‘Breakdown’ S06, Ep. 2: Voice of a killer?


Atlanta homicide Detective Scott Berhalter had been working the double-murder case for weeks.

Reginald “Reggie” Coicou, 24, and Quincy “Fat” Wytche, 22, were shot to death outside a northwest Atlanta Burger King in April 2016. They had been sitting in a car with two other men, apparently to transact a drug deal, when the man in the back passenger seat suddenly opened fire with a .40-caliber handgun.

Coicou was shot six times at very close range and died where he sat; Wytche was hit a total of three times and died on the way to the hospital.

» Episode 1 and earlier seasons of ‘Breakdown’ 

» Photos: Images from Season 6 of ‘Breakdown’

In this sixth season of our Breakdown podcast, AJC Editor-in-Chief Kevin Riley details Berhalter’s pursuit of the man he believes to be the killer. The latest episode went live early Monday. In it, Riley also reveals how the top editor at a major metropolitan newspaper came to be so closely involved in a murder case.

Berhalter knew the identities of the two dead men. He also knew the name of the car’s driver, who bolted from the vehicle when the shooting started and began running up I-285. Carlton Redding was captured on the Perimeter Highway after a police car ran into him, and Berhalter was able to interview him shortly after Redding was taken into custody. But the detective didn’t have an ID on the fourth man, the shooter. After the shootings, that fourth man had jumped into another car at the Burger King and driven away. (Read the indictment below.)

But cellphone records and video surveillance gave Berhalter the first clues to the suspect’s identity.

Episode 2 includes audio of the detective’s first contact with the suspect – and his mother. The Q&A session took place in the mom’s living room.

AJC legal affairs writer Bill Rankin joins Riley on “Breakdown: A Jury of His Peers.” You can download it today on iTunes, Stitcher or your favorite podcasting player. Or you can stream it right here, right now.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION: Join the Breakdown Podcast Facebook group for more AJC coverage and behind-the-scenes looks at previous Breakdown seasons.

Read the indictment



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Gwinnett weekend weather & events: Storms, wind possible
Gwinnett weekend weather & events: Storms, wind possible

It’s going to be a rainy weekend, according to Channel 2 Action News meteorologists. A system bringing isolated storms to metro Atlanta is moving in Friday afternoon and staying put all weekend, says meteorologist Karen Minton. Those storms have the potential to bring hail and winds between 40 and 60 miles per hour. Prepare for the wet weekend...
5 indicted for arson after posting video on social media, prosecutors say
5 indicted for arson after posting video on social media, prosecutors say

Five metro Atlanta men accused of arson after prosecutors said they got drunk, set a fire at a vacant home and posted a video of their exploits have been indicted.  The April 19 fire burned the Sharpsburg home to the ground and posed a threat to the surrounding woods, a Coweta County fire official said. Prosecutors accused the men of walking...
Woman hits 3 vehicles on busy Peachtree Street following chase, GSP says
Woman hits 3 vehicles on busy Peachtree Street following chase, GSP says

A woman pulled over by Capitol police Friday morning led authorities on a chase through East Point and downtown Atlanta before hitting three vehicles on busy Peachtree Street, the Georgia State Patrol said. Authorities initially stopped Ashlea Baumann, 38, of Snellville, about 9 a.m. on Northside Drive near Markham Street for a tag infraction, according...
CrossRoadsNews delivers final print edition to south DeKalb
CrossRoadsNews delivers final print edition to south DeKalb

Today is the last day the CrossRoadsNews newspaper will be dropped off at locations across south DeKalb County. The paper’s publisher recently decided to cut costs by ending the printed edition and going online only. “It was a good run, but our time is up,” read the headline on a post by editor and publisher Jennifer Parker ...
Milton’s Peyton Barber set to start at running back for Buccaneers
Milton’s Peyton Barber set to start at running back for Buccaneers

A native of north Fulton County is set to get the bulk of carries at running back for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers this season. Earlier this week, Tampa head coach Dirk Koetter identified Peyton Barber, a Milton High School graduate, as the Buccaneers starting running back. A third-year back out of Auburn, Peyton carried the ball four times in the Bucs&rsquo...
More Stories