Opinion: GOP substance vs. style

Legislators this past week passed a significant income-tax cut for Georgians. Both the House and the Senate passed their own versions of a plan to coordinate and expand mass transit in metro Atlanta. A raft of bills to boost rural Georgia advanced in the legislative process, as did measures to take cellphones out of drivers’ hands and keep the mentally ill from buying guns.

Agree or disagree with any or all of those, they are substantive, meaningful policies receiving sober consideration. And yet, the only story many Georgians — not to mention millions outside the state — might recall from the week’s action under the Gold Dome is the move by Lt. Gov. Casey Cagle to block the elimination of the jet-fuel tax for commercial airlines because Delta Air Lines ended a minor discount for NRA members.

If that’s not emblematic of the age of Trump, I don’t know what is.

The substance of Trumpism alarms many people. Possible political dalliances with Moscow by his campaign, restrictionist immigration policies, little seriousness about the national debt, the new tariffs on aluminum and steel he announced Thursday: There’s something worrisome for everyone. But even when the substance has been better — the long-needed revamp of the corporate tax code, regulatory relief, success against ISIS — it’s only temporarily gained notice before being drowned out by the latest tweet, or outburst, or White House infighting.

At some point, all many people remember is the style of Trumpism, which can range from tinpot dictator to somewhat-controlled chaos.

You have surely heard even the MAGA-iest Trump supporter concede it would be nice if the president would either stop tweeting or learn to bite his tongue just a bit. Yes, the lack of political correctness or what experienced politicians call “message discipline” endeared him to some voters. But eventually the unpredictability wears on people.

So you might think the political class would take a hint and avoid running a bunch of clones of this style. But theirs is an industry in which many copycats just want to wring one more electoral victory (or consulting contract) out of a formula that worked once before, no matter how poorly the suit fits their client. And when the substance is impossible to mimic — because hey, it’s hard to predict who will be the last person in the president’s ear before he opens his mouth — the style is all that’s left.

While we haven’t (yet) gotten to that point in this year’s gubernatorial election, this past week was an indication we might be heading in that direction.

It’s an open question whether Cagle helped himself in May’s GOP primary and/or hurt himself in the general election, should he win the nomination. But he was hardly the only Republican to employ the talk tough/tweet tough method. Not to be out-pandered, Secretary of State Brian Kemp proposed replacing a sound tax change (removing a tax on a business input, i.e. jet fuel) with a truly un-sound one (a sales tax holiday, which shifts consumption rather than stimulating it, for guns and ammunition).

The real problem here, as the Kemp example ought to illustrate if the Cagle one didn’t, is the style eventually becomes the substance.

We already saw that with some lower-tier candidates. It’s not reassuring to see the front-runners adopt that tactic.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: What the Times misses about poverty

It’s an affecting story. Matthew Desmond, writing in The New York Times Magazine, profiles Vanessa Solivan, a poor single mother raising three children. Vanessa works as a home health aide, yet she and her three adolescent children are often reduced to sleeping in her car, a 2004 Chrysler Pacifica. In the morning, she takes her two daughters...
Opinion: Days of fear, years of obstruction

Lehman Bros. failed 10 years ago. The U.S. economy was already in a recession, but Lehman’s fall and the chaos that followed sent it off a cliff: Six and a half million jobs would be lost during the next year. We didn’t experience a full replay of the Great Depression, and some have argued that the system worked, in the sense that policymakers...
Opinion: Welcome moves toward transparency
Opinion: Welcome moves toward transparency

Stephen Deere, a new Atlanta city government reporter for The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, joined the paper last October. He put in his first open records request with the city even before his first day on the job. He requested legal invoices, settlements and an expenditure database. And despite the law that says most open records should be produced...
Opinion: Ari Fleischer asks if we’re being fair to Brett Kavanaugh

Ari Fleischer wants to know if we’re being fair. “How much in society should any of us be held liable today when we’ve lived a good life, an upstanding life by all accounts, and then something that maybe is an arguable issue, took place in high school? Should that deny us chances later in life?” Fleischer, a former spokesman...

Late Senator wrong to disdain Confederate ancestor’s service I certainly respect the late U.S. Sen. John McCain for his service to the U.S. Navy and our nation, but I also have a certain level of disgust for him. McCain rightfully bragged about the military service of his father and grandfather, but by ignoring and disdaining the military service...
More Stories