Experts: Lead testing is no guarantee of safe water in schools


Flora Anthony assumed the drinking water at her son’s Atlanta elementary school was safe.

Then she learned water at Morningside Elementary School, originally built in 1930, had high lead levels, according to school district test results released this week. Morningside was one of 25 Atlanta schools with especially high lead levels in one or more water fountains or sinks tested.

Now she’s terrified—and angry.

“There are people who are supposed to be looking out for the safety and well-being of the children who go to the city schools,” she said. “It’s absolutely insane that they didn’t automatically test when they knew we had pipes that old.”

Even as other states have moved to require school drinking water be tested for lead, no law requires testing in Georgia schools or day care centers.

Atlanta Public Schools decided to test its water fountains and sinks this spring, after news of dangerously high lead levels in Flint, Michigan. No other metro Atlanta school district has tested school water system-wide or announced plans to do so.

Several local school districts said they rely on local water utilities to test drinking water. But those tests are conducted at various sites in the county or service area. They don’t measure the lead levels in water from the fountains or sinks inside schools.

Experts say even voluntary testing and repairs, like those under way in Atlanta, aren’t a guarantee the water students drink is safe.

“You can never say with certainty as long as you have lead plumbing the water is safe,” said Marc Edwards, a Virginia Tech environmental engineering professor who led research uncovering dangerous lead levels in drinking water in Flint and Washington, D.C.

Atlanta school superintendent Meria Carstarphen has repeatedly told parents that water fountains and sinks are “cleared” and safe to use if initial or follow-up tests show lead levels below 15 parts per billion. That’s the level above which water systems, such as Atlanta Watershed, are generally required to try to reduce lead in drinking water under federal law.

That kind of statement is “concerning,” Edwards said. There is no safe level of lead in drinking water, according to the Environmental Protection Agency.

The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that school water fountains not exceed lead concentrations of 1 part per billion. Even low levels of lead in children’s blood can result in behavior and learning problems, lower IQ, slowed growth and other problems, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Through a spokeswoman, Carstarphen declined requests to speak with The Atlanta Journal-Constitution about lead test results.

Results depend heavily on how testing is conducted, Edwards said. How recently a tap was used or how quickly water flows during collection can mean the difference between a shockingly high lead level and a negative result. Atlanta Public Schools has not yet provided a description of the district’s testing methods requested by the AJC under the Georgia Open Records Act.

And a single test can’t prove that a water source is safe.

“I could go into the worst system in the country and test in a way that makes every tap look good,” Edwards said.

Results to date for Atlanta schools show levels above 15 parts per billion in one or more water fountains or sinks in 25 of 60 schools. In total, 39 of the 1,542 school water fountains and sinks tested had levels above 15 parts per billion.

Levels at several schools were as high were as 15 times the federal limit for water systems. High lead levels were also found at some administrative buildings.

Results from all 113 buildings tested are expected later this summer.

The school district is flushing water lines or making repairs at any water fountains or sinks where lead levels top 15 parts per billion and retesting them. District operations chief Larry Hoskins told the AJC last month the district would develop a plan for ongoing testing and repairs.

Flora Anthony took her son, who will return to Morningside as a first-grader next month, to get his lead levels tested. She’s waiting for results. Her whole family is drinking bottled water. And she plans to reach out to local and state officials.

“Why isn’t there a rule?” she asked.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Education

Errors in financial, housing red tape can snarl first day on campus
Errors in financial, housing red tape can snarl first day on campus

The fall semester often begins with familiar complaints from some students and parents on many college campuses. The school didn’t properly process the student’s financial paperwork. The college erred and the student has nowhere to live on campus. This year was no different for some metro Atlanta campuses. More than 150 Clark Atlanta University...
DeKalb Schools: Recent departures highlight administrative turnover
DeKalb Schools: Recent departures highlight administrative turnover

The DeKalb County School District has confirmed in the last two weeks two departures from the superintendent’s staff cabinet, high-ranking officials in charge of key departments. Chief of Staff Ramona Tyson will be stepping into a new role with the school board, according to an announcement during the Sept. 10 DeKalb County Board of Education...
School systems find inexpensive safety alternatives
School systems find inexpensive safety alternatives

Not all aspects of school safety have to be expensive. That’s the message some local schools are sending out as districts across the state and country focus on that topic. Although technology such as cameras and key-card entry systems, and highly trained personnel such as police officers and counselors require a considerable amount of funding...
Schools try to thwart a troubling trend: childhood suicide
Schools try to thwart a troubling trend: childhood suicide

Doris Adhuze saw no signs on April 21, 2017, that her son planned to take his life. Jovany, she said, was a black teen from a two-parent household known for high-fiving friends and teachers, and quietly buying lunch for students who needed one. Still, she found him hanging from a coat hook on his closet door about 10 minutes after the 13-year-old arrived...
Atlanta school board considers goals for 2018-19 year
Atlanta school board considers goals for 2018-19 year

This year will be all about planning for the Atlanta Board of Education. The school board is finalizing its goals for the 2018-2019 year, even though school began Aug. 1. The proposed goals, which the board approved tentatively earlier this  month but  must still approve via a final vote, are:  To develop a user-friendly community...
More Stories