell to put more pressure on those red-state Democrats who are facing re-election and have little desire to incur Trump’s wrath. But should those senators be liberated from such pressure — either by winning or losing Nov. 6 — and not face a vote until after the election, the president’s leverage would be diminished. 

Some Democrats have already argued that no nominee should be voted on before the midterms and that argument may grow more plausible closer to Election Day. 

The Most Important Audience: Women 

The success or failure of Kavanaugh’s nomination, and its political impact, are likely to hinge on two different groups of women. 

First, there are the women of the Senate, including two Republicans supportive of abortion rights, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Susan Collins of Maine, and two red-state Democrats up for re-election this year, Heidi Heitkamp of North Dakota and Claire McCaskill of Missouri. With the abortion right protections of Roe v. Wade at stake, Kavanaugh and his backers cannot afford to lose even one Republican vote if Democrats put up a wall of opposition against him. 

Second, there are the women who vote in November: Female voters have swung hard toward Democrats in recent elections and polls show a potentially historic gender gap emerging in the midterm campaign. Trump and his party must avoid a confirmation process that alienates women any further. 

Signaling that he recognizes this political context for his nomination, Kavanaugh repeatedly stressed his respect for women as role models and peers. In his remarks Monday evening, he cited his mother’s example as a prosecutor and judge in inspiring his own legal career, and thanked Justice Elena Kagan for having hired him during her tenure as dean of Harvard Law School. And Kavanaugh noted that most of the clerks he has hired while a judge have been women. 

But Kavanaugh will face a sterner test in the coming weeks. Already, his role in a recent case involving an immigrant in the country illegally seeking to have an abortion has come under scrutiny, and Senate Democrats have indicated they will press him hard to commit to preserving Roe— a commitment Kavanaugh cannot make without alienating the right, even in the uncertain event he wanted to do so.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation & World

Trump can’t beat Putin at his own game
Trump can’t beat Putin at his own game

Before last Thursday, President Donald Trump's meeting in Helsinki with Russian President Vladimir Putin already promised to be interesting. Then special counsel Robert Mueller's team indicted 12 Russian military intelligence officers on charges of interfering in the 2016 U.S. presidential election, and things got even more complicated.  Monday's...
Smoking to be banned at, near public housing
Smoking to be banned at, near public housing

July 31 marks the day that smokers will not be permitted to light up at or near public housing.  Starting at the end of the month, those who smoke will not be allowed to smoke cigarettes, cigars and pipes inside or within 25 feet of a building, CNN reported. The rule will not apply to electronic cigarettes, chewing tobacco or snuff, CBS News reported...
Trump, Putin meet at Helsinki summit: Live updates
Trump, Putin meet at Helsinki summit: Live updates

President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin are having their first stand-alone meeting Monday at a highly anticipated summit in Helsinki. Update 7:51 a.m. EDT July 16: Trump and Putin are now meeting one-on-one, with translators. Washington correspondent Jamie Dupree tweeted the following key points from their photo op:  Update...
Target competes with Amazon with own prime day promotions
Target competes with Amazon with own prime day promotions

We’re hours from the beginning of  Amazon’s Prime Day -- the day (and now half) that bargain shoppers will scour the online retailer for one or more of its million deals worldwide.  But Amazon isn’t alone in the discount day.   Target has announced its version of the shopper’s online paradise called ...
With Trump in the White House, candidates who sound like him hit the campaign trail
With Trump in the White House, candidates who sound like him hit the campaign trail

In last week's debate between Georgia's Republican candidates for governor, policy was quickly abandoned as Lt. Gov. Casey Cagle and Secretary of State Brian Kemp lit into one another with a familiar slate of accusations.  Kemp called Cagle a liar at least a dozen times. Cagle accused Kemp of conspiring with another Republican to release a recording...
More Stories