Best way to aid underrepresented students not so clear cut

The alumni association at the high school I graduated from, let’s just say a few years ago, is urging alumni to oppose legislation it considers sacrilegious.

New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio earlier this month announced a plan that would, in part, automatically offer enrollment to the top students in each public middle school in the city’s eight specialized high schools. Hizzoner’s (New York slang for “mayor”) goal is to help more African-American and Latino students, currently underrepresented in those schools, learn in high schools considered the best in the Big Apple and consistently ranked among the nation’s elite.

For decades, the only way to get into one of these high schools was to pass an admissions test. My former high school, Brooklyn Tech, is one of those specialized schools, and the alumni association doesn’t like this proposal.

“This bill not only fails to address the longer term educational challenges facing too many underrepresented communities, but it disturbingly eliminates equal access to the specialized high schools for youngsters from Catholic, Jewish and Muslim middle schools as well as private secular schools, as its primary admissions system is limited to only students attending public schools,” one email says.

Many education leaders on the K-12 level and in higher education have grappled with finding the right formula to provide access to more historically underrepresented students in high-caliber high schools and colleges.

I thought about this dilemma as I recently reported on an article about the ongoing effort of several top-flight Georgia universities, such as Emory, Georgia Tech and the University of Georgia, to improve enrollment rates for another group of underrepresented students: those from rural communities.

About 5 percent of Georgia Tech’s undergraduate students come from what it considers rural Georgia counties. Emory is at 8 percent. UGA is at 15 percent.

Georgia Tech is trying to boost the percentage by offering automatic admissions to valedictorians and salutatorians from each Georgia high school, an initiative it started last year. The effort has made some headway, Tech officials say. However, in about one-quarter of all Georgia counties Georgia Tech did not get a single application from a student.

“It’s incumbent on us to recruit students from that area,” said Rick Clark, Georgia Tech’s director of undergraduate admissions, citing data he’s seen that show rural students are more likely to return to their communities upon graduation.

Georgia Tech started a similar program a few years earlier with Atlanta’s public school system. Clark said it’s resulted in more applications and more APS students enrolled at Georgia Tech.

Clark is taking the long-view approach with rural students. He hopes to get at least one application from each county in the next five years.

About two decades ago, Texas lawmakers started a program that offered admission to any public university in that state to a student who finished in the top 10 percent of his/her high school graduating class. Some state lawmakers have proposed shelving the program. Not all high schools are equal, and the concern is some students from better high schools are ineligible for admission.

The legislation from New York’s mayor has a similar goal to the Texas program.

“Just 10 percent of specialized high school students are Black or Latino, despite making up 70 percent of the City’s overall student population,” the mayor’s office said in a news release.

It’s unclear whether de Blasio’s proposal will become law. It must pass the state’s Legislature, which is often resistant to significant bills from City Hall. Additionally, New York’s governor and mayor are frenemies.

If it does pass, many educators in Georgia and the nation will watch to see how it works.

I’ll be watching too.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Education

Opinion: To teach writing, it helps to see yourself as a writer
Opinion: To teach writing, it helps to see yourself as a writer

One of the joys of my job is reading the wonderful guest columns submitted by teachers. Often, teachers will send me a suggestion for a column. But their notes are so well written, so engaging and so full of passion that I suggest they write the piece instead.  Many do, and those essays are always interesting and authentic.  It is not a surprise...
Ga. Senate committee studying Atlanta’s Emory, CDC annexation
Ga. Senate committee studying Atlanta’s Emory, CDC annexation

State legislators hope to end discord between the DeKalb County School District and Atlanta Public Schools over Atlanta’s annexation plans for Emory University and the Centers for Disease Control. The Senate Study Committee on the Financial Impact of Atlanta Annexation on Schools held its first meeting Thursday. Sen. Emanuel Jones, D-Decatur...
As assessments soar, taxpayers hope for relief from Atlanta Public Schools
As assessments soar, taxpayers hope for relief from Atlanta Public Schools

Some sticker-shocked homeowners are calling for tax relief after seeing their estimated Atlanta Public Schools taxes on the heels of Fulton County property value hikes. Last year, Fulton County froze residential property values at 2016 levels after complaints about big bumps. This year, property values assessed have gone up significantly to reflect...
Former Savannah St. chief violated harassment policy, report finds
Former Savannah St. chief violated harassment policy, report finds

The conduct of Savannah State University’s former police chief with three female officers violated the school’s sexual harassment policy, according to a state investigative reports released Thursday. The officers said they feared retaliation if they told others about his conduct, the reports say. The most serious allegation was that...
Georgia gets mixed grades for college grad rates of black, Latino students
Georgia gets mixed grades for college grad rates of black, Latino students

Georgia received mixed grades from an organization for its efforts to help African-American and Latino students earn college degrees. The Education Trust released a report Thursday that found African-American and Latino adults are less likely to hold a college degree today than white adults were in 1990. While about 47 percent of white adults...
More Stories