DA: No death penalty for Gwinnett mom who killed 4 kids, husband


A Gwinnett County woman charged with killing her husband and four children will not face the death penalty when her case goes to trial.

Isabel Martinez entered a plea of not guilty to stabbing her 9-year-old daughter and killing the five other members of her family at a brief Monday morning arraignment. The Gwinnett County District Attorney’s Office had not formally declared their intent to seek the death penalty by the time of the arraignment. That is the legal deadline to decide whether or not a defendant will be eligible for the death penalty.


MORE | Gwinnett mom felt ‘devil-like spirit’ before stabbing husband, children, report says

PREVIOUSLY | Georgia woman accused of killing children, husband


Martinez, 34, is charged with five counts of murder, one count of aggravated assault and one count of third-degree cruelty to children in connection with the July 2017 attack that left 9-year-old Diana Romero seriously injured and 33-year-old Martin Romero, 2-year-old Axel Romero, 4-year-old Dillan Romero, 7-year-old Dacota Romero and 10-year-old Isabela Martinez all dead.

The DA’s office confirmed the decision not to seek the death penalty to Channel 2 Action News. The decision was made due to Martinez’s “apparent mental issues,” District Attorney Danny Porter told Channel 2. 

Martinez had been depressed in  the months before the killings and had experienced outbursts of anger and sadness that friends considered unusual, neighbors told The Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Martinez felt a “devil-like spirit” was trying to take her children when they were playing in the ocean near Savannah shortly before the killings, she told a Department of Family and Child Services worker after her arrest. 

Court records do not indicate that Martinez has been ordered to undergo a psychological evaluation. Her attorneys, Josh Moore and Laura Berg, did not respond to phone calls from the AJC.

Martinez, who mimed praying and gave news cameras a double thumbs up at her first court hearing in July, smiled meekly as she walked into the courtroom Monday morning. She did not speak at the hearing. 

Martinez had previously told police that a “family friend” committed the stabbings in her Loganville home, but she did not give police the name of that alleged friend. The attack is believed to have occurred between 2 a.m. and 4 a.m. July 7.

Diana Romero, the only surviving child, told a DFCS worker that Martinez began stabbing the children first; when Martin Romero tried to stop her, Martinez stabbed him, according to a DFCS report. Martinez was not crying or screaming as she killed her family members, and told Diana Romero that she was “going to the sky to see Jesus,” Diana Romero told a DFCS worker.

Martinez called 911 at 4:47 a.m. on July 6, and first responders found her with a cut wrist, sitting among the six stabbing victims, according to Gwinnett County police. She was detained and charged that afternoon, and has since been held without bond at the Gwinnett County Detention Center. 


Like Gwinnett County News on Facebook | Follow us on Twitter and Instagram

Stay up to the minute with breaking news on Channel 2 Action News This Morning



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

A youth’s second chance, another family’s tragedy
A youth’s second chance, another family’s tragedy

Fulton County Superior Court Judge Doris Downs decided last year to give Jayden Myrick — the teen accused of shooting a man this month as he left a wedding receiption — a chance to turn his life around. Myrick had been arrested at the age of 14 for his role in an armed robbery and agreed to a negotiated plea of 15 years, to serve seven...
Driver charged with vehicular homicide, DUI after pedestrian killed
Driver charged with vehicular homicide, DUI after pedestrian killed

A woman is facing vehicular homicide and DUI charges after her vehicle hit and killed a pedestrian in southwest Atlanta early Sunday, police said. Jamilia Aisha Clark, 43, of Atlanta, was arrested after the incident in the 100 block of Florida Avenue about 3:20 a.m., police spokesman John Chafee said. According to investigators, a vehicle was traveling...
9 members of one family among 17 killed in duck boat accident on lake in Branson, Missouri 
9 members of one family among 17 killed in duck boat accident on lake in Branson, Missouri 

A duck boat accident on Table Rock Lake in Branson, Missouri, killed 17 people Thursday night, including the boat’s driver and nine members of an Indiana family, according to authorities. Fourteen other people were injured. >> Read more trending news  Update 12:50 p.m. EDT July 22: The 17 people killed in the duck boat accident...
Police ID parents charged with leaving 3 children,  malnourished man
Police ID parents charged with leaving 3 children,  malnourished man

Police arrested the mother and stepfather of three unsupervised children and a disabled adult who appeared malnourished after officers found them in a southwest Atlanta residence. Shalanda Monroe, 38, and Jarvais Monroe, 33, returned to the scene and were taken into custody Saturday, police spokesman John Chafee said. Officers responded to the...
Group studying transit options to get around Hartsfield area easier
Group studying transit options to get around Hartsfield area easier

Mobility in the area around Hartsfield-Jackson International must be improved before the southside of Atlanta can live up to its potential, leaders hoping to boost economic development say. While MARTA makes it easy to get to Hartsfield-Jackson International, getting around the surrounding areas can be a challenge, said Grady Smith, a project manager...
More Stories