Legal defense for Atlanta judge’s ethics case improper, city says

Atlanta City Attorney Nina Hickson has fired the lawyer representing municipal court Judge Terrinee Gundy, arguing in a letter that the more than $30,000 the city has paid for Gundy’s legal representation in a Georgia Judicial Qualifications Commission investigation is improper under state law.

Now Atlanta City Council President Felicia Moore is calling on Gundy to repay what the city spent on her legal fees.

“It is a personal issue, and I think the council should inquire or, if nothing else, request respectfully that because it is a personal matter that the city be reimbursed for those legal fees,” Moore told Channel 2 Action News this week.

The Georgia Judicial Qualifications Commission can discipline or remove judges it finds have committed ethical breaches in the judiciary.

The commission is looking into complaints about Gundy being late or absent in her courtroom, and also for questionable spending.

On July 12, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution and Channel 2 reported that Gundy spent more than $9,000 on gifts, a charitable fundraiser hosted by former Mayor Kasim Reed and luxurious stationery, including gold-seal letterhead.

The money, which had been budgeted for Gundy’s courtroom, paid for three “flame of excellence” sculptures made of glass that cost a combined $1,800, one of which was specially engraved with Reed’s name; engraved envelopes and other stationery at a cost of $4,156; and $870 in beverage napkins for a party after Reed’s annual Masked Ball.

Reed appointed Gundy to the bench in 2013.

Former Atlanta City Attorney Jeremy Berry, who left the city in June, authorized attorney Frank Strickland to work on Gundy’s behalf, though in a manner that appeared intended to keep the work out of the public eye.

Berry’s March 28 letter of engagement with Strickland did not mention Gundy by name. It said Strickland was being hired at $600 an hour, “In the matter of a Judge.”

Strickland’s legal bills refer to work reviewing JQC documents, and meeting with JQC executive director Benjamin F. Easterlin IV.

The AJC and Channel 2 reported that taxpayers were paying for Gundy’s legal defense in the July 12 story about her spending.

In a letter to Strickland dated July 24, Hickson, who replaced Berry, wrote that “upon receipt of this correspondence, the City of Atlanta rescinds its engagement of you and your firm to represent Judge Terrinee Gundy in the investigation by the Georgia Judicial Ethics Commission.”

Hickson wrote that Georgia law only allows the city to pay for employees’ legal representation in civil matters where they may be liable for monetary damages.

Investigations by the Judicial Ethics Commission are regulatory matters that could potentially become criminal matters depending on the commission’s findings.

“In my opinion,” Hickson wrote, “your continued engagement in the matter before the Judicial Qualifications Commission is not a proper expenditure.”

In the same letter, Hickson asked Strickland to submit a final statement for any work for which the city had not yet received an invoice.

A city spokesperson said the city has yet to determine if it will pay the invoice when it comes in.

Strickland did not immediately respond to phone and email messages seeking comment. Gundy also did not respond to a message seeking comment.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Truck hit by train after getting stuck on tracks outside Vinings restaurant
Truck hit by train after getting stuck on tracks outside Vinings restaurant

A pickup truck was hit by a train outside a train-themed restaurant in Vinings Tuesday evening, police confirmed. The truck’s driver got his vehicle stuck on the railroad track in the parking lot of Orient Express at 2921 Paces Ferry Road, Cobb County police spokesman Wayne Delk told Orient Express is a Chinese, sushi and hibachi...
Carjacking in NW Atlanta prompts police chase that injures bicyclist
Carjacking in NW Atlanta prompts police chase that injures bicyclist

One person is in custody and one is on the run in northwest Atlanta after a police chase that left a bicyclist injured Tuesday night, authorities said. Two men are accused of carjacking someone near Spring Street and 10th Street, prompting a brief chase with police, Atlanta police spokeswoman Stephanie Brown said. At some point during the chase, a...
DeKalb voters complain of election issues as county certifies votes
DeKalb voters complain of election issues as county certifies votes

In less than 30 minutes Tuesday afternoon, the DeKalb County Elections Board certified its midterm election results, touted their hard work and listened to questions and complaints from residents about the election process. But hours after the meeting, a “technical glitch” prevented the certified numbers from being posted to the ...
Amazon headquarters decision: It’s not Atlanta
Amazon headquarters decision: It’s not Atlanta

In the end, Georgia didn’t convince Amazon that Atlanta is the best location for its second headquarters. Or even the second best. The Seattle-based tech giant made it official Tuesday, announcing that it will split its proposed $5 billion HQ2 project into two operations. One will be in New York’s Long Island City in Queens and the other...
Atlanta eyes regulation of booming electric scooter business
Atlanta eyes regulation of booming electric scooter business

To supporters, they’re an inventive, convenient way to get around the city without much of a carbon footprint. To critics, they’re critters that litter Atlanta’s sidewalks, posing a danger to pedestrians, drivers and the people who use them. Love ‘em or hate ‘em, those dockless scooters that popped up around Atlanta...
More Stories