Opinion: Federal tax reform could have ripple effect in Georgia


Republicans unveiled their long-awaited federal tax-reform bill Thursday, closing loopholes and reducing rates across the board. There’s much work left to do, but it gets the ball rolling on one of the GOP’s last chances to enact a major piece of legislation before next year’s midterm elections.

It should also give renewed momentum to an update of Georgia’s tax code.

If you think the Reagan tax reform of 1986 was a long time ago, that’s a blink of an eye compared to the last major overhaul of Georgia’s individual income tax. According to a 2014 report from Georgia State University, it was in 1937 — 80 years ago — that the “bracket structure (was) established which remains, with minor modifications, in place today.”

When lawmakers have changed that basic structure, they’ve gone in the wrong direction. For example: In 1931, the top rate was 5 percent, and it kicked in at $20,000. That’s more than $310,000 in today’s dollars. Today, Georgians enter the top bracket of 6 percent at $7,000 (single filers) or $10,000 (married couples filing jointly).

But if Congress can close the deal on its tax-reform package, it will put pressure on state lawmakers to lower rates.

It’s simple: Georgia adopts taxpayers’ federal adjusted gross income, with a handful of exceptions, and then allows them to claim either the state’s standard deduction or their federal itemized deductions. So for the most part, your federal taxable income is the same as your state taxable income. (The biggest exception is for retirees, who get a generous income exclusion in Georgia.)

A tax reform that expands federal taxable income will thus lead to a sizable increase in state taxable income as well. Just as the increase justifies rate cuts federally, it demands the same at the state level.

For the moment, state leaders are keeping mum on the new bill. They saw the House GOP push through an Obamacare-repeal bill, only to watch the effort bog down in the Senate, and they haven’t forgotten.

They also have something of a head start because of work done in the 2017 legislative session.

You may recall a similar dynamic played out regarding state tax reform earlier this year. The House passed a bill that reduced Georgia’s unwieldy six brackets to a single, lower rate of 5.4 percent. A later version put the rate at 5.55 percent, which would have amounted to a $180 million tax cut — right at the upper limit of what observers believed Gov. Nathan Deal would sign.

The Senate balked because, according to several people with whom I spoke at the time, a number of senators and Lt. Casey Cagle wanted to pass a larger cut, even if that meant Deal would veto the bill. The bill stalled out. Cagle is now campaigning for governor on a plan to cut income taxes by $100 million.

His GOP opponents promise more, all the way up to eliminating the state income tax. That’s a few bridges too far: The individual income tax is projected to raise almost $11.5 billion in the current fiscal year, or just over half of all state tax revenues.

But given that state lawmakers have already charted a path to 5.4 percent, a federal overhaul could give them the space to go significantly lower. This tax reform could be doubly good for Georgians.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

READERS WRITE: JUNE 20

Father’s Day proves value of, need for dads Fathers on the fringe did not see their kids on Father’s Day, and many will wish they did. Many deserve a second chance or amnesty at least on this one day. Kids from father-absent homes are much more likely to carry guns and deal drugs than their peers living with fathers. Mothers and children...
Opinion: Who do you believe, Donald Trump or Donald Trump?
Opinion: Who do you believe, Donald Trump or Donald Trump?

It can’t be easy to keep believing all the things that the Trump faith requires you to believe these days, particularly when they so often contradict each other. For example: 1.) According to Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen, “we don’t have a policy of separating families at the border.” Also, according to Homeland...
READERS WRITE: JUNE 19

Climate-change criers sing redundant tune Well, yet again! Redundancy is one thing, but enough is enough. Month after month, the AJC publishes letters from the same group of writers, many Citizens Climate Lobby members, pushing their carbon fee and dividend mantra (“Maria’s toll shows need to cut emissions,” Readers Write, June 8...
READERS WRITE: JUNE 18

Climate-change criers sing redundant tune Well, yet again! Redundancy is one thing, but enough is enough. Month after month, the AJC publishes letters from the same group of writers, many Citizens Climate Lobby members, pushing their carbon fee and dividend mantra (“Maria’s toll shows need to cut emissions,” Readers Write, June 8...
Opinion: The lesser cruelty on immigration

Let’s start with the easy part. The policy of separating children from their parents at the southern border, delivering them into a bureaucratic labyrinth while their fathers and mothers await trial or petition for asylum, is the wickedest thing the Trump administration has done so far — and you can tell exactly how wicked by observing...
More Stories