Cobb mom who allegedly killed disabled 2-year-old son will not testify


With six utterances of “yes, ma’am” to a Cobb County judge Wednesday, it was determined that the jury would not hear Erica White defend herself during her own murder trial.

The trial, which started more than a week ago, will determine whether or not the Austell woman poisoned her disabled 2-year-old son, Tyrael McFall, in November 2014, and then opened credit cards in his name.

The jury is set to hear closing arguments Thursday.


READCobb cops: MS-13 gang member arrested in retaliatory drive-by shooting


Prosecutors have painted the 45-year-old woman as a calculated killer, but her defense attorneys portrayed a mother broken by her boy’s death.

John Melvin, a prosecutor on the case, said the state brought 48 witnesses and the defense had seven.

Melvin said Tyrael was killed with Tylenol No. 3 — which has codeine — that was ground up into his gastric bypass tube.

The young boy had been profoundly handicapped since eight weeks old when his father, Joseph McFall, beat him.

McFall and White were married less than a year, court records show, and upon seperation White wrote that her reasoning was his cheating and severe beating of Tyrael.

In April 2014, McFall was sentenced to 20 years in prison

White’s murder trial also invoked the name of another man, Michael Schullerman, whom she was dating when Tyrael died.

Police originally charged White and Schullerman with killing the boy and taking out several credit cards in the dead boy’s name by falsifying information.

About two months ago, Schullerman pleaded guilty to about a dozen charges — but not the murder counts.


READMan gets life again for beating Cobb girlfriend to death with hammer


He was sentenced to serve 20 years in prison on a racketeering charge, which White also faces, for financial fraud. That fraud, according to the indictment, involves not notifying Social Security of the boy’s death in order to continue getting benefits.

Beginning in opening arguments, defense attorney Bryan Lumpkin indicated that Schullerman was involved in what happened the night Tyrael died.

But it doesn’t matter.

The defense rested its case Wednesday. Only closing arguments and jury deliberation are left between White and her sentencing.

Read previous coverage of the case here.


Like Cobb County News Now on Facebook | Follow on Twitter


In other news...


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Big changes for metro Atlanta schools, opening soon
Big changes for metro Atlanta schools, opening soon

More than 800,000 students will return to schools in metro Atlanta by early August, and they and their parents will see some changes, as will anyone who uses the roadways or pays taxes. Seventeen school districts in the metro area will be open by Aug. 8, with most of them starting the week before that. >>See when school districts re-open New...
D.C. restaurant manager dies after being shot at Atlanta country club
D.C. restaurant manager dies after being shot at Atlanta country club

The general manager of several restaurants in the D.C. area died Friday after being shot nearly two weeks ago at a wedding reception at an Atlanta country club, Atlanta police confirm. Christian Broder, 34, was the general manager of Millie’s Spring Valley, a well-known California Baja-style restaurant, and several others, according...
Buckhead country club allegedly hid 2 restaurants from health department
Buckhead country club allegedly hid 2 restaurants from health department

A whistleblower accused a Buckhead country club of hiding two restaurants from the health department, Channel 2 Action News reported. A former employee of the Capital City Country Club, who asked to remain anonymous, told Channel 2 he was fired after complaining to managers about being asked to hide from health inspectors. “They hurriedly...
19-year-old killed in single-vehicle crash on Ga. 400, police say
19-year-old killed in single-vehicle crash on Ga. 400, police say

A young man died in a car accident late Friday night on Ga. 400, Sandy Springs police said. Seth Wheeler, 19, of Marietta, allegedly lost control of the 1998 Ford Explorer he was driving and wrecked near the southbound exit to I-285 west, Sandy Springs police Capt. Forrest Bohannon told Channel 2 Action News. 19-year-old passenger John Carpenter, of...
9 members of one family among 17 killed in duck boat accident on lake in Branson, Missouri 
9 members of one family among 17 killed in duck boat accident on lake in Branson, Missouri 

A duck boat accident on Table Rock Lake in Branson, Missouri, killed 17 people Thursday night, including the boat’s driver and nine members of an Indiana family, according to authorities. Fourteen other people were injured. >> Read more trending news  Update 8:45 a.m. EDT July 21: The Stone County coroner confirmed to KSDK...
More Stories