'Breakdown’ S02 Ep. 5: A jury of his peers, with some preconceived notions


We’re still in the throes of jury selection in the Justin Ross Harris hot-car murder case, although it appears to be slogging toward a conclusion.

In this phase, Cobb Superior Court Judge Mary Staley is qualifying a large panel of prospective jurors – a panel from which the final 12 and some alternates will be selected. Staley hasn’t said how many alternates she wants, and the number will affect how much longer jury selection will take.

Among those citizens qualified already, nearly a third have expressed the view that Harris is guilty. Several of them, but not all, said they could set aside their opinions and impartially evaluate the evidence laid before them.

The question, ultimately, is whether they really can, whether Harris can receive a fair trial from a jury on which some members admitted to a bias against Harris at the outset. The judge obviously believes that he can. Lead defense attorney Maddox Kilgore seems to have his doubts.

While arguing one of his challenges, he declared, his voice rising higher and higher: “We’re actually arguing over somebody who’s sat right there and said, ‘I think he’s guilty. I’m not impartial. I did not presume he’s innocent.’”

But a presumption of innocence is sometimes proving elusive among the prospective jurors in the Harris case.  


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

21-year-old ID’d who shot self after 5-hour SWAT standoff in DeKalb, police say
21-year-old ID’d who shot self after 5-hour SWAT standoff in DeKalb, police say

Police have identified the man they said took place in a five-hour SWAT standoff Friday night in a DeKalb neighborhood, Channel 2 Action News reported. Blake Howell, 21, allegedly barricaded himself in a home in the 600 block of Valley Brook Road, police told Channel. After about five hours, he allegedly shot himself in the chest and is now in stable...
Police: Driver shot multiple times in aggressive driving incident in Atlanta
Police: Driver shot multiple times in aggressive driving incident in Atlanta

A driver was shot multiple times in the leg Saturday morning after an alleged aggressive driving incident in south Atlanta, police confirmed. Atlanta police responded to the 300 block of Cleveland Street and determined that a man was shot in his car after engaging with other people in another car over aggressive driving, Channel 2 Action News reported...
Atlanta man shot, killed in Pittsburgh, police say
Atlanta man shot, killed in Pittsburgh, police say

An Atlanta man died Thursday after being shot earlier this week in Pennsylvania, authorities confirmed. Antwon Jones, 36, was shot early Monday morning in the Bedford Dwellings section of Pittsburgh’s Hill District, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported. Lamont Pendleton, 40, of the Hill District, was arrested after a brief chase by a Pittsburth...
Reports: Ruptured gas line causes coffee shop blast in South Ga., injuring 3
Reports: Ruptured gas line causes coffee shop blast in South Ga., injuring 3

An explosion destroyed a coffee shop and seriously injured three people in South Georgia Friday, authorities confirmed. Investigators determined a nearby construction crew installing fiber optic cable ruptured an underground gas line, causing natural gas to leak into a sewer line connected to the coffee shop, Glenn Allen, Georgia Insurance and...
Duke University says Robert E. Lee statue won't return to chapel entrance
Duke University says Robert E. Lee statue won't return to chapel entrance

Duke University announced the spot where a statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee once stood will remain empty.  >> Read more trending news  A year ago on Aug. 19, crews removed the statue from the iconic chapel entrance. The removal came several days after the statue was defaced in the wake of the protests that turned violent...
More Stories