Opinion: Independent in Kansas underscores a broken political system


Kathleen Sebelius might as well be spitting into the Kansas wind.

Don’t try this. People who have stood against the blistering gales of the prairie can attest to the futility.

And yet Sebelius, a former Kansas governor and U.S. secretary of health and human services, is hopeful that a popular third-party candidate will withdraw from the Kansas governor’s race. It’s not going to happen.

The candidate in question, businessman Greg Orman, is projected by the political forecasting site Fivethirtyeight to garner just over 11 percent of the vote on Election Day. That is a serious amount of support for an independent. And it leaves the two major party contenders, state Sen. Laura Kelly, a Democrat, and Secretary of State Kris Kobach, a Republican, with support levels well short of a majority of likely voters.

Orman has virtually no chance of winning. Polls have been split fairly evenly between Kelly and Kobach, although at the moment Fivethirtyeight shows Kobach in a slight lead. That accounts for Sebelius’ concern.

“Greg Orman could elect Kris Kobach governor,” Sebelius has said to various media and other groups while campaigning for Kelly, a personal friend whom she convinced to run.

Sebelius’ efforts to elicit fear among voters of a Kobach governorship will certainly find a receptive audience. Kobach is a demagogue of the worst sort, an innovator of voter suppression techniques and an avatar of the bogus outrage over supposed voter fraud, not to mention his frequent demonizing of immigrants.

But expecting Orman to withdraw supposedly for the good of the state misunderstands the reasons that he got into politics in the first place.

He’s by no means a neophyte or dilettante. He helped found a group called the Common Sense Coalition for Change back in 2010, putting out position papers with more centrist views on a range of issues, critical of hyper-partisanship. In 2016, after failing two years earlier to unseat U.S. Sen. Pat Roberts, he published the book, “A Declaration of Independents.” The subtitle captures a high-minded goal, albeit one that currently seems unattainable: “How We Can Break the Two-Party Stranglehold and Restore the American Dream.”

Orman would be betraying his longstanding views if he abandoned this year’s governor’s race. He would undercut his argument that mediocrity in government is sealed by campaigns where voters don’t choose the candidate they believe is most qualified but rather the one who scares them the least.

That describes too many Kansas voters this go round.

Orman will be perfectly content to recede after a defeat to enjoy life with his two young daughters and his wife, and to continue growing businesses.

So, a harsh truth comes into view: The Kansas governorship will not be won by the candidate that a majority of the voters truly believe will do the best job.

The threat of Kobach as governor is a strong motivator, one that he’s earned through various antics through the years. Moderate voters from both major parties believe that, if elected, he will continue the disastrous tax-cutting policies of former Gov. Sam Brownback. Yet not enough people are fully in the camp of Kelly either.

Democrats and Republicans will be opting for their least offensive option. And they don’t view an independent as viable.

Which is exactly the scenario that Orman sees as the defect of our political system at every level of government.

On November 6, Kansans will prove a philosophical point, and the election will be a loss to Kansas no matter who wins.

Writes for Tribune Content Agency.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: Macron to Trump: ‘You’re no patriot!’

In a rebuke bordering on national insult Sunday, Emmanuel Macron retorted to Donald Trump’s calling himself a nationalist. “Patriotism is the exact opposite of nationalism; nationalism is a betrayal of patriotism.” As for Trump’s policy of “America first,” Macron said: “By saying we put ourselves first and...
Opinion: Will the GOP keep dancing with autocracy?

WASHINGTON — When a national leader urges that votes be ignored or that an election result he doesn’t like might best be set aside, we label him an autocrat or an authoritarian. When it’s President Trump, we shrug. Worse, many in his party go right along with baseless charges of fraud. We are in for a difficult two years. Surviving...
READERS WRITE: NOV. 15

Conceding gracefully is Abrams’ best move I have been following closely the chaos surrounding the recent election for governor. It seems to me Stacey Abrams’ best path forward is to gracefully concede the race and begin preparing to run for another office, such as senator. With all the suspicious actively going on in the Florida governor&rsquo...
READERS WRITE: NOV. 14

Ballot proposals need more-accurate descriptions All of Georgia’s proposed constitutional amendments passed in landslides. Why? The handout I received just before voting said the Georgia Outdoor Stewardship Fund proposal would “conserve lands that protect drinking water sources and the water quality of lakes and streams … (and) provide...
Opinion : The how, what and why of a Trump lie

Donald Trump lies with an audacity and on a scale never before seen in American politics, and it’s tempting to get so caught up in the showmanship of it all that you miss what makes it work. So let me propose a different approach. Instead of focusing on the number and scale of Trump’s lies, what if we focused more intently on one oft-repeated...
More Stories