Fulton judge unlikely to let dad bring guns to children's school events


A Fulton County judge said Tuesday she is unlikely to rule that a Alpharetta father can bring his gun when he attends events at his children’s elementary school, but she would delay ruling until she had done more research on the matter.

Judge Kelly Lee Ellerbe heard James Johnson’s request to allow him to bring his 9 mm Smith and Wesson when he goes to functions at New Prospect Elementary School in Alpharetta, where his 6-year-old daughter and 7-year-old son attend while she considers his lawsuit against the Fulton County school system..

His is one of two lawsuits filed by metro area fathers challenging the state Code Revision Commission’s interpretation of two gun bills passed by the 2014 Legislature and how they interact.

“My inclination is to deny the injunction,” Ellerbe said after the hour-long hearing on the Fulton County suit. “It’s not my final ruling on this case.”

She expected to decide by the end of this week.

Johnson’s lawyer, John Monroe, said the father would suffer “irreparable” harm while the suit is pending because his Second Amendment right would be violated.

Johnson and a second father who filed a similar suit in Gwinnett say they arm themselves in case of confrontation and they wanted to continue to protect themselves and be active in their children’s schools at the same time.

“It’s clearly the overwhelming will of the people,” Monroe said about carrying guns in most places. “It can’t just be thrown away.”

Brandon Moulard, the attorney for the Fulton County school system, said Johnson had not shown he would be damaged if he is restricted to just bringing his gun when when he picks up or drops off his children at school while the suit is pending.

Johnson’s suit raises the same issue that Phillip Evans raised when he also filed a suit in August, saying he wanted to bring a gun when he attends his children’s functions at Centerville Elementary School in Snellville. A third father had sued the Douglas County school system but dropped his case last month when he enrolled his daughter in a private school

The fathers argue that two laws passed this year are in conflict —- House Bill 862 and House Bill 60, which came to be known as the “guns everywhere” law. Even though it restricted guns at schools, it broadened the number of places they were allowed.

HB 862 said licensed gun owners could carry their weapons into a school zone, which includes school property, any time. The bill was passed in February and the law took effect April 21, when the governor signed it.

“The Legislature passed the bill. It has to mean something,” Monroe said in court Tuesday morning.

HB 60, however, said gun owners could only legally have their firearms on school property in their locked cars or when dropping off or picking up a student. That was the law before changes were made this year.

HB 60 also repealed any existing laws that were in conflict, which included HB 862. The governor signed HB 60, limiting firearms at schools, on April 23, two days after he signed the other gun legislation.

Code Revision Commission, which notes at the end of the law now on the books referenced the difference between the two bills approved by the 2014 Legislature. The note said HB 60 “implicitly repealed and superseded” the gun law that took effect in April that allowed guns at schools.

Johnson and Evans said they are confused as to when a licensed gun owner can bring a gun to their children’s schools. They are concerned they could be charged with misdemeanors if they bring firearms to school events.

But Moulard, the attorney for Fulton schools, said the U.S. Supreme Court, in a 2008 decision, “recognized there are certain sensitive settings” where guns cannot be allowed.

“One of those is the school setting,” Moulard said.



Next Up in Local

Marietta man ejected from truck, seriously injured during Cobb crash
Marietta man ejected from truck, seriously injured during Cobb crash

A man was seriously injured after being ejected from his truck during a two-vehicle wreck in Cobb County Monday, police said. Patrick Bruce, 38, of Marietta, was driving his 1998 Ford F-150 north on Canton Road when he left the roadway around 6:30 a.m. for unknown reasons, striking a utility pole and a stone wall, Cobb County police said in a news...
Walton County lawyer, judge faces 12 child porn, enticing children charges
Walton County lawyer, judge faces 12 child porn, enticing children charges

A Walton County lawyer, part-time judge and ex-special assistant attorneys general (SAAG) faces 12 charges of sexual exploitation of children, Channel 2 Action News reported. George Randolph Jeffrey, who goes by Randy, was arrested amid a joint investigation by the GBI and FBI, Channel 2 reported Monday. Documents obtained by the news station indicate...
Defense: Uber Eats driver accused of killing Morehouse grad shot in self-defense
Defense: Uber Eats driver accused of killing Morehouse grad shot in self-defense

The attorney for an Uber Eats driver accused of killing a customer wants a judge to throw out the charges against his client.   Robert Bivines’ attorney filed a request for an immunity hearing, allowing a judge to decide if his client acted in self-defense when he allegedly killed one of his customers in February. If the judge agrees...
Director Sean Anders on filming ‘Instant Family’ in Atlanta and Cobb
Director Sean Anders on filming ‘Instant Family’ in Atlanta and Cobb

Sean Anders sat in a mostly empty event space at Four Seasons Atlanta, casual in a ball cap with a “Wagner Custom Renovations” logo — a nod to the fictional company in his latest movie, “Instant Family.” He patiently awaited a delivery from South City Kitchen around the corner.  “I wasn’t really...
Texas pet shelter gets food donations from community 
Texas pet shelter gets food donations from community 

A Texas animal services company got some paw-sitive news this week, KSAT reported. >> Read more trending news  San Antonio Animal Care Services announced last week that it had just nine bags of dog food in its pantry, the television station reported. Since then, the nonprofit group had more than 8,000 pounds of pet food donated within...
More Stories