Emory scholar’s battle with Holocaust denier on big screen with ‘Denial’

A new movie, “Denial,” which opens Friday in Atlanta is based on the true story of Deborah Lipstadt, a prominent scholar and writer, and Emory University professor who was sued for libel in Britain in 1996 by Holocaust denier David Irving for calling him a liar.

Lipstadt had called Irving a liar and said he distorted evidence in her 1993 book, “Denying the Holocaust: The Growing Assault on Truth and Memory.” In a brief passage, she described Irving, a prolific, self-taught World War II historian, as “one of the most dangerous spokesmen in the service of Holocaust denial.” Lipstadt based her conclusion, in part, on Irving’s writings that Hitler did not plan The Final Solution and that there were no gas chambers at Auschwitz.


The movie, starring Rachel Weisz, opens Friday at Tara Theatre in Atlanta. With superb acting and great attention to detail (all of the trial testimony in the movie comes from court transcripts), “Denial” is a fascinating historical drama.

After Lipstadt’s book was published in England, Lipstadt was shocked to find out that Irving was suing her for libel. She was further distressed to learn that in reverse of what happens in American courts, British law placed the burden on Lipstadt to prove she was right to call Irving a liar rather than requiring Irving to prove she had defamed him.

Lipstadt felt she had no choice but to fight back.

“You can’t fight every battle, but if you have to fight some,” she said in a recent interview.

Lipstadt found herself in the position of not only defending herself, but establishing beyond a doubt that the Holocaust

took place.

Bert Roughton, senior managing editor at The Atlanta Journal-Constitution was based in London for the newspaper as a correspodent in 2000, and covered the trial. In a recent column, he wrote about meeting up with Lipstadt at an elegant London hotel that had become her home during the weeks of the trial.

On that bright April morning in 2000, she glowed in the way people do when they find themselves on the world stage in a warm and favorable light. During her three months in the spotlight, the professor from Emory University had emerged as a champion for truth and justice in the eyes of Americans and Europeans who followed the trial.

More: read more of the column here


About the mass exterminations at Auschwitz, Irving once said,“It’s baloney, it’s legend…I say quite tastelessly, in fact, that more women died in the back seat of Edward Kennedy’s car at Chappaquiddick than ever died in a gas chamber in Auschwitz.”

To prove Irving was a fraud, Lipstadt’s legal team summoned a team of historians who presented reams of Nazi records, photographs and other documents – some of which hadn’t been public before – to prove that he Holocaust consumed between 5 million and 6 million innocent lives.

On Wednesday, Lipstadt, wearing a turquoise scarf and still sporting short red hair as depicted in the movie, said in an interview, “This movie is about the fight for truth, but if it has a takeaway, I would say it is there are not two sides to every issue. Certain things are facts not to be debated. Slavery happened. The earth is round. The ice caps are melting. Elvis is not alive.”

She said she hopes the movie also demonstrates the difference between facts, opinions and lies.

“If you take a lie and say it very strongly and say lots of us believe the earth is flat. Doesn’t make it true. It’s still a lie.”

MORE: The Survivor (Part 1)

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Living

Here’s how to identify (and get rid of) venomous spiders in your home
Here’s how to identify (and get rid of) venomous spiders in your home

Most people aren't too happy when they encounter a spider, and that's especially true if the creepy-crawly you come across happens to be venomous. Although it's understandable to be anxious about venomous spiders, it’s important to know the difference between a harmless spider and a dangerous one. Here are some important tips from experts on...
6 perfect dinner (or lunch) dates for the amateur chef
6 perfect dinner (or lunch) dates for the amateur chef

If the way to a heart is through the stomach, Atlanta's culinary scene has plenty of date options even for those who are still getting the hang of boiling water. Sure, surprising a date with a gourmet meal right at home is a worthy goal, but these six Atlanta cooking classes make great date ideas regardless of skill level in the kitchen. 660 Irwin...
New boozy push pops contain more alcohol than a glass of wine
New boozy push pops contain more alcohol than a glass of wine

If you miss the summer days of cooling off with a Push-Pop, never fear! Buzz Pop Cocktails, a Las Vegas-based company, has invented liquor-infused push pops with flavors including Lemon Drop Martini and Moscow Mule. Each Buzz Pop Cocktail is 15 percent alcoholic by volume -- double the amount of alcohol in a glass of beer, or nearly two glasses of...
Atlanta Constitution history: Titanic ocean liner sinks
Atlanta Constitution history: Titanic ocean liner sinks

How The Atlanta Constitution covered the sinking of the Titanic on Tuesday, April 16, 1912: One of the world’s biggest stories of the 20th century happened at the worst possible time for The Constitution’s press deadlines. The doomed liner sank in the early morning hours of April 15, and it would take hours more for the news to reach...
Orchid needs correct light to bloom
Orchid needs correct light to bloom

Q: My orchid has had new growth but no blooms for two years. What can I do to promote blooms? K. W. Branton, email A: Most often it is a question of light. Orchids grow naturally on jungle trees, so they like intermittent sunlight with a little shade for most of the day. That is hard to accomplish in most homes. Try moving your orchid to...
More Stories