Even food writers have kitchen disasters … and so do readers

My worst kitchen disaster came when I had been cooking for just a few years, but long enough to know better.

I put a baking sheet of oatmeal cookies into the oven and baked them for the appropriate time. When I took the sheet out, it was nothing but hot, sweet, oatmeal soup. With raisins.

I called the woman I was dating at the time and asked what I had done wrong.

“How much flour did you use?” she asked.

Me: “Flour?”

It was embarrassing, but not bad enough to keep her from marrying me. Still, to this day the recollection of it all gnaws away at the back of my mind, like a mouse.

So I decided my misery deserves company. I went on Facebook and asked my Facebook friends to share their biggest kitchen disasters. And they responded. Oh, did they respond. Here are just a few of the very best:

Lee said: “I sometimes make a standard chili, but with white chicken meat instead of beef. It isn’t really chili, but it’s good. I once rationalized that canned tuna is as mild as white chicken meat, so I made canned tuna chili. Even the dog wouldn’t eat it.”

Betsy was in college and did not know the meaning of a “clove” of garlic, so she cooked a chicken dinner with two heads of garlic. “I blew my food budget for the week” and went out to eat.

When Doug was a child of 10 or 11, he decided to bake a cake for his mother. Ever the thoughtful child, and knowing that she liked the color green, he used white frosting with a generous sprinkling of green sugar sprinkles which, he said, made a beautiful cake.

“Then we ate it. The green crystals were celery salt,” he said.

Annie also had a problem with a cake — and her own sense of humor. She has a friend who absolutely hates rutabagas, a vegetable with which she was unfamiliar. As a joke, she decided to bake him a cake with rutabagas in it.

“I thought, ‘I use zucchini in cake, right? This will be just like that.’”

“I mixed up a German sweet chocolate cake, shredded rutabagas in it, and popped it in the oven. The smell was the worst. It was so horrible that I was gagging. I grabbed the cake pans out of the oven and threw them out into the backyard just to get this abomination out of my house.

“Then I had to crank all the windows open to get the smell out, which wouldn’t have been so terrible except that it was early March in Ohio and really cold outside. So there I was in my freezing house that smelled like a German chocolate fart, admitting to my friend that one really cannot make a rutabaga cake.”

Mitzi’s cake story was equally unappetizing: “As a teenager, I baked a chocolate cake and forgot to add the eggs to the batter. I discovered the uncracked eggs and tried to add them after the cake was half-baked. Not a pretty picture. Scrambled eggs in chocolate.”

Julie’s daughter had a very different problem with a birthday cake. She “misunderstood the recipe’s instruction to slice the layers in half. I have the photo …” she said.

The first time Carrie made pie crust, “I took the recipe’s advice and weighted down the dough with pennies while it baked. Unfortunately, I left the coins in the plastic bag.”

Similarly, Melanie once tried lining a cake pan with plastic wrap instead of parchment paper. “I picked out the biggest pieces. The rest was easily digestible,” she said.

Cheryl tried to bake a loaf bread made with barley flour. “It wouldn’t get done and wouldn’t get done. I kept putting in back in the oven, but it still wouldn’t cook through. Finally, in disgust, I stuck it back in the oven until it burned black, thinking “Now it’ll be cooked.” Nope. When I broke it open (with a hammer and screwdriver), the inside was still dough.”

During the Depression, Priscilla’s mother’s family “was fortunate to come into possession of four fine steaks. In those days, they would fry the steaks. On the big night, with high anticipation, the cooker of these steaks put a large scoop of lard into the fry pan and fried ’em up — only it turned out the ‘lard’ was soap. I do believe that real tears were shed.”

Mary Ellin’s middle-school son “once put Fast Mac in the microwave with no water — just macaroni and cheese. The thing caught fire and as smoke poured out of the microwave, he ran around the house once, then next door to our neighbor (I wasn’t home), who threw the mess into the sink, poured cold water on it, and opened all our windows.”

A lot of the Facebook friends had stories about Pyrex dishes or other glassware that shattered, but my favorite came from Shelia, who, I should point out, runs a restaurant: “I was making a roast in the oven and for some reason decided to add water to the glass casserole dish. I took the roast out and poured in the water, and it exploded. Glass everywhere. Luckily, I had removed the roast,” she wrote.

Susan’s cooking disaster involves Lime Chicken. “I invented it. And it’s an invention I’m not sharing with the world. So. Much. Lime.” She had only been dating her now-husband for a few months, and she decided she “was going to prove my culinary prowess. I learned in short order that, yes, you can have too much lime. Way too much lime.”

It’s hard to get a pizza wrong, unless you do as Tammy did and bake it upside-down. She “opened the oven when smoke began pouring out and the cheese looked like stalactites. What a gooey mess!”

When he was 2 years old, Ray tore all the paper labels off the family’s canned vegetables. “My mother had ‘surprise’ side dishes every night for a week,” he said.

Amy wrote that her mother was once baking cookies when she “opened the oven too quickly, with her face too close, and she singed off her eyebrows. Does that count?”

Dear Amy: No.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Cooking and Recipes

Dining With the Stars: Actress Zoe Renee’s favorite Atlanta restaurants
Dining With the Stars: Actress Zoe Renee’s favorite Atlanta restaurants

Actress Zoe Renee seems to be everywhere these days -- she stars on the BET series “The Quad” and will appear in the upcoming movies “Nancy Drew and the Hidden Staircase” and  “Gully”.  She also co-stars in the movie JINN, which won the special jury award for narrative feature at SXSW Film...
5 spots to buy delectable Thanksgiving pies in metro Atlanta
5 spots to buy delectable Thanksgiving pies in metro Atlanta

You can have you cake pie and eat it too. Pumpkin pie is always an option, and certainly, this list includes a few, but there are more choices you might want to sink your teeth into. From bourbon pecan pie to apple crumble, these decadent desserts are just what you need to put the finishing touch on your Thanksgiving meal. <<Make these savory...
Where to get Thanksgiving meals to go in metro Atlanta
Where to get Thanksgiving meals to go in metro Atlanta

Want to host Thanksgiving this year but don’t want to deal with cooking? These metro Atlanta restaurants have you covered. Be sure to place your orders quickly, as many restaurants have deadlines.  4 Rivers Smokehouse. The restaurant is offering everything from smoked turkey and brisket to àla carte sides and fixins’ packages...
Kick off ‘Giving Season’ with a tapping of SweetWater Second Helping IPA
Kick off ‘Giving Season’ with a tapping of SweetWater Second Helping IPA

For the sixth time, SweetWater Brewing is partnering with The Giving Kitchen to release the limited-edition Second Helping IPA.  And as always, 100 percent of the profits from SweetWater and United Distributors will be donated to the Giving Kitchen non-profit to help provide emergency assistance to restaurant workers through financial support...
Recipe: Sweet corn, shrimp make this soup special
Recipe: Sweet corn, shrimp make this soup special

While The Federal has received national accolades for its oxtail French onion soup, the corn soup deserves an honorable mention. As corn comes into season, all I can think about is this velvety soup that left me craving more for months after my last spoonful. I hope they would be willing to share the recipe. — Kelley Wisniewski, Marietta...
More Stories