Trump nominee for Atlanta court is unscathed in confirmation hearing


Judge Elizabeth Branch, nominated to sit on the federal appeals court in Atlanta, breezed through her confirmation hearing on Monday before the Senate Judiciary Committee

Branch, a judge on the Georgia Court of Appeals and a native of Fulton County, encountered no stated opposition during the proceeding. With family and friends seated behind her, the judge expressed gratitude to President Donald Trump for “his nomination and the trust he has placed in me.”

Committee chairman Charles Grassley, R-Iowa, praised Branch for ruling in favor of both “big guys and little guys” and sometimes in favor of criminal defendants in the roughly 1,500 cases she has handled on the Georgia appellate court.

Branch vowed to “do equal justice to the rich and the poor” and to faithfully apply the law.

In response to questions from Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, Branch acknowledged that she considers herself to be both an “originalist” and a “textualist.”

That is, she thinks the words in the Constitution should be interpreted as they were intended to mean when they were written. She also said she will look to the plain text of the Constitution to help guide her when rendering a decision. Both philosophies are often attributed to conservative jurists.

Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., seemed mildly annoyed when Branch declined to answer his question about a 1965 U.S. Supreme Court decision that overturned a Connecticut law that criminalized the use of contraceptive devices. That landmark decision established a right to privacy.

The word “privacy” is not in the Constitution, Durbin told Branch. To rely only on the words of the document, he said, “is a mindless reflection of the reality of court decisions.”

But Branch repeatedly said she would follow the precedents set by the U.S. Supreme Court and the court to which she is nominated – the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which hears cases from Georgia, Alabama and Florida.

“I have always faithfully applied binding precedent and would continue to do so,” she said of her five years on the state appellate court.

“I think she did well in responding to the GOP senators and that is all that matters in the present Senate,” said Carl Tobias, a University of Richmond law professor who closely tracks judicial nominations. “Her answers to difficult questions from Democrats resembled those of most Trump circuit nominees.”

The Judiciary Committee is expected to vote on Branch’s nomination in the coming weeks. If confirmed by the Senate, she would replace Judge Frank Hull, who was put on the 11th Circuit by President Bill Clinton in 1997.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Lightning to blame for house fire, Sandy Springs says
Lightning to blame for house fire, Sandy Springs says

Officials with the city of Sandy Springs and its fire department are blaming a house fire on lightning. The fire happened shortly after 10 p.m. Friday on the 1000 block of Pitts Road. There were no reported injuries, the city said, but the home “sustained extensive damage.” READ | New music venue and bar in Alpharetta hopes to open...
Traffic alert: Busy road in Roswell to close for 21 days
Traffic alert: Busy road in Roswell to close for 21 days

Beginning Monday, a road in Roswell will close for three weeks, the city said. Pine Grove Road is expected to reopen Aug. 6 after the completion of a project that will replace culverts along the road. The culvert replacement project is set up at 375 Pine Grove Road, so crews are closing a section of the road, from its intersections at North Coleman...
Quick-thinking 5-year-old escapes carjacking
Quick-thinking 5-year-old escapes carjacking

It could have been a different call if a 5-year-old girl didn’t take matters into her own hands to escape a carjacking, police said. According to Channel 2 Action News, a man approached the child and her mother outside the Villages at Carver apartments in southeast Atlanta Sunday night. He pointed a gun at the 5-year-old and took off with the...
Torpy at Large: 2 metro Atlanta ZIPs in America’s widening wealth gap
Torpy at Large: 2 metro Atlanta ZIPs in America’s widening wealth gap

Times are swell, right? Unemployment’s down. Stocks are up. Construction cranes are swinging. Head to Suwanee in Gwinnett County and you’ll see that: Stately homes, manicured lawns and a sense that business is booming. Storefronts are occupied, fine cars queue up at traffic lights, and everything is just so brand spanking new. But drive...
6-month-old grazed by bullet in southeast Atlanta shooting
6-month-old grazed by bullet in southeast Atlanta shooting

A mother was attempting to protect her 6-month-old baby when both were hit by a spray of bullets in southeast Atlanta Sunday night, Channel 2 Action News reported. The woman’s grandmother told the news station that she was running away from the gunfire in the 600 block of New Town Circle, holding her baby girl, when both were shot. The baby...
More Stories