Fate of Plant Vogtle could be decided by the end of next week


The fate of Georgia’s nuclear power plant Vogtle could be known as early as Dec. 21 when the Public Service Commission decides whether to allow construction or suspend it.

The decision to change the date follows letter exchanges last week between Georgia Power CEO Paul Bowers and Georgia Public Service Commission chair Stan Wise, in the wake of proposed tax reforms in Congress.

VIDEO: Previous coverage on this issue

The proposed changes would reduce the corporate tax rates from 35% to 20%. Tax benefits from the current tax rate are higher than the proposed rate.

Georgia Power hoped a quicker decision by the commission would allow the company to utilize the benefits of the current tax rate before they expire.

The commission had initially set the decision for February 28th.

The announcement was made at the beginning of hearings in which staff appointed by the commission to monitor progress of Vogtle presented the scope of their findings to commissioners.

The analysts told commissioners they were not calling for the cancelation of the project, but made recommendations to modify some of the proposed conditions set by Georgia Power. The staff recommended the commission only approve $44 million of the $542 million Georgia Power had asked.Staff said the remaining $498 million covering liens and other costs owed to Westinghouse should not be passed on to ratepayers.

Based on their conclusions, staff maintained Georgia power had not actively managed the project well, resulting in repeated schedule delays and increases in costs. They blamed the “licensee of the project,” Southern Nuclear company for the flaws, as they failed to properly manage the project.

Giving his testimony, independent monitor William Jacobs said Westinghouse Electric Company, which was lead contractor from project inception was rarely held accountable.

If the company had properly managed the contractor, the problems surfacing now would have been dealt with years ago, staff said.

In March, Westinghouse filed for bankruptcy citing losses from Vogtle and South Carolina’s V.C Summer project. A change of the projects lead contractor from Westinghouse Electric Company to Southern Nuclear and construction management from Fluor Corporation to Bechtel this year has resulted in progress at the plant, the analysts said.

But without a realistic schedule, the fate of Vogtle has been riddled with uncertainty placing the project in “significant risk, which the company is not willing to accept for itself,” analysts said in their written testimony.

According to the testimony, staff had since 2012 pointed to the lack of a detailed project schedule. Staff told commissioners Monday that a schedule was completed last month, but they had not seen a copy of it. Jacobs said the copy would be released to on the 20th, a day before the commission decides on Vogtle.

The staff said Westinghouse failed to provide complete schedules prior to construction. According to the latest testimony, project design is still not complete.

Lead analysts Stephen Roetger said he was not sure the design would be complete until the project was done. He pointed out that their concern was the quality of the design which could look good on paper, but difficult to implement.

According to their written testimony, Vogtle has had 12,296 design changes since inception. Staffers said some changes were necessary, but others resulted from “[un]constructible or otherwise deficient” original designs.

The analysts told commissioners they were not aware of the decision by Toshiba to pay off the rest of the $3.7 billion of their parent guarantee while preparing their report. Roetger, however told commissioners the decision reached at last week had no impact on their testimony.

With Toshiba agreeing to a speedy payoff of the parent guarantee last week, the Tokyo based electronics giant is absolved from liability in case the reactors don’t function as expected. Westinghouse’s bankruptcy in March led to the cancellation of the Engineering, Procurement and Construction agreement, which protected ratepayers from risks associated with cost overruns. The risks now transferred to Georgia Power could ultimately become the ratepayer’s problem. The analysts, in their testimony, called on commissioners to consider that risk.

Testimony resumes Tuesday.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

North Georgia woman charged with statutory rape, child molestation
North Georgia woman charged with statutory rape, child molestation

A Lumpkin County woman was arrested Tuesday for allegedly having a sexual relationship with an underage boy, authorities said. Erica Christine McDaniel, 32, is charged with two counts of child molestation and two counts of statutory rape, the Lumpkin County Sheriff’s Office said in a news release. Investigators said there were multiple incidents...
Darlington received nearly 40 code violations in 5 years, records show
Darlington received nearly 40 code violations in 5 years, records show

When a code complaint regarding no hot water in a fourth floor unit was filed with Atlanta police on Thursday, it became the 24th complaint about The Darlington Apartments since April 2017.  Residents of the Darlington, one of the few apartment buildings in the area affordable for low-income residents, were notified in mid-August that they...
BREAKING: Second teen arrested in connection with Atlanta charity worker’s death
BREAKING: Second teen arrested in connection with Atlanta charity worker’s death

A second teenager has been arrested in connection with the death of an Atlanta grandmother who was shot and killed while driving home from her job at a center for homeless mothers, police said. Khalid Bays, 18, turned himself in to Atlanta police Friday, police spokeswoman Stephanie Brown said in a news release. Another 18-year-old suspect, Adarius...
Georgia Uber driver accused of stabbing 2 customers
Georgia Uber driver accused of stabbing 2 customers

An Uber driver is accused of stabbing two of her customers Sunday in east Georgia, the Augusta Chronicle reported. Shaunisha Danielle Brown, 29, of Augusta, faces two counts of aggravated assault, the newspaper reported. She’s accused of stabbing two people in the 5000 block of Reynolds Way, according to a Grovetown police incident report...
$3M home in Historic Brookhaven has ‘breathtaking view’ of golf course 
$3M home in Historic Brookhaven has ‘breathtaking view’ of golf course 

Described as one of Historic Brookhaven’s loveliest homes, residents can purchase it for $3.1 million, according to Zillow.  The six-year-old home, located on 4000 East Brookhaven Drive, has been on the market since Sept. 11.  Perched near the Brookhaven County Club, the five-bedroom home boasts a “breathtaking view&rdquo...
More Stories