DeKalb commissioners approve payout after police shooting, jail death


The families of two men whose deaths were blamed in part on shortcomings with DeKalb County law enforcement will receive six-figure settlements to end years of litigation, according to court documents obtained by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

The DeKalb Board of Commissioners agreed to pay $475,000 to the wife and children of Dirk Smith, who filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the county, then Police Chief William O’Brien and the officers who shot and killed Smith in 2010.

VIDEO: In other DeKalb police news

The commission also agreed to pay out $187,500 to the estate of Godfrey Cook, who was killed inside the DeKalb County jail in 2009. Saleevan Adan was already facing a murder charge when he attacked Cook.

County officials said no one was available Thursday to confirm the settlements had been finalized and both cases closed.

Smith was killed in his Lithonia home after he barricaded himself in a bathroom and refused to follow orders to drop a kitchen knife. Before being shot by police, he was also tased twice.

The incident occurred after Smith arrived home early from vacation in Las Vegas after arguing with his wife, Estelle. The house-sitter refused to let him inside, so Smith broke a glass door and then used a knife to open locked bedroom doors. Estelle Smith told the house-sitter to call police and later told officers she wanted her husband to get help because he was under emotional stress.

Smith was shot after charging out of a bathroom closet where he had been hiding. Officers testified that he had the knife raised and was slashing it around, but his son who was present for the ordeal and photo evidence cast doubt on their explanation.

The district attorney cleared the officers of criminal wrongdoing, but Estelle Smith filed suit in federal court in 2012 accusing police of entering the home without a warrant, using excessive force on her husband and improperly firing their guns to kill him.

A federal appeals court ruled in 2016 that police were justified in entering the home but that the different versions of what preceded the shooting warranted a jury trial. Instead, both sides decided to go into mediation that resulted in the settlement DeKalb commissioners approved on June 28.

Adan has been transferred from a state mental health hospital to the jail after being deemed competent to stand trial, but judge then reversed that decision. Delays in paperwork kept Adan at the jail long enough for a lethal interaction with Cook inside a jail cell.

After Cook’s death, Adan was sent to Central State Hospital where he killed again.

Cook’s estate sued the county, Sheriff Thomas Brown and several correctional officers, saying neglectful behavior and failure to follow policy contributed to his death. Courts eventually ruled that the sheriff had done nothing wrong, although other parts of the case were allowed to proceed.

A Fulton County State Court judge wrote that evidence against two correctional officers indicated they failed to take precautions that could have prevented Cook’s death and therefore could qualify for punitive damages. The case was ordered to jury trial, which was scheduled for this week.

The Board of Commissioners said both lawsuits will be dismissed as a result of these settlements, and the plaintiffs agreed not to pursue additional action against the county.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Does your pup have the chops to be Piedmont Park’s Dog of the Year?
Does your pup have the chops to be Piedmont Park’s Dog of the Year?

When people see your dog, do they say “woof” — not in a playful way, but how people do when something is particularly awful or repulsive? No? Then you might want to consider entering this contest.   The Piedmont Park Conservancy’s second Dog of the Year Contest is once again welcoming submissions. ...
Tex-Mex joint near Perimeter Mall fails health check
Tex-Mex joint near Perimeter Mall fails health check

A Tex-Mex chain eatery near Perimeter Mall failed its recent inspection, according to Georgia health department records.  Chuy’s, 118 Perimeter Center West, scored a 65 on Monday. Any score below a 70 is considered failing.  A manager declined to comment to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution on Tuesday.  The inspector noted employees...
Cellphone of missing teen found at site of Rainbow Family gathering
Cellphone of missing teen found at site of Rainbow Family gathering

Another missing person has been connected to the recent Rainbow Family counterculture gathering in North Georgia. William Johnson, 18, has been reported missing by the Lumpkin County Sheriff’s Office, according to a Facebook post. “His cellphone was found in the Chattahoochee-Oconee National Forest in the trash where the recent Rainbow...
Johns Creek police: With stolen info, man bought $29K in gift cards
Johns Creek police: With stolen info, man bought $29K in gift cards

Police in Johns Creek are searching for a man who they say bought $29,000 worth of Home Depot gift cards using a stolen credit card. The theft occurred in early April, but police put a BOLO out on the suspect on Monday. He is shown in surveillance footage as having short hair, wearing a long-sleeved shirt and blue jeans. READ | Civil War: In 1864...
Man tried to hire hitman to kill Cobb ex-wife for $10K, Hawks tickets
Man tried to hire hitman to kill Cobb ex-wife for $10K, Hawks tickets

An Acworth inmate promised $10,000 and two Atlanta Hawks tickets to anyone who could kill his ex-wife and her current boyfriend. Word got around, including to an FBI informant. Michael Lawrence Dane McEarchern, 29, was sentenced to 10 years in prison Monday, according to federal court documents. McEarchern was in Bartow County jail during October on...
More Stories