‘Breakdown’ S05, Ep. 9: The Pilloried Policeman


The Tex McIver murder trial returns from spring break this week. Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney told the jury before the break that prosecutor Clint Rucker still has witnesses to call, and he has already called more than 60.

The judge didn’t sound thrilled.

“Mr. Rucker and his team have helped me understand there are not a whole lot of witnesses left,” McBurney said. “I don’t think there are that many people left in the world.

» Join the Breakdown Facebook group

The AJC’s podcast, “Breakdown: The McIver Murder Case,” will post Episode 9 early Monday. Although the judge is looking forward, Episode 9 looks back – at the rough treatment of an Atlanta homicide detective by the prosecution. And it details some fireworks between the defense and Judge McBurney.

Detective Darrin Smith, who investigated the death of Diane McIver, concluded that the shooting was an accident. The district attorney, however, decided that Tex McIver intended to kill his wife. As the final witness before the break, Smith was compelled to answer for all the questions he didn’t ask, all the steps he didn’t take in his investigation.

Normally, the district attorney and the police department are allies, working together to win a conviction. Not in this case.

Defense attorney Bruce Harvey took Detective Smith through a lengthy cross-examination in which Harvey tried his best to rehabilitate the witness. But then Harvey stopped asking questions and just started making statements.

“You know what he’s saying,“ Harvey said of prosecutor Rucker. “He’s saying you did a crummy job. That’s what he’s saying. You didn’t investigate it right. So I’m going through these things because you did investigate it right, didn’t you?”

Rucker objects. McBurney tells the witness, “So, don’t answer that question.”

Then the judge addresses Harvey: “If you want to ask a question, then let’s do that. That’s not an appropriate question. I invite you to continue your thorough and sifting cross-examination.”

» Past episodes of the Breakdown podcast

Later, in response to an exchange that was not on the tape of the proceedings, McBurney instructed Harvey, “And don’t call me your worship again.”

Episode 9, “The Pilloried Policeman,” will go live early Monday on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher or your favorite podcast platform. Or you can stream it right here, right now:



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Alpharetta officer injured during ‘high-speed’ chase; suspect held
Alpharetta officer injured during ‘high-speed’ chase; suspect held

An Alpharetta officer was injured in a crash overnight during a “high speed pursuit,” police said. The officer was treated for minor injuries at a hospital and released, according to a statement. Nearby agencies also were involved in the chase for a driver believed to be DUI,  according to a Facebook post. “The suspect is...
ICYMI: Three big stories that metro Atlantans were checking out this week
ICYMI: Three big stories that metro Atlantans were checking out this week

A GRAND LADY’S TIES TO GEORGIA: Former first lady Barbara Bush died at age 92 on Tuesday at her home in Houston, Texas. The Bush family matriarch — wife of a president and mother of a subsequent president — had been hospitalized numerous times while battling congestive heart failure and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease...
Trump rips New York Times reporter, defends Cohen
Trump rips New York Times reporter, defends Cohen

President Donald Trump came out swinging on Twitter Saturday morning, firing off three tweets attacking The New York Times and reporter Maggie Haberman. A story published Friday in the Times -- written by Haberman, Sharon LaFraniere and Danny Hakim -- suggested that Trump’s personal attorney, Michael Cohen might cooperate with federal...
Clear day, then clouds; rain later in weekend
Clear day, then clouds; rain later in weekend

Today: Sunny to partly cloudy. High: 72 Tonight: Cloudy. Low: 54 Tomorrow: Showers turning to steady rain. High: 64 Metro Atlanta is in for another weekend of mixed weather. Saturday should feature enjoyable spring conditions, but things will begin changing later in the day. Then, well, keep the rain gear handy, according to Channel 2 Action...
Queen Elizabeth turns 92: 5 fun facts
Queen Elizabeth turns 92: 5 fun facts

Queen Elizabeth II turned 92 on Saturday, and after 65 years on the throne, she holds the distinction of ruling longer than any monarch in the United Kingdom’s history.  The queen actually celebrates two birthdays each year: her actual birthday, which is April 21; and one in June when she hosts a parade -- weather permitting -- called &ldquo...
More Stories