‘Breakdown’ S06, Ep. 1: A Jury of His Peers


The four men – two in each car – had a rendezvous at a gas station near I-285. Then they decided to drive both cars across the road to the new Burger King.

It was a few minutes before midnight, closing time for the restaurant. The two vehicles pulled in. Two men got out of the black sedan – the car has never been identified – and joined the two men sitting in the blue Pontiac.

» Listen to earlier seasons of “Breakdown”

» Photos: Images from Season 6 of ‘Breakdown’

What happens next is the subject of the sixth season of our “Breakdown” podcast, hosted this season by Kevin Riley, the editor of The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, and the AJC’s legal affairs writer, Bill Rankin. The first episode went live on Monday.

And here’s what happened next: Almost immediately, the man who had just gotten into the rear passenger-side seat started shooting. He got off 10 shots from a .40-caliber Glock, shooting the man directly in front of him in the head twice at nearly point-black range. The shooter’s companion also was hit. He would later die en route to the hospital.

The driver of the car, who apparently had just been giving a friend a ride, leaped from the Bonneville and fled. Police eventually caught him running on I-285 North; in fact, a police car ran into him.

The fourth man, the one with the Glock, got out of the Bonneville, hopped into the black sedan and disappeared.

Reginald Coicou, 24, and Quincy “Fat” Wytche, 24, were killed just before midnight on April 24, 2016. So began a homicide investigation and then a prosecution that eventually pulled a very diverse group of people into its orbit. One of them was Kevin Riley, the AJC’s editor.

Riley gained extraordinary access to police and prosecutors in this double-murder case, and he teams with Bill Rankin, the AJC’s legal affairs writer, to tell the story in Season 6 of “Breakdown.”

You can download the podcast from iTunes, Stitcher or your favorite podcasting platform. Or you can stream it on your computer in the player below.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION: Join the Breakdown Podcast Facebook group for more AJC coverage and behind-the-scenes looks at previous Breakdown seasons.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Indiana bus driver arrested on suspicion of letting students drive vehicle
Indiana bus driver arrested on suspicion of letting students drive vehicle

An Indiana bus driver was arrested Friday, accused of allowing three teenagers to drive her bus, the Chicago Tribune reported. >> Read more trending news  Joandrea McAtee, 27, was arrested by the Porter County Sheriff’s Office and charged with felony neglect of a dependent after she allegedly let three students, ages 11, 13 and...
Florence aftermath: Good Samaritan who sheltered animals during storm arrested
Florence aftermath: Good Samaritan who sheltered animals during storm arrested

A North Carolina woman was arrested Friday after authorities said she ran an illegal operation while sheltering animals during Florence, the News-Argus of Goldsboro reported. >> Read more trending news  Tammie Hedges, the founder of Crazy’s Claws N Paws in Goldsboro, was charged with 12 misdemeanor counts of practicing veterinary...
Fulton County restaurant inspection scores

Fulton County • Amara Restaurant, 870 Inman Village Parkway, Atlanta. 85/B • Stem’s Café, 3777 Campbellton Road, Atlanta. 90/A • Tannour Grill, 398 14th St., Atlanta. 100/A • The Sun Dial Restaurant, 210 Peachtree St., Atlanta. 98/A • Zest, 957 Canton St., Roswell. 87/B
Gwinnett County restaurant inspection scores

Gwinnett County • Lazeez Tava Fry, 4650 Jimmy Carter Blvd., Norcross. 100/A • New Dragon Chinese Restaurant, 5450 Peachtree Parkway, Peachtree Corners. 100/A • Schlotzkey’s Austin Eatery, 2260 Peachtree Industrial Blvd., Duluth. 94/A • Teriyaki Box, 1766 Old Norcross Road, Lawrenceville. 96/A • Thai Star Restaurant, 5370...
DNA links Cobb County man to 3 rapes dating back to 2006, police say

A man who has served five sentences in state prison is behind bars again, this time accused of three rapes dating back to 2006. DNA evidence links Christopher Charles Sanders, 51, to the crimes, police say. Georgia Department of Corrections records show Sanders began serving prison time in August 1989. Ten years later, he was in the middle of his fourth...
More Stories