Snow days don’t mean extra days later for most metro students


Most students in metro Atlanta have missed a week or more of classroom time due to weather this school year, but few have to make up any of it.

Nearly every school district has a waiver from the state requirement of a minimum of 180 classroom days. And some, including Gwinnett and Forsyth counties, are keeping their students on track with the internet.

“We have online learning days so we don’t have inclement weather days built into the calendar,” said Jennifer Carracciolo, spokeswoman for Forsyth County Schools.

Like most, Forsyth missed school for Tropical Storm Irma, a weather scare last week and the snowstorm this week. The district kept kids learning online most of those days, but even if Forsyth falls behind, it won’t have to make up any days.

Forsyth and most other districts can get around the instruction time requirement with so-called “flexibility” contracts. All but two of Georgia’s 180 districts have them, and most of the contracts contain a calendar waiver.

The flexibility contracts allow exemption from many state rules in exchange for reaching goals on state tests and other measures.

Gwinnett County Public Schools’ contract doesn’t contain a calendar waiver, but that could change soon. The district petitioned the Georgia Board of Education last week to add a calendar waiver, and it’s to be considered next month. The Cobb County School District successfully petitioned for the waiver in the fall.

Randy Scamihorn, a Cobb school board member, said, “Any time the state can give you that flexibility, most people, I think, would want to have it.” It means the district won’t have to make up any of the seven days that would be missed as of Friday — two for Irma in September, one on Dec. 11 after a snowstorm, one last week for a dire weather forecast that didn’t pan out and three days for this week’s snow.

John Stafford, a Cobb district spokesman, said there has been no talk of making up for the closures, because Cobb’s school days are longer than required. “We’ve got plenty of seat time built in, so we won’t have to make up those days anyway.”

Even the handful of districts without waivers face little pressure to make up days. State law gives every district four missed days for inclement weather that don’t have to be made up, and the state education board can exempt closures on days that were during a state of emergency, as most were this school year.

There are still incentives to make up time, including student performance on the Georgia Milestones tests. Districts are held accountable for the results.

Many build make-up days into their calendars, often in the form of teacher-preparation days scheduled during students’ seasonal breaks. Sloan Roach, a Gwinnett spokeswoman, said her district will make up three of its six missed days with days already built into the calendar. She said the other three don’t have to be made up because, as in Forsyth, students studied online.

A state education department spokeswoman confirmed that online learning days count as regular school days. Also, schools don’t get docked when they close early or open late as long as students attend at least half the day.

DeKalb had several inclement weather days built into its calendar. In late September, school leaders debated reneging on a planned fall break in October, but eventually settled on adding time to the school days through October and November, and sending students to school on Election Day in November.

This time, district officials could choose to eliminate a winter break scheduled in February.

Clayton County Schools officials said make-up days will be discussed after administrators return from snow days.

Fulton County Schools will announce its strategy for making up the instructional time next week, said spokeswoman Donna Lowry.

On Thursday evening, Atlanta called off school for Friday, which means it will have missed seven days.

Earlier, Atlanta Public Schools Superintendent Meria Carstarphen asked parents, via her blog, to weigh in on how best to make up the lost days.

She wrote on her blog that APS’ state charter “DOES NOT require us to make up days. BUT, I am concerned about the significant loss of instructional time we have suffered.”

Some parents feel days should be recouped, regardless of calendar waivers, to avoid chaos when lesson plans get behind, or to keep children competitive with others.

“I already feel we’re behind,” said Kathryn Brown, whose daughter, a kindergartner, attends school in Cobb County. “If she was older, I would be really concerned. I know other districts have ways to make up the time online and Cobb does not. That’s a disadvantage to us.”

DeKalb County parent Lauren Taylor said her second-grader and his classmates were scheduled to undergo assessments before school was canceled. It was a nightmare last year, she said, when the district tried to reschedule winter assessments.

“It’s a double-edged sword,” Taylor said. “Our kids are being denied any kind of education. We don’t have digital learning like some of the other school districts. I want them to make the days up so they don’t have to scramble like they did last year.”

Anything else, she said, “is a disservice to our kids.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Education

Are test scores fair way to judge charter schools or any schools?
Are test scores fair way to judge charter schools or any schools?
School choice and charter school advocates increasingly contend test scores provide a limited snapshot of a school’s effectiveness, maintaining other factors may be more telling, including graduation rates, college attendance and parental satisfaction. They also argue more allowances ought to be made for the characteristics of the students, who...
APS to train students to protect themselves from school shooters
APS to train students to protect themselves from school shooters

Atlanta Public Schools is developing training to teach students how to respond and protect themselves if there is a school shooting. The training will teach students what to do if they are surprised by an attacker, how to respond, and how to use items in the classroom to protect and defend themselves. Superintendent Meria Carstarphen said the district...
APS to get deeds to 7 more properties after city council OKs deed transfers
APS to get deeds to 7 more properties after city council OKs deed transfers

Atlanta City Council on Monday agreed to transfer deeds to seven more properties to Atlanta Public Schools. Council voted Monday to give the school district the deeds to five current and former elementary school sites: Morris Brandon, Humphries, Bethune, E.S.Jackson, and D.H. Stanton, now known as Barack and Michelle Obama Academy; as well as the deeds...
Nominate the best teachers in metro Atlanta
Nominate the best teachers in metro Atlanta

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution is taking nominations for its annual Celebrating Teachers awards. Last year, friends, family, students and co-workers nominated 375 teachers who went above and beyond the call of duty to work with their students and make sure they are successful. Ten teachers from across the metro Atlanta area were chosen...
Georgia online school’s closure means one less option for high-risk students 
Georgia online school’s closure means one less option for high-risk students 

When Georgia’s first online statewide charter high school closes next month, it will leave behind roughly 1,700 students without a diploma— many of whom have struggled in school — and a mixed legacy as an education pioneer that ultimately perished. Graduation Achievement Charter High School failed to meet state academic standards...
More Stories