Ex-chiefs offer option in defense of Georgia judicial watchdog


Two former directors of the state agency that investigates judges defended the Judicial Qualifications Commission before a key legislative committee Thursday, but they also conceded there was room for improvement.

Voters are being asked in November to give the Legislature power over the JQC in a move critics call a political power grab. The committee was set up to consider ways to reincarnate the agency that investigates allegations of unethical behavior in the state’s judiciary.

The JQC has won praise for its handling of judicial investigations in the past, but lawmakers began proposing changes after several judges were forced off the bench. More than five dozen have lost their jobs since 2007.

One of the co-sponsors of the bills proposing the change, state Rep. Johnnie Caldwell Jr., R-Thomaston, was among the judges the JQC investigated. Caldwell resigned from the Griffin Judicial Circuit in 2010 after being accused of making rude, sexually suggestive comments to a female attorney.

Under the measure before voters in November, two of the three appointments the State Bar of Georgia now has to the JQC would go to the Legislature, and the governor would get the other one. Some critics have said that House Speaker David Ralston, R-Blue Ridge, backed the change because it would ding the State Bar, where he has had a complaint pending against him for two years.

State Rep. Wendell Willard, R-Sandy Springs, the chairman of the House Special Study Committee on Judicial Qualifications Commission Reform, said Thursday that “we’re not trying to destroy the commission.”

But Willard, a lawyer, said the Legislature needs some control over the seven JQC members. Currently, the Georgia Supreme Court, the governor and the State Bar of Georgia make the appointments. Lawmakers said it was dangerous to not have legislative oversight.

Willard said the JQC takes complaints, investigates them, decides whether there is any wrongdoing and then determines punishment for judges if it finds they have behaved unethically. Punishment can range from a private letter chastising the errant judge to removal from the bench.

“The JQC is serving as prosecutor, jury and the judge,” Willard said. “Surely this raises questions of fairness and impartiality.”

Former Executive Directors Ronnie Joe Lane and Jeff Davis suggested the agency be split in two, with one group investigating complaints and a separate one using those investigations to determine whether there is wrongdoing and what punishment should be meted out.

Cartersville attorney and former JQC Chairman Lester Tate said lawmakers merely reacted to griping from judges and former judges who don’t like the panel’s independence

“What you have here are judges who have complained to their legislators,” said Tate, who resigned from the commission earlier this year over the issue.

Tate, whose conduct was questioned during the legislative meeting, said lawmakers are asking voters to give them control of the JQC.

“It’s not supposed to be a system where judges tight with legislators get a pass,” he said.

The most recent JQC executive director, Mark Dehler, refused to appear before the committee, writing in a five-page letter to Willard that he had “no interest in being a part of your ploy.”

Dehler, who resigned last month, said he feared committee members would use the opportunity to critique his job performance.

“I do not have faith that the special study committee genuinely has an honest interest in trying to solve a problem,” Dehler wrote. “Instead, I believe that the special study committee is really trying to find ways to make the JQC look bad in order to justify what the General Assembly, at the urging of you and others, has already done — setting the stage to dismantle a constitutionally created judicial branch agency.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Indiana man's casket discovered missing from gravesite after wife's death
Indiana man's casket discovered missing from gravesite after wife's death

An Indiana woman is angry after learning her father’s casket is missing from his gravesite, WISH reported. Mary Helen Samson Bovenschen died Feb. 18 at the age of 88. She was to buried next to her husband, Charles Bovenschen, who died Nov. 4, 2006 at age 80. But the couple’s daughter, Sandi Vasel, was stunned when speaking...
Proposed bill in California would provide a choice in driver's license photos
Proposed bill in California would provide a choice in driver's license photos

Have you ever met anyone who liked their driver’s license photo?  Of course not.  Photos on driver’s licenses always seem to show a person at his or her worst, but a bill proposed in the California state legislature would give drivers a choice, KABC reported. The bill would allow drivers to have multiple photos taken...
Teen admits to killing Tennessee couple, setting apartment on fire
Teen admits to killing Tennessee couple, setting apartment on fire

A Tennessee man was arrested in connection with the deaths of a Memphis couple who was found dead in an apartment that caught fire Thursday afternoon. Aareon Berryman, 18, was charged with two counts of first-degree murder, especially aggravated robbery, aggravated arson, possession of marijuana with the intent to manufacture or sell, and possession...
Convicted murderer mistakenly released from jail 
Convicted murderer mistakenly released from jail 

The Georgia jail that mistakenly released a convicted murderer said no one will be disciplined for what happened. The DeKalb County Sheriff's Office realized a mistake was made after the murder victim's family saw the murderer on the streets. "Sounds like somebody didn't relay the right information or didn't look," one DeKalb County...
DeKalb County restaurant inspection scores

DeKalb County • American Deli, 225 E. Ponce De Leon Ave., Decatur. 87/B • Coyote’s Mexican Grill, 105 Sycamore Place, Decatur. 94/A • Las Brasas, 614 Church St., Decatur. 70/C • Raymok Bar and Grill, 3420 E. Ponce De Leon, Scottdale. 85/B • Skip’s, 48 N. Avondale Road, Avondale Estates. 91/A
More Stories