Atlanta second-graders’ blackface masks draw outrage, apology


An Atlanta charter school apologized for a black-history program that featured second-graders with masks depicting blackface.

The Kindezi School at Old Fourth Ward said it will provide “cultural competency” training for teachers after parents expressed concern about the Thursday performance, during which children recited Paul Laurence Dunbar’s poem “We Wear the Mask” while holding up masks that looked like minstrel-show makeup. White performers in those 19th-century shows ridiculed blacks through exaggerated dialect, gestures and grotesque face paint.

The school issued a statement Friday to apologize and accept “responsibility for the hurt, anger, frustration and disappointment caused by the poor judgment we made in having students use masks that mimic blackface.”

Kindezi said it is investigating the matter and is committed to making sure “this never happens again.”

A video of the performance posted on Facebook amassed more than 830,000 views in 18 hours. It sparked outrage from around the internet and questions from parents.

“The children have been rehearsing for months, dress rehearsals, staying after school … There’s no way in the world no one saw this. They allowed this to get on stage,” said Ari Lima, a parent who attended the program to watch her third-grade son perform in a different segment of the program.

The live performance was met with very light applause, she said. “You could kind of feel the uncomfortableness in the room.”

Although Black History Month is celebrated in February, the school schedules its performance when it works best for the schedule. This year, that was in March, said Kindezi spokeswoman Elizabeth Sharp Broderick.

The Dunbar poem, published around the start of the 20th century, speaks to pain endured by African-Americans. It begins, “We wear the mask that grins and lies, It hides our cheeks and shades our eyes, This debt we pay to human guile; With torn and bleeding hearts we smile.”

The historical context of blackface as “a tool of oppressors” to poke fun or inflict harm was not part of the children’s presentation, Lima said. She said the performance overlooked the fact that “blackface, of course, is not a black invention” and said it was inappropriate to have white or black students hold the masks without providing additional context.

“I can’t even think of how the teacher may have looked at her white students and thought this was OK to put it in front of their faces,” she said.

White performers wore blackface while acting in minstrel shows beginning around the 1830s in the United States, said Dwandalyn Reece, curator of music and performing arts at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of African American History and Culture. The shows, and the offensive stereotypes they perpetuated, spread through white society.

Kindezi plans to provide teacher education to ensure “staff has a thorough understanding of our shared history regarding race and racism in America, and how to engage in productive conversations with our students and the community.”

The school also plans to speak with students about the “historical context” of the imagery and the poem and planned a parent forum.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Education

Kemp unveils school safety plan
Kemp unveils school safety plan

Georgia Republican gubernatorial candidate Brian Kemp wants to keep the state’s school children safe by wrapping them in a $90 million security blanket. He did not define a specific source of funding to pay for it. The current secretary of state unveiled a plan today that he called a “three prong” approach. Adding a school counselor...
Congrats to schools and parents on rising high school graduation rate
Congrats to schools and parents on rising high school graduation rate

The climb in Georgia’s high school graduation rate reflects two concomitant actions: Schools are working harder to push kids over the finish line, and parents are realizing their children have no future without at least a high school diploma. The Georgia Department of Education announced today the grad rate rose again in 2018, to 81.6 percent...
Three metro Atlanta students among finalists for national science award
Three metro Atlanta students among finalists for national science award

William Jenkins  from The Westminster Schools, Kennedy Rogers from Chapel Hill Middle School in DeKalb County, and Asmi Kumar from Northwestern Middle School in Fulton County have been named among the top young scientists in the country and will compete for more than $100,000 in awards.  William, 14, designed and built an automatic tennis...
DeKalb Schools’ graduation rate increases again
DeKalb Schools’ graduation rate increases again

The DeKalb County School District saw its graduation rate rise another percentage point to 75, surpassing the previous year's 74 percent record rate.  The district’s graduation rate has risen 15.5 percentage points since 2013, including 10.5 points between 2013 and 2015.   The DeKalb Early Career Academy graduated all...
Atlanta high school graduation rate increases, approaches state average
Atlanta high school graduation rate increases, approaches state average

Atlanta Public Schools bumped its graduation rate to 79.9 percent and drew closer to the statewide average, according to data released Wednesday.  The graduation rate for Atlanta’s class of 2018 is 2.9 percentage points higher than the 2017 rate of 77 percent. APS still falls behind the Georgia average of 81.6 percent, but it has narrowed...
More Stories