Opinion: If this school-choice bill won’t pass, what possibly could?

School-choice proponents have honed their arguments in recent years, taking their opponents’ objections and, where possible, addressing them in the bills they propose. The evolution continues with the latest measure to appear under the Gold Dome.

Will it matter?

House Bill 482 by Rep. Wes Cantrell, R-Woodstock, is probably the most bulletproof piece of school-choice legislation Georgia has ever seen. The bill would create Educational Scholarship Accounts allowing parents to take the state funding allotted for their child and spend it outside the public k-12 system: for private-school tuition, homeschooling materials, tutoring or, ultimately, college expenses.

The latest version of the bill limits the initial size of the program to just 0.25 percent of all public-school students. It prioritizes students with special needs, students from low-income families, students who were adopted or who are in the foster-care system, students with an active-duty military parent stationed in Georgia, students who have been bullied. It imposes tight financial controls on the program, and some requirements on participating private schools. It requires participating students to take standardized tests annually, with the results reported to the state and their parents.

In short, it addresses every objection school-choice opponents have ever raised. Well, except for their objection to the very existence of school choice at all.

And there’s the rub. If Cantrell’s bill won’t pass muster, no school-choice bill ever will.

Opponents at a hearing Monday were left grasping for straws: The private-school teachers, they lamented, wouldn’t be required to have state certification (though they would need either a college degree or at least three years of education experience, and schools would have to report “the relevant credentials” of ESA students’ teachers to parents). And the students would be allowed to take nationally norm-referenced tests, not the state test (probably because private schools don’t necessarily adhere to the state’s guidelines for what to teach, and when).

They also added the usual boilerplate about public schools “losing money.” Of course, those schools also lose the expense of educating those students, while keeping the federal and local dollars sent to them (roughly half of their per-pupil revenue). It’s not as if they’re unaccustomed to juggling any financial impact of students transferring: Who among us doesn’t recall, as either a student or a parent, kids who left our school to move to another district or state? Adam Peshek of the Foundation for Excellence in Education told legislators Monday that all but 21 of Georgia’s 180 public school districts already deal with the same kind of annual turnover envisioned by Cantrell’s bill. Somehow, schools keep the lights on anyway.

But school-choice opponents aren’t the real folks left without cover here. That would be the lawmakers who hide behind the opponents’ excuses.

Cantrell’s bill left no I’s undotted or T’s uncrossed. Georgia Republicans’ constituents overwhelmingly support school choice. (Dirty little open secret: So do Georgia Democrats’ constituents.) If they won’t vote to give it to Georgians through Cantrell’s bill, how can we expect them ever to do it?

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Just saying yes to drug companies

Last week we learned that Novartis, the Swiss drug company, had paid Michael Cohen — Donald Trump’s personal lawyer — $1.2 million for what ended up being a single meeting. Then, on Friday, Trump announced a “plan” to reduce drug prices. Why the scare quotes? Because the “plan” was mostly free of substance...
Opinion: Trump breaks bread, glasses and party at lunch

POTUS coming to Tuesday lunch. Translated, the president of the United States is joining 50 Republican senators in the Capitol to crash their private Tuesday lunch. Nobody is glad to hear this on the Senate side. We love the constitutional separation of powers. The Senate is the last citadel of democracy, they say. We in the press are free as birds...

Current pols’ mixing of church and state’s unseemly The flurry of so-called conservative candidates for state offices are now blatantly touting their “Christianity” on their TV commercials. We also have a Democrat candidate mentioning her preacher parents as one of her qualifications for office. There are all kinds of &ldquo...
Opinion: Colleges are uneasy mix of ideology, donor dollars

Thanks to a group of courageous and persistent students, George Mason University was recently forced to acknowledge that it had accepted millions of dollars from billionaire Charles Koch and other conservatives under arrangements that gave the donors input into several appointments at the university’s famously libertarian economics department...
Opinion: Anything is possible in latest round of outrageous events

Once I would have rolled my eyes at a “Homeland” season in which the Russians deftly maneuvered to control whether a Democratic woman, an increasingly paranoid former junior senator from New York, would occupy the Oval Office. Last year, I shook my head at the “Billions” plotline showing a top New York law enforcement official...
More Stories