PolitiFact: Steel vital to U.S. security? Depends on definition


President Donald Trump’s stated reason for imposing tariffs on steel and aluminum imports was national security.

In an undated but recent memo, Defense Secretary James Mattis acknowledged concerns about “unfair trade practices,” but emphasized “the U.S. military requirements for steel and aluminum each only represent about 3 percent of U.S. production.” In other words, production in the United States is more than 30 times the amount required to satisfy Defense Department needs.

According to the Aerospace Industries Association of America, defense’s share of the high-purity aluminum produced domestically is a bit higher — 10 percent — so the need “is more than adequately met” by existing U.S. sources.

However, the decision to impose tariffs for steel and aluminum imports was based on a different argument by the Commerce Department, which is headed by a longtime free-trade skeptic, Wilbur Ross.

In a pair of January 2018 reports, the Commerce Department concluded that the import situation was “weakening our internal economy,” which it noted was language included in the Trade Expansion Act of 1962. That law requires the president to recognize “the impact of foreign competition on the economic welfare of individual domestic industries” and consider whether “excessive imports” weaken the economy and thus “impair the national security.”

Wayne Ranick, spokesman for the United Steelworkers labor union, said he has no quarrel with the Defense Department’s 3 percent calculation. However, he argued — as the Commerce Department did — that “to sustain that 3 percent, there must be viable U.S. aluminum and steel mills.”

Ranick said, “Mills that have so few orders that they must operate at less than 80 percent capacity shut down sections, lay off workers and lose money. When too much money is lost, the company goes bankrupt and the mill closes.”

He pointed to Commerce Department findings that there’s only one company left in the United States that produces the Navy armor plate used to build Virginia Class Submarines, and only one smelter produces the high-purity aluminum required for defense aerospace needs.

Critics of the tariffs say they can cause at least as many national security headaches as they solve.

For instance, the tariff issue has irked U.S. allies whose assistance is needed in military and diplomatic situations across the globe. Those allies also tend to be valued customers for the U.S. defense sector, which has a sizable trade surplus with the rest of the world.

There’s also a concern that the tariffs could kick off a global trade war, with unknown but potentially significant impacts on the availability of other products the U.S. military needs, not to mention the economy at large.

In addition, while the tariffs would likely aid domestic producers of aluminum and steel, they would presumably raise prices for companies that turn those raw materials into finished products, and this could hurt national security as well. This is especially acute for companies that sell both to private sector companies and the Pentagon, said Remy Nathan, vice president for international affairs at the Aerospace Industries Association.

The White House did not respond to an inquiry for this article.

Our ruling

Military purchases account for a small fraction of U.S. production for steel and aluminum, and critics say the tariffs could hurt national security in ways the White House or Commerce Department aren’t taking into account.

Bolstering Trump’s point, however, the 1962 law used as justification for the tariffs specifically allows a more expansive definition that adds far-reaching critical infrastructure to specific military activities.

Because this claim needs so much additional context, we rate the statement Half True.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation & World

Woman accused of embezzling more than $150,000 from a doctor's office
Woman accused of embezzling more than $150,000 from a doctor's office

The Oklahoma Attorney General’s Office is prosecuting a woman for eight counts of embezzlement. Officials said Ciera Garvin, 31, embezzled $153,000 from the doctor’s office where she worked over a period of seven years. Garvin turned herself in to the Tulsa County Jail. Investigators said the doctor noticed on her tax forms that Garvin...
Giant spoon erected in front of pharmaceutical company to protest opioid addiction
Giant spoon erected in front of pharmaceutical company to protest opioid addiction

A giant spoon was left in front of a pharmaceutical company in protest by a Connecticut artist. The 800-pound, 11-foot-long steel spoon symbolizes a much heavier burden for two artists. "A symbol of the negative emotion I felt of the opioid addiction of my brother, Danny," Westwood native Domenic Esposito said. "For the last 14...
12-year-old's invention for detecting plastics in oceans getting national recognition
12-year-old's invention for detecting plastics in oceans getting national recognition

A 12-year-old girl from Andover, Massachusetts, is getting a big prize and national recognition for her invention to clean up the world's oceans. Anna Du is one of 10 finalists for the Discovery Education 3M Young Scientist Challenge for her work on an invention that detects microplastics in bodies of water without disturbing plants or animals. "...
Jimmy Carter: What to know about the former president and humanitarian
Jimmy Carter: What to know about the former president and humanitarian

President Jimmy Carter served as the 39th president of the United States, from 1977 to 1981, but before that, he was the 76th governor of Georgia and a member of the Georgia State Senate.  >> Read more trending news  Although he’s had a lengthy career in politics, Carter has  worked as a diplomat and humanitarian. He&rsquo...
Hundreds of children reunited with parents; Trump tweets after Republicans delay immigration vote 
Hundreds of children reunited with parents; Trump tweets after Republicans delay immigration vote 

Republican leaders have delayed a vote on a compromise immigration reform bill until next week, hoping to rally more support for the measure even as President Donald Trump casts doubt on its chances of success. Update 4 p.m. EDT June 22: Officials with Immigration and Customs Enforcement issued a notice Friday that said it might seek as many as...
More Stories