More bad news for supplement king: Judge orders $40 million penalty


It has been a difficult month for Jared Wheat, the Atlanta-area dietary supplement entrepreneur. And that’s putting it mildly.

Less than a week after federal authorities unsealed an indictment accusing the Hi-Tech Pharmaceuticals CEO of wire fraud, money laundering and other charges, a federal judge has ordered him, his company and an associate to pay more than $40 million to resolve an unrelated civil matter.

The Tuesday ruling by U.S. District Judge Charles A. Pannell Jr. didn’t arrive out of the blue. It’s the latest chapter in the Federal Trade Commission’s long-running lawsuit challenging Hi-Tech’s advertising. Still, Pannell’s 132-paging ruling is yet another body blow for Wheat and his Norcross-based firm, detailing what, in the judge’s view, was an attempt to justify product claims with questionable science.

Pannell affirmed the FTC’s contention that Wheat, Hi-Tech and a company vice president, Stephen Smith, violated permanent injunctions barring them from making unsubstantiated claims about four supposed weight-loss supplements: Fastin, Lipodrene, Benzedrine and Stimerex-ES. The group must pay $40.1 million, the amount it received in gross receipts for the products during a 4½-year period, and the FTC must distribute the money to consumers, the judge ruled.

The FTC had asked Pannell to impose a separate sanction of $34.4 million to compensate consumers, but the judge declined.

The ruling also requires an Atlanta weight-loss physician, Dr. Terrill Mark Wright, to pay $120,000 for making unsubstantiated statements about Fastin.

“The court recognizes that the compensatory sanctions were significant, but so, too, was the defendants’ contumacious conduct,” Pannell wrote.

The sanctions stem from a lawsuit filed by the FTC 13 years ago that has had a number of twists and turns, including a hearing in which Wheat invoked his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination 19 times and later collapsed in a men’s room outside the courtroom.

In 2014, Pannell ruled that the defendants were liable for $40 million in compensatory sanctions. However, the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals vacated the order. It said the lower court had improperly applied the doctrine of collateral estoppel, which prevents certain issues from being re-litigated.

Pannell’s ruling Tuesday in essence reinstates the earlier order while also poking holes in Hi-Tech’s reasoning for why its advertising claims can stand up to scrutiny.

In one particularly telling passage, Pannell notes that one of the experts who testified on Hi-Tech’s behalf, Timothy Gaginella, received $60,000 a year from Wheat or his companies. The judge goes on to state that Wheat or his companies twice forged Gaginella’s signature to show that he endorsed a Hi-Tech product.

“While the evidence is more reflective of Wheat’s guile, the court mentions it here because the history between Hi-Tech and Dr. Gaginella is dubious,” Pannell wrote.

In the indictment unsealed on Oct. 5, the government contends that Wheat created a series of fake documents to make it appear to customers that Hi-Tech products met various standards set by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. The indictment also asserts that Wheat and Hi-Tech manufactured and distributed prohormone supplements that contained anabolic steroids and a supplement for reducing cholesterol that contained the prescription drug Lovastatin.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

3 injured in shooting near Grant Park; suspect in custody
3 injured in shooting near Grant Park; suspect in custody

Three people were shot near Grant Park Friday, police said. Atlanta police said it appears a dispute escalated to gunfire at 520 Park Avenue in southeast Atlanta. Two people traveled by private vehicle to Grady Memorial Hospital, police said. The extent of their injuries has not been released. The other person, who was shot in the leg, traveled...
Gwinnett prosecutors unable to contact key witness in teen’s rape case
Gwinnett prosecutors unable to contact key witness in teen’s rape case

State prosecutors have been unable to make contact with the key witness in a 2-year-old rape case involving multiple high school teens who haven’t been allowed bond, Channel 2 Action News reported. Darriah Mitchell, 16, and three other juvenile defendants have been locked up and denied bond in a rape case that allegedly took place May 2016...
Mattie’s Call issued for 2 missing people in Clayton County
Mattie’s Call issued for 2 missing people in Clayton County

Police are trying to find two missing people in Clayton County. A Mattie’s Call was issued Friday for Lewis Thomson, 35, of Hampton, and Yvonne Patrice West, 49, of Riverdale, according to a news release from the Clayton County Police Department. Thomson suffers from schizophrenia and bipolar disorder and doesn’t have his medication with...
SATURDAY’S WEATHER-TRAFFIC: Weekend rain builds as subtropical storm approaches U.S. coast
SATURDAY’S WEATHER-TRAFFIC: Weekend rain builds as subtropical storm approaches U.S. coast

Saturday: High: 83 Saturday night: Low: 68  Sunday: High: 78 The holiday weekend is expected to be a rainy, windy and stormy one, but Saturday should see the least amount of rain. But don’t mistake that for a dry day. The predicted chance of rain is 60 percent, and a flash flood warning is in effect until early Saturday morning, which...
Man allegedly tried to force woman into his truck — then her dog bit him
Man allegedly tried to force woman into his truck — then her dog bit him

Coweta County authorities are searching for a “suspicious” man they say attempted to get a woman to get in his truck Monday. The man allegedly approached the woman while she was walking her dog near the Timberidge neighborhood on North Ga. 29 when a black Dodge Ram pickup approached her, according to a news release by the Coweta County...
More Stories