Turtles — and the Sea Island spit — back in court


Coastal and environmental groups are appealing a judge’s ruling allowing development of posh Sea Island homes claiming harm to loggerhead turtles and pristine beaches.

A state administrative law judge ruled in August that the Sea Island company can build eight expensive homes — lots begin at $3.5 million — on a “spit” of land below the famed Cloister Hotel. The beach practically disappears at high tide.

The Altamaha Riverkeeper, represented by GreenLaw, and One Hundred Miles, represented by the Southern Environmental Law Center, are appealing the judge’s ruling in Fulton Superior Court. They argue that the administrative judge impropely ruled that a proposed 350-foot-long rock groin would keep endangered turtles from laying eggs and hatchlings from returning to the Atlantic Ocean. They add that the sliver of beach could be renourished without a groin.

“As sea-level rise and related shoreline retreat are increasingly impacting our coast, it’s critical to look to solutions that will provide the greatest benefit to the environment and to the people and wildlife that depend on healthy shorelines and beaches,” Megan Hinkle, staff attorney for the law center, said in a statement. “Groins and other structures that result in the loss of shorelines and valuable ecosystems are not an acceptable solution for the Georgia coast.”

Sea Island, a favorite coastal retreat for well-heeled Atlantans, where suites at The Cloister run $1,000 a night, is selling home lots with unparalleled ocean views. Between 2003 and 2013, though, the beach alongside the planned development shrank by 108 feet. The spit is the only spot on Sea Island ineligible for federal flood insurance.

Environmentalists also say the groin, and a sand dune built with as much as 120,000 cubic yards of sand, will cause the beach to shift and could also impact nearby St. Simons Island.

Administrative Law Judge Kristin Miller, in her August ruling, said: “Weighed against Sea Island’s interest in protecting its valuable upland property, the modest adverse impacts of the permitted project are not unreasonable.”

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is also reviewing the permit application. Earlier, a sea turtle expert with the Georgia Department of Natural Resources, testified that the proposed groin would “unreasonably” interfere with conservation of the endangered turtles.

Sea Island Co. representatives were disappointed Tuesday with the appeal, labeling Judge Miller’s ruling “very thorough and careful.”

In a statement, Scott Steilen, the company’s president, said: “Sea Island has a responsibility to protect its property from continuing erosion, by investing our own funds, using approved methods, and securing all required permits, and we hope to be able to move forward soon to construct the project.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

ONEClayton community resource guide launched
ONEClayton community resource guide launched

ONEClayton Community Resource Guide is an easily accessible comprehensive listing of programs and services available to the Clayton County community, according to a press release. This new website connects residents to resources, programs, and services that are focused on supporting a healthy, successful life. The website offers nearly 200 resources...
Peachtree Corners seeks input to help shape comprehensive plan
Peachtree Corners seeks input to help shape comprehensive plan

Peachtree Corners is seeking citizen input as the city works to update its 2033 Comprehensive Plan. Local governments are encouraged to use the planning process to help shape and guide growth and development. Effective planning ensures future development will occur where, when, and in ways that meet the vision and goals of the community and local government...
Milton OKs STEM summer camps
Milton OKs STEM summer camps

The Milton City Council has approved an agreement with Davis Educational Services LLC to offer two STEM-based educational camps this summer at the Bethwell Community Center. The Parks and Recreation Department facility use agreement has Davis, doing business as Challenge Island, paying a 15 percent commission on registrations to the city, according...
Fayette County begins budget hearings
Fayette County begins budget hearings

Fayette County held the first of its two required public hearings for the FY2019 budget during the Board of Commissioners meeting on June 14. The proposed $93 million budget contains no property tax increase and includes a millage rollback for the sixth consecutive year. The General Fund Balance will increase by $540,250, and just over $6.3 million...
Woodstock sets fines for after-hours park users
Woodstock sets fines for after-hours park users

The Woodstock City Council, responding to the problem of people using the city’s mountain bike trails when they’re closed, has approved a schedule of fines for those caught in the parks after hours. The fines are set at $100 for a first offense, $150 for a second offense and $200 for a third offense, with fines not to exceed $1,000 for...
More Stories