PolitiFact: Nebulous link between assault weapons, shootings


Rep. Ted Deutch, D-Fla., claimed mass shootings increased substantially after an assault weapons ban expired in 2004.

At least one researcher found a significant increase in mass shootings since the assault weapons ban expired. But overall, experts caution against pegging an increase solely to the ban’s expiration and told us Deutch’s claim is based on a flawed analysis.

A federal law from 1994 to 2004 banned the manufacture of 19 assault weapons and certain ammunition magazines of more than 10 rounds. Congress did not renew the ban once it expired in September 2004.

Advocates on both sides of the gun debate often point to the same report assessing the ban, published in 2004 for the U.S. Justice Department. The report said it was premature to make a definitive conclusion about the ban’s impact.

But several experts, including the author of a report Deutch referenced, pointed out flaws in Deutch’s relay of that information. That researcher, Grant Duwe, director of research and evaluation at the Minnesota Department of Corrections, said, “This claim is, at best, very misleading for a few reasons.”

For starters, to arrive at a 200 percent increase, the claim has to go back to 1900, not the decade after the ban’s expiration that Deutch cited.

“The assault weapons ban was only in effect from 1994 to 2004, and that is the relevant period to compare with the period after 2004 if one is making a claim about the impact of the assault weapons ban,” said Gary Kleck, David J. Bordua emeritus professor of criminology and criminal justice at Florida State University.

It’s also important to factor in population size changes, experts said.

“If you have more shootings after the ban but also have a larger population, then when the numerator and denominator are increasing, the outcome number stays the same,” said Jaclyn Schildkraut, an expert on mass shootings research and an assistant professor of public justice at the State University of New York at Oswego.

Mass public shootings have become deadlier over the past decade, as the number of victims shot and killed has increased since the expiration of the assault weapons ban, Duwe said.

A critical question in the assessment of the assault weapons ban would be how often assault weapons, however defined, were used in mass shootings, said Gregory Koger, a professor of political science at the University of Miami.

“I do not expect the effect of a ban to be instantaneous, nor to end when the ban ends,” Koger said. “If there are a certain number of assault weapons in circulation when the ban goes into effect and these weapons are removed from circulation over time (say, if they are destroyed, become ineffective, or are seized by the police), then the effect of a sales ban increases over time.”

Our ruling

Researchers of mass shootings told us the analysis Deutch relied on is flawed because it did not adjust for population changes and used irrelevant data points for comparison.

Trends in the incidence and severity of mass public shootings on a per capita basis also show that the rate per 100 million is similar now to that of the 1980s and early 1990s, an expert told us.

A separate analysis found an 183 percent increase in mass shootings where six or more people were killed in the decade after the ban, compared with the 10-year ban period. But experts caution against inferring that an increase is due only to the ban’s expiration.

Deutch’s claim contains an element of truth but ignores critical facts that would give a different impression. We rate it Mostly False.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation & World

Report: Florida man, 39, batters 78-year-old girlfriend
Report: Florida man, 39, batters 78-year-old girlfriend

A 39-year-old Nassau County, Florida, man has been jailed after his arrest on suspicion of battery on a person over the age of 65.  The Nassau County Sheriff's Office said in a report that David Mann, who lives with his 78-year-old girlfriend, was involved in an argument over an unpaid DirecTV bill.  Mann was very angry when services to the...
Property company sues R. Kelly for $203K in damages to homes
Property company sues R. Kelly for $203K in damages to homes

An Atlanta based property management company is suing R. Kelly for damages to two homes he rented near Johns Creek. Fred J. Rushing and Heather L. Johnson — two attorneys with RBBS, LLC — filed the civil suit in the state court of Fulton County on Wednesday on behalf of SB Property Management Global, LLC. The suit claims that Kelly, a Grammy-winning...
Video shows woman in Tennessee forced into back of car; police investigating possible abduction
Video shows woman in Tennessee forced into back of car; police investigating possible abduction

Police are investigating after video shows a woman possibly being abducted in Memphis, Tennessee.  According to the Memphis Police Department, officers responded to a complaint around 8 p.m. Wednesday in the 4100 block of Delp Street about a woman possibly being abducted.  The person who called police told officers he saw a man and woman...
61-year-old man bitten by shark off Cape Cod
61-year-old man bitten by shark off Cape Cod

A 61-year-old man was bitten by a shark Wednesday off Long Nook Beach in Truro. >> Read more trending news  A Medflight was called in to take the victim to the hospital with "deep puncture wounds" to the hip and torso area, and he was rushed to Tufts Medical Center. His name and condition have not been released. Robert Weinstein...
Colorado man who pleaded for return of missing wife, daughters arrested in deaths
Colorado man who pleaded for return of missing wife, daughters arrested in deaths

A Colorado man who for days pleaded publicly for the return of his pregnant wife and two young daughters has been arrested and charged with killing them, police said.  Christopher Lee Watts, 33, of Frederick, was arrested just after 11 p.m. Wednesday night in connection with the slayings of his wife, Shanann Watts, and their two daughters...
More Stories