Public has no right to courtroom recordings, Georgia justices rule


The Georgia Supreme Court on Monday ruled that the public may not obtain or even copy audio recordings of courtroom proceedings that are made by taxpayer-funded stenographers.

The unanimous decision rejected an attempt by the popular podcast “Undisclosed” to copy a court reporter’s audiotape of a 2001 murder trial in Floyd County.

Because Georgia’s judiciary is not subject to the state’s Open Records Act, the podcast sought access to the audio recordings under a judicial rule that ensures disclosure of official court records. The problem, the state Supreme Court said, is that a court reporter’s recording is not an official record because it is not filed with the court. But the official trial transcript is filed and can be accessed by the public, the decision noted.

Most stenographers record what’s said during trials as a backup to ensure the accuracy of their transcriptions. Podcasts in particular depend on the audio record of an event to enable them to tell the story of that event more accurately and effectively. In its ruling, the state high court cited limited exceptions for when recordings can made available, such as when parties believe there are errors in the official transcript and want them corrected.

The ruling, written by Justice Nels Peterson, does not forbid court reporters or judges from sharing recordings of open court proceedings with podcasts or members of the news media. But it gives court officials the right to turn down the requests whenever they want to.

In recent years, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution has been granted access to copy stenographers’ recordings to use in Seasons 1 and 4 of the newspaper’s “Breakdown” podcast.

“In criminal cases, the court reporters who make the audio recordings are typically paid with taxpayer dollars,” the Georgia First Amendment Foundation said in a statement. “The public should get the benefit of that expenditure.”

The state Supreme Court should require audio recordings to be filed with the court, the foundation said. “Then, under the logic of the court’s decision, the public and press would be able to obtain copies of them.”

“Undisclosed” sought to use the audio so its listeners could hear testimony in the murder trial of Joey Watkins. Watkins is serving a life sentence, but the podcast has raised questions as to whether Watkins was wrongly convicted in the killing of Isaac Dawkins.

“We are, of course, disappointed with the court’s ruling … because Undisclosed’s audience will not get the benefit of listening to the trial,” said Atlanta lawyer James Cobb, who represents the podcast.

“It is ultimately up to individual judges and court reporters to decide whether they want to make recordings available, and we would urge all judges and court reporters to do so,” Cobb said.

University of South Carolina law professor Colin Miller, one of the hosts of “Undisclosed,” also expressed disappointment the court rejected the podcast’s arguments. But Miller praised the court for ruling separately that members of the public not only have access to official court records, they also now have a clearly established right to be able tocopy them.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Cops: Victim in deadly crash was driving ‘well above’ speed limit
Cops: Victim in deadly crash was driving ‘well above’ speed limit

A 31-year-old man was speeding when his vehicle left a Cobb County road early Sunday and hit a utility pole, police said. According to a witness, the man “was traveling well above the posted 45 mph speed limit” when his silver 2002 Chevrolet Suburban left the roadway, Officer Sara O’Hara said in a statement. The SUV was heading northeast...
Lightning strikes house in Gwinnett during storm
Lightning strikes house in Gwinnett during storm

Lightning struck a home in eastern Gwinnett County during a Sunday afternoon storm, fire officials said. No one was injured by the lightning strike, which hit a house on Berry Hall Road in Bethlehem.  READ | Macaroni Grill at Mall of Georgia evacuated, damaged in fire A resident called 911 after the strike and reported seeing smoke coming...
Get your brake lights repaired for free in metro Atlanta this weekend
Get your brake lights repaired for free in metro Atlanta this weekend

The local chapter of a democratic socialist group will repair drivers’ brake lights for free in metro Atlanta this Memorial Day weekend.  Metro Atlanta Democratic Socialists of America organizers say the clinic aims to prevent “unnecessary police stops that can result in expensive tickets and court appearances.” “By reducing...
Police: Florida man tasered after walking naked through neighborhood carrying cooking oil
Police: Florida man tasered after walking naked through neighborhood carrying cooking oil

A Florida man was arrested Thursday for allegedly walking naked through a neighborhood during a rainstorm and carrying cooking oil, the Pensacola News Journal reported. Joseph John Musso, 63, was charged with loitering and prowling, lewd and lascivious behavior, resisting an officer without violence and exposure of sexual organs, the Santa Rosa...
UPDATE: Student hit by car while walking to school
UPDATE: Student hit by car while walking to school

A student was hit by a car while walking to Jonesboro High School on Monday morning, Channel 2 Action News reported. The student was taken to Atlanta Medical Center with minor injuries, according to the news station. He was in a crosswalk when he was hit, Channel 2 reported. Traffic is blocked in the area of Ga. 138 and Jonesboro Road. “Please...
More Stories