Lawmakers reveal a new plan for ‘unacceptable’ schools


Georgia lawmakers are trying a new approach on the most intractable problem in public education, three months after voters refused to amend the state constitution so that an appointee of the governor could take over “chronically failing” schools.

Those two words do not appear in House Bill 338, the much anticipated “plan B” that had been on the table since Gov. Nathan Deal vowed to revisit the issue after the decisive defeat of Amendment 1 at the polls in November. Instead, the legislation filed by five Republican co-sponsors and others Friday uses terms like “unacceptable” and “low-performing.”

Though it differs from the failed constitutional amendment in significant ways, there are striking similarities.

As Deal’s Opportunity School District — a central plank of his second term educational agenda — would have done, the new proposal would allow the state to step into the lowest performing schools and replace the staff or even take over the operation and hand it to someone else to run. Under HB 338, though, local dollars allocated to those schools wouldn’t flow to the state, and the schools would not be absorbed into a new state-run district. Instead, they could be turned over to another, “successful,” school district or to a private nonprofit — or the district could be compelled to bus the students to a better-performing school.

“We still have a growing number of schools in the state that are failing to produce adequate results,” said Rep. Christian Coomer, R-Cartersville, explaining why this bill is needed. Coomer is a co-sponsor, along with chief co-sponsor Kevin Tanner, R-Dawsonville.

Coomer also supported Amendment 1, and said this legislation represents an attempt at compromise with school boards, teachers groups and others who opposed the Opportunity School District and have been bending Tanner’s ears. They argued that control over schools should remain under locally elected school boards, and Coomer described this legislation as less invasive and more collaborative with school boards and others.

Even so, it contains some harsh penalties, like giving the governor the authority to suspend school board members in districts where at least half the schools are judged to be under-performing.

“The Georgia School Boards Association is continuing to work with the bill’s author on that provision,” said Angela Palm, the group’s lobbyist.

Chuck Clay, a former state senator who now lobbies for the Georgia Education Coalition, a collection of some of the largest and fastest-growing school districts, said everyone wants to improve schools but that’s about as far as the consensus gets. “Everybody has a slightly different view of how to get there,” he said. Educators contend that poverty is a thread running through failing schools, and that it’s a societal problem that must be unraveled if schools are to succeed. “Most of us know the true problems in schools are much more intractable,” Clay said.

HB 338 seems to acknowledge that. It says the turnaround effort must address community problems, “such as poverty, lack of economic development, safety, transportation options for parents and students, adult educational opportunities, wellness and mental health services … .” It does not say how all this would be paid for, though it does say “state and community resources” should be identified.

The Professional Association of Georgia Educators, the state’s largest teacher advocacy group, was concerned about the lack of a clear funding source, but appreciated Tanner’s decision to include the language about poverty.

“We are pleased to see the bill’s provision for a more robust root-cause analysis of why schools are struggling, including community factors,” said Craig Harper, their spokesman.

The group was troubled, though, by the line of authority over the position that would be created to monitor schools and determine which needed to be improved or even taken over.

The chief turnaround officer would report to the state education board, which is appointed by the governor. The teachers’ group would rather see that person reporting to the state school superintendent, the elected official who oversees the state education department.

Richard Woods, the superintendent, is not taking a position on the bill yet. A spokesman said he will comment eventually, but needs time to review it. “He looks forward to working with the legislature and Gov. Deal on a bill that appropriately addresses improving under-performing schools,” the spokesman said.

Deal’s office said on Twitter that the governor appreciates Tanner’s work on the bill and supports it.

An element that is sure to be the center of debate is the definition of what, exactly, constitutes an “unacceptable” rating or a determination of “low-performing.” Those words are key, since they would trigger the state intervention after two years for schools and after five for school boards. HB 338 does not tie them to any specific measure, such as standardized state tests.

The bill also revisits an older discussion about school accreditation. Currently, schools rely mostly on the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools for accreditation, a non-governmental organization. HB 338 would establish a committee to study the “advantages and disadvantages” of establishing a state accreditation process, “including the resources and structure that would be necessary and any impediments that would need to be addressed.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Education

DeKalb Schools: Sickout’s second day sees more bus drivers delivering students
DeKalb Schools: Sickout’s second day sees more bus drivers delivering students

A sickout staged by DeKalb County School District bus drivers resulted in transportation delays for the second day Friday. About 224 bus drivers were absent Friday, compared to 383 who were absent Thursday, according to an absentee report received by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution from the school system. Andre Riley, a schools spokesman, said there...
APS plans budget, pay hikes amid revenue questions
APS plans budget, pay hikes amid revenue questions

Atlanta Public Schools expects Fulton County residential property values to increase after being frozen at 2016 levels. But school officials are facing major revenue unknowns while creating the budget for the fiscal year that begins July 1 .  The board is scheduled to tentatively adopt the budget May 7 and consider final approval June 4...
DeKalb school bus drivers stage sickout
DeKalb school bus drivers stage sickout

DeKalb County School District Superintendent Steve Green had a stern message for the 400 or so bus drivers who called in sick Thursday: There will be consequences. They found out quickly how severe, with at least a half dozen drivers confirming late Thursday they had been fired for calling out of work, and apparently being vocal about drivers&rsquo...
Student events, walkouts to be smaller than month ago
Student events, walkouts to be smaller than month ago

At Lakeside High School this morning, student activities for a national walkout will center around ways young people can continue having their voice heard, from registering to vote to engaging in conversations on continued activism. The purpose of last month’s walkout was to remember the 17 students and staff members killed at Marjory Stoneman...
19 years later, Columbine massacre echoes in Ga. schools
19 years later, Columbine massacre echoes in Ga. schools

The enhanced security at Atlanta Public Schools’ Daniel McLaughlin Therrell High School for the start of the 1999-2000 school year was nothing to write home about, said Verdaillia Turner, who taught there at the time. School resource officers roamed the halls more frequently. Then there were the metal detectors, at the old building’s main...
More Stories