Deputies mistake Georgia man for murder suspect, pull guns on family


Authorities pulled their guns on Peter Butler, thinking he might be a murder suspect. 

The actual suspect, Richard Lyle Timmons Jr., remains at large. 

Timmons is accused of fatally shooting his wife outside a nursing home. 

Friday was a frightening day for Peter Butler and his family. 

They were headed to Charlie Norwood Veterans Medical Center in downtown Augusta for an appointment when Richmond County sheriff’s deputies drew guns on them, news station WRDW/WAGT reported, saying he fit the description of a murder suspect: a black male driving a white SUV. 

Earlier that day, nursing home employee Jazna O. Timmons was shot and killed in the parking lot of the Georgia War Veterans Nursing Home, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution previously reported. Her husband, Richard Lyle Timmons Jr., is the suspected shooter and remains on the run.

The VA hospital and nursing home are a quarter of a mile apart. 

READ: Husband sought, accused of fatally shooting wife at Georgia veterans nursing home

“We were like, ‘Wait a minute, what’s going on? Why are they pointing at us?’” Butler told the news station. “So they run up to our car, and they immediately pull their guns out at us.”

Butler said officers told him he and Timmons, described as 5-foot-10 with a medium build and short twists in his hair, looked alike and had similar vehicles: a white Chevrolet Traverse. Butler has a 2017 model, Timmons a 2010 one. 

In a Facebook Live post captured by Butler’s wife, deputies told the family: “You gotta understand what we’re looking for. We got a vehicle here, two people they can see in it, one that matches the description ... they’re gonna come up here and check it.”

The AJC has reached out to the Richmond County Sheriff’s Department for comment. 

Butler, who said he served in the military, said he understood officials had to do their job, but when he saw a picture of Timmons: “I was just like, ‘This guy doesn’t even look like me.’”

In other news:

Next Up in Local

UPDATE: 3 children found with malnourished man; parents arrested
UPDATE: 3 children found with malnourished man; parents arrested

Police arrested the mother and stepfather of three unsupervised children and a disabled adult who appeared malnourished after officers found them in a southwest Atlanta residence. Officers responded to the house in the the 3000 block of Thornberry Lane on Saturday about 5:30 p.m., police spokesman John Chafee said in a statement. The people who called...
Group studying transit options to get around Hartsfield area easier
Group studying transit options to get around Hartsfield area easier

Mobility in the area around Hartsfield-Jackson International must be improved before the southside of Atlanta can live up to its potential, leaders hoping to boost economic development say. While MARTA makes it easy to get to Hartsfield-Jackson International, getting around the surrounding areas can be a challenge, said Grady Smith, a project manager...
Cobb County restaurant inspection scores

Cobb County • Food Big Apple, 2727 Paces Ferry Road, Atlanta. 80/B • McDonald’s, 5145 Cowan Road, Acworth. 85/B • Paleteria La Delicia, 1869 Cobb Parkway, Marietta. 91/A • Tapestry at the Old Mill, 4271 Southside Drive, Acworth. 100/A
Gridlock Guy: Our city’s parking problems are a reflection of our traffic woes
Gridlock Guy: Our city’s parking problems are a reflection of our traffic woes

Atlanta gets more flack than Roberta about how slow its traffic moves. While rush hour, lack of mass transit, and often just plain sloppy organization with big events are killing drivers softly with a very slow song, another vehicular problem needs consideration. Businesses, organizations, and cities need to do better with how they handle parking....
Cherokee County restaurant inspection scores

Cherokee County • Arby’s, 1461 Riverstone Parkway, Canton. 87/B • Bojangles, 1665 Ball Ground Highway, Canton. 91/A • Five Guys, 1359 Riverstone Parkway, Canton. 99/A • Hong Kong City, 12050 Highway 92, Woodstock. 78/C • Pizza Hut, 12050 Highway 92, Woodstock. 95/A
More Stories