Review: Emily Blunt is excellent, but this 'Girl' is a trainwreck


The Girl on the Train is more successful as a public service announcement about the dangers of binge drinking than as a gripping, twisty mystery.

If only this could have been a one-woman show for Emily Blunt, because everything else around her fails in director Tate Taylor’s underwhelming adaptation (*½ out of four; rated R; in theaters nationwide Friday) of the popular Paula Hawkins novel. The major whodunit here is who made a best-selling thriller so darn boring.

Rachel Watson (Blunt) is a troubled divorcée and struggling alcoholic who spends her days coming and going from Manhattan on the train, mainly for the view. At one stop along the way, she obsessively watches seemingly perfect young couple Megan (Haley Bennett) and Scott Hipwell (Luke Evans), yet avoids the home two doors down — the one she used to share with her ex Tom (Justin Theroux) that now houses his new wife Anna (Rebecca Ferguson).

Little time is spent fleshing out Rachel’s personality early on; she’s mainly seen mainlining vodka out of a large water bottle while the film focuses on the other two women and their Lifetime-ready suburban melodrama. Anna is a devoted supermom who’s bothered by Rachel’s mere existence — and the fact that she’s constantly calling and hanging up — while Megan is tired of being a wife and shares her deepest secrets not with the oversexed Scott but with her therapist Kamal Abdic (Edgar Ramirez).

But their stories aren’t told in order, and the narrative shifts between various points of view when Megan goes missing. It’s particularly worrisome for Rachel, who suspects she might be involved somehow after waking up from a blackout covered in blood and unable to remember what happened.

Blunt is completely up for the task of playing a woman who downs her troubles in drink, and she’s at her unhinged best when her puffy-cheeked, maniacal Rachel lashes out at her lot in life.

But Girl’s biggest problem is letting her down when digging into what messed her up so badly psychologically. While it’s touched upon, the adapted screenplay by Erin Cressida Wilson dilutes the hows and whys of her depression that Hawkins nailed in her novel, thereby missing a vital connection with the audience. Instead, it’s more concerned with ratcheting up the tension as it steams toward the not-that-surprising finale.

Though the revelations are somewhat satisfying when they come, the narrative until then is a dull slog. The appointments between Megan and her psychiatrist are complete snoozefests (the later meetings with Rachel and Abdic are only slightly more interesting), and the investigation of Megan’s death is mostly relegated to Rachel reading news stories on her fellow subway passengers’ tablets. (Allison Janney at least is game as a hard-nosed detective who’s skeptical of pretty much anything that comes out of Rachel’s mouth.)

Evans' and Theroux’s characters lack dimension and consistent motivations, so the movie hinges on its women, a complicated bunch. None of them are like the other yet they all share, in their own ways, yearning for a happiness they can’t have.

The actresses, especially Blunt, do their part though ultimately can’t escape this trainwreck.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Living

‘The Walking Dead’ ratings dip again but all is not lost
‘The Walking Dead’ ratings dip again but all is not lost

On Metacritic, fans of the show has given this season the highest ranking (7.1) since season five (also 7.1), when the show’s popularity peaked. The problem: millions of fans abandoned ship seasons seven and eight during the ill-fated Rick/Negan war and are not ever coming back. “The Walking Dead” hit its lowest overnight numbers...
Jeff Lynne’s ELO will return to the road summer 2019, play Atlanta
Jeff Lynne’s ELO will return to the road summer 2019, play Atlanta

After Jeff Lynne’s ELO played a brief tour this summer – their first in North American since 1981 - the responses were rapturous (the words “flawless” and “visually stunning” were often invoked). Lynne will bring his live production back to the masses in summer 2019 and this time, Atlanta is on the itinerary (ELO...
African-American Hollywood stars raise $300K for Stacey Abrams
African-American Hollywood stars raise $300K for Stacey Abrams

Producer Will Packer and actor/rapper Chris “Ludacris” Bridges helped raise more than $300,000 for the Stacey Abrams gubernatorial campaign on Sunday. They brought a raft of celebrities to Packer’s Atlanta home including Chris Tucker, Tiffany Haddish, Kelly Rowland, Marlon Wayans, LaToya Luckett, Marsai Martin and Tyrese...
SweetWater 420 Fest taps Widespread Panic, Avett Brothers, Jason Isbell for 15th anniversary
SweetWater 420 Fest taps Widespread Panic, Avett Brothers, Jason Isbell for 15th anniversary

It’s a lineup befitting an anniversary year with the kingpins of the jam genre sharing the marquee with a couple of top Americana names. For the 15th year of SweetWater 420 Fest, Widespread Panic will return to perform four sets during two nights, while The Avett Brothers and Jason Isbell and the 400 Unit will also energize fans of...
680/93.7 The Fan’s Battery offices evacuated after freak gas leak
680/93.7 The Fan’s Battery offices evacuated after freak gas leak

680/93.7 The Fan had to evacuate its offices at the Battery Tuesday morning after a landscaper hit a gas pipe and caused a major leak. SunTrust Park was evacuated as well. For a time, the sports talk station switched to ESPN syndicated programming but were soon able to return to local content by using its UGA Broadcast Center, where Chuck Dowdle and...
More Stories