How to nurture — and try to understand — active 5-year-old twins


Q: My twin boys will turn 5 soon. They’re great, bright, normal kids (backed up by their preschool teachers), but in my mind, 5 feels like the transition from toddler to kid, and I’m afraid I’ll start expecting too much of them. For example, they aren’t especially interested in learning their letters, which I’ve been figuring they’ll come around to when they’re ready, but I’m afraid that when they’re 5, I will start worrying and push it too much. Can you give me an overview of what to expect from active 5-year-old boys?

A: I have never raised twins, but from what I have heard, you have made it through a pretty tough (but exciting and fun) couple of years. Two toddlers throwing tantrums, two toddlers whining, two toddlers running in opposite directions, two toddlers giving you sticky kisses and two toddlers to cuddle. And now they are in preschool! Developmental changes are afoot, but I am not sure why you are panicking now. Is it because this feels like “real school”? If that is the reason, I don’t blame you. Schools in the United States are moving toward more rigorous standards in the younger grades, which can result in unreasonable learning expectations.

In general terms, 5-year-olds are coming into their own. You may find that your boys are more empathetic and kind to others, but may also accuse others of cheating if they lose a game. Children this age love to play and use their imaginations, but these imaginations can also scare them. You may find that your boys are sharing their newly found opinions often and loudly, and that they cannot be fooled or manipulated into moving on from a subject or place easily. With this stubbornness, you also can get defiance that does not disappear with punishments; instead it worsens. Parents also find that their 5-year-olds enjoy potty humor, and storytelling can be imaginative, funny and (sometimes) boundary-pushing. Five-year-olds love to have real work that means something to the world and the family. And because their attention spans can last a bit longer, they can focus on more complex projects and instructions.

Even though your twins may appear to be mature at times, 5-year-olds still have tantrums, resort to violence and call people names. If the school days have been long and their nervous systems are taxed, you will find a 5-year-old regressing into 3-year-old behaviors. This is completely normal.

As for what to expect from active little boys, our culture loves to think that boys and girls are opposite, but their brains are not as different as people imagine. Boys’ brains tend to excel in visual-spatial integration, while girls’ brains excel in reading social cues.

What does this mean for your twin boys? It doesn’t mean that a girl cannot be coordinated and that your boys cannot be highly verbal. Instead, it can show how, if a boy’s brain excels in spatial issues, his body longs to jump, climb and test out the space around him. It also tells parents of boys to do (at least) two things: Let the young boys move frequently, and use emotionally expressive language with them.

Because 5-year-old boys typically love to move, most educators and parents focus on getting them outside and into activities such as soccer and karate. I encourage more movement for all children, especially during school hours. But just because boys’ brains quickly assess spatial relations doesn’t mean they don’t have a need for us to model and use productive emotional language with them. Parents can say things like “I felt really frustrated that I got stuck in traffic today, and because of that, everything got tough at work. I was angry about it for a little while, but I took a walk and cooled down,” or, “You’re sad that we ran out of cookies; I am, too. It really stinks, doesn’t it?” This has a huge impact on all children, especially boys. Even the simplest show of emotions can help a 5-year-old express and regulate his feelings.

Remember, development is not a steady climb uphill; it comes in fits and starts. It’s not easy having two boys around the same age with their own developmental road maps. So be kind to yourself. Practice asking, “What is this behavior really about?” when you find yourself stumped.

Finally, don’t forget the power of connecting to each child as an individual. Maybe it is roughhousing, maybe it is cuddles, maybe it is foot rubs, maybe it is walking around the block, or maybe it is reading together. Just be prepared to continuously reach out to both children with love, especially when they are moody.

For books, I would begin with “The Whole Brain Child” by Dan Siegel and Tina Bryson. I find their explanation of the child’s brain and how it relates to their behavior to be clear, nonjudgmental and science-based.

Good luck.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Living

This Life: Could DeKalb police do more to find Jenna Van Gelderen?
This Life: Could DeKalb police do more to find Jenna Van Gelderen?

I don’t know how they do it. How they get through the day. How they sleep at night. Roseanne Glick and Leon Van Gelderen don’t really know either. What they know for sure is their daughter, Jenna, has been missing for more than a year, and they still don’t know why she disappeared—or if she’s dead or alive. “The...
Trevor Noah addresses Georgia voting access controversies on ‘The Daily Show’
Trevor Noah addresses Georgia voting access controversies on ‘The Daily Show’

Trevor Noah on “The Daily Show” Thursday night did a five-minute comedy bit addressing some of the controversies involving voting in Georgia during the gubernatorial race.  Noah, who is coming to the Fox Theatre to do a stand-up show in February of next year, pointed out the 53,000 names placed in “pending” status...
Concert review and photos: Josh Groban soars in tour kickoff in Duluth
Concert review and photos: Josh Groban soars in tour kickoff in Duluth

When Josh Groban spoke to us last week about preparing for his tour opener, he noted the challenge of finding ways to fill an arena space with energy. Mission accomplished. Thursday night, Groban and tour mate Idina Menzel launched their monthlong jaunt from Infinite Energy Arena in Duluth (which prompted a witty aside from Groban about Duluth Trading...
Jeff Dunham’s fourth trip to what is now State Farm Arena March 28, 2019
Jeff Dunham’s fourth trip to what is now State Farm Arena March 28, 2019

Puppet master and ventriloquist extraordinaire Jeff Dunham is coming back to what is now State Farm Arena for a fourth time next year on March 28.  Ticket prices range from $53.50 to $221.  This will be Dunham’s first trip back since 2014, when it was still called Philips Arena.  “Atlanta has always treated me well,&rdquo...
It takes a granny to get tough on Michael Myers
It takes a granny to get tough on Michael Myers

At this point in 2018, a movie featuring three generations of victimized women squaring off against a predatory male is destined to find an audience. Nostalgia and catharsis; splatter and sisterhood. The new “Halloween” couldn’t miss even if it were set on Arbor Day. It’s a fairly engrossing bit of fan service, boasting many...
More Stories