Trial begins in Waffle House chairman’s sex tape case

A housekeeper for the former CEO of Waffle House and her two lawyers are once again facing a judge over accusations they secretly recorded a sex tape of the executive — the latest development in a case that has spent the last six years tied up in the courts.

Testimony began Tuesday in the case of Mye Brindle, a former housekeeper for Waffle House chairman Joe Rogers Jr., and her two attorneys, John Butters and David Cohen. The three defendants are facing charges of unlawful eavesdropping over allegations they made a secret video recording of Brindle performing a sexual act on Rogers in his bedroom without his knowledge.

Fulton County Superior Court Judge Henry Newkirk is once again presiding over the case after throwing it out last year, a decision that was overturned by the Georgia Supreme Court in November. The high court’s decision to reinstate the indictment is the most recent complication in a lengthy court process that has become a tangled web of lawsuits, counter-lawsuits and appeals.

Prosecutors said the video, which they indicated will be shown to the jury, depicts a nude Rogers shaving himself in his bathroom after getting out of the shower. Brindle, who was recording Rogers on a camera disguised as a cell phone, then has a conversation with Rogers and gives him a massage that ends with a sexual act.

Related: Charges reinstated in Waffle House sex tape case

Also: Lawyers try to stay in sex tape case involving Waffle House chair

And: Judge criticizes lawyers in Waffle House chairman’s sex-tape case

The video was recorded a few weeks after Brindle retained Cohen and Butters as legal counsel, and was the subject of a letter Cohen sent to Rogers in 2012, which encouraged Rogers to pay Brindle $12 million to resolve sexual harassment allegations she’d made against him. Failure to pay the requested amount could lead to media attention and criminal charges, the letter said.

Brindle stopped attending work shortly after the video was recorded.

Fran Rogers, Joe Rogers’ wife, has denied the allegations against her husband.

On the stand Tuesday, Fran Rogers was in tears as she described finding a resignation note from Brindle in her husband’s sock drawer weeks later. In the note, Brindle wrote, “I can no longer bear the pain, humiliation and damage to my well-being from what you have demanded and required of me in this position.”

Brindle filed a civil suit against Rogers that’s still pending in Cobb County, and Rogers later countersued to have the video kept private. Cobb County Superior Court Judge Robert Leonard, who later recused himself from the case, disqualified Cohen and Rogers from serving as Brindle’s counsel in the civil suit due to their involvement in the creation of the video.

The prosecution’s argument rests largely on whether Brindle, who engaged in sexual acts with Rogers for most of the nine years she was employed by him, consented to the contact. Prosecuting attorney Melissa Redmon said Brindle routinely gave Rogers massages that would end with sexual favors.

“What you won’t see on the camera is any threats, any coercion,” Redmon said.

Reid Thompson, Brindle’s defense attorney, gave the jury a much different picture, presenting his 49-year-old client as a vulnerable, working-class single mother who feared refusing sexual contact with Rogers would cost her her job. The jury of 12 and 2 alternates is made up of ten women and four men.

“He required her to perform sexual acts on him — not with him, on him,” said Thompson. “She had a decision to make, that’s true — the same decision, unfortunately, too many women have to make: Do what the boss requires you to do or start looking for another job.”

In other news: Man turns down parole for a chance at a better life on the outside

The defense claims Brindle was justified in recording the video as evidence she would later use to sue Rogers for sexual harassment. Thompson has sought to paint his client’s indictment as evidence of a wealthy man abusing his power. Rogers has not been charged with a crime in this case.

“If you’re wondering why it is that Mye Brindle and the two attorneys who tried to help her … why they’re the ones arrested, remember Joe Rogers is an extremely wealthy, extremely powerful and extremely well-connected man,” Thompson said.

Brian Steele, a defense attorney for David Cohen, also argued that the laws surrounding unlawful surveillance apply only to places where people who are not members of the victim’s household are present. So by allowing the housekeeper into his home, Steele said, Rogers no longer could claim the expectation of privacy in his bedroom.

“He removes the public shield,” Steele said. “It becomes a public place.”

Thomas Hawkins, the president of the private investigation firm Hawk Professional Investigation, said Cohen and Butters approached him about secretly documenting a sexual abuser, but his firm refused to take the case.

“They had mentioned that the recording was going to be taking place in a private residence, and I did not think that would be something that would be legal to do,” Hawkins said.

Hawkins noted his firm had been asked to record video in private homes many times over the years, and had refused to do it every time. While Hawkins said his firm didn’t take on Cohen and Butter’s case, it did order the camera Brindle would use to record Rogers and showed her how to use it.

The trial will resume Wednesday. Come back to for more coverage.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Winning numbers drawn for record-setting $1.6B Mega Millions jackpot
Winning numbers drawn for record-setting $1.6B Mega Millions jackpot

Tuesday night’s winning Mega Millions numbers were just drawn, and the lucky numbers are 28, 70, 5, 62 and 65 with the MegaBall being 5. The Mega Millions jackpot has continued to increase, breaking records along the way. If someone wins the $1.6 billion jackpot, it will be the highest jackpot paid out in history, surpassing the $1.586 billion...
Scaled-down version of Julio Jones’ Mall of Georgia project approved
Scaled-down version of Julio Jones’ Mall of Georgia project approved

Gwinnett County officials approved Tuesday a significantly scaled back version of the Mall Of Georgia-area development backed by Atlanta Falcons star Julio Jones. The original vision for the project known as “Ariston” called for more than 500 apartments, a 25-story hotel and more to be built on about 16 acres near Woodward Crossing...
Sheriff beefs up Georgia-Florida game security after 6 shot near stadium
Sheriff beefs up Georgia-Florida game security after 6 shot near stadium

Just days after six people were shot within a mile of Jacksonville’s football stadium, the sheriff said he’s boosting manpower for Saturday’s Georgia-Florida game. “More than 600 police will be assigned on game day to secure not only the venue, but the larger footprint of downtown and into the surrounding neighborhoods including...
Honoring a hero: Hundreds attend visitation for slain Gwinnett officer
Honoring a hero: Hundreds attend visitation for slain Gwinnett officer

A single, white snapdragon fell from a large flower arrangement as she stood inside a Gwinnett County funeral home Tuesday afternoon. Marion Johnson just knew it was a sign, and she picked it up. “I will hold onto this forever,” Johnson said. It was her favorite flower, and it was proof that the young-faced officer she’d seen so many...
Federal judge mulling action over Georgia absentee ballots
Federal judge mulling action over Georgia absentee ballots

An overly stringent review of absentee ballots in Gwinnett County and the state of Georgia has the potential to disenfranchise thousands of people, attorneys for multiple voting and civil rights groups argued in federal court Tuesday. A judge will decide soon if she agrees. U.S. District Court Judge Leigh Martin May heard arguments Tuesday afternoon...
More Stories