Does Hollywood prefer films about women sexually harassing men?

Two years before the Equal Rights Amendment officially failed, “Nine to Five” (1980), in which Dolly Parton, Jane Fonda and Lily Tomlin lightheartedly battle a serial sexual predator, memorably explored the sheer zaniness of workplace harassment. It was a smash, earning $103 million. It even had a catchy theme song.

It’s almost 40 years later, in the Weinstein-C.K.-Moore-Rose-Tambor-Lauer-Keillor-era, and no film about men mistreating women at the office has similarly captured the popular imagination since. When it comes to sexual harassment, Hollywood seems to prefer stories of women treating men badly — in films from “Disclosure” to “Horrible Bosses” — to ones about damsels in distress. Even though just 17 percent of sexual harassment claims filed in 2016 were filed by men, according to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

Exhibit A is 1994’s “Disclosure,” a box-office smash in which the very vulnerable Michael Douglas is sexually harassed by the very vicious Demi Moore.

The Michael Crichton novel, also released in 1994, is an ideology-fueled, anti-PC thriller by a future climate-change denier married five times before he died in 2008 — one who had already taken on the invincible Japanese businesses exploiting America in “Rising Sun” (1992).

The novel, about a male computer executive whose ex-girlfriend harasses him after getting the promotion he thought was his, starts pushing buttons with its epigraph: “Power is neither male nor female,” a quote attributed to former Washington Post publisher Katharine Graham. For more than 400 pages, it doesn’t really stop. There’s even an afterword that, to borrow a phrase from President Donald Trump, shows there can be bad behavior on both sides.

“The advantage of a role-reversal story is that it may enable us to examine aspects concealed by traditional responses and conventional rhetoric,” Crichton wrote. “However readers respond to this story, it is important to recognize that the behavior of the two antagonists mirrors each other.”

Starring aggrieved white male specialist Douglas — see “Fatal Attraction” (1987), “Basic Instinct” (1992) and “Falling Down” (1993) — “Disclosure” packs a bit less punch on film. Befuddled in a toothpaste-stained tie, its hero stumbles through the movie like a 1950s sitcom dad adrift in the 1990s, mumbling about CD-ROM speeds and trying to field his daughter’s questions about why her friend has two moms.

Moore, meanwhile, does everything but gnash her teeth as a Gordon Gekko-like corporate manipulator who tries to seduce Douglas and then falsely claims harassment after he turns her down. After an answering-machine tape of their excruciating encounter derails her story, “Disclosure” morphs into a standard thriller, its third act less about sex than about tech. There’s even a virtual-reality showdown.

Released three years after Anita Hill took on Clarence Thomas on Capitol Hill, “Disclosure” made waves among gender theorists. Bonnie J. Dow, a communications professor at Vanderbilt University and the author of “The Sage Handbook of Gender and Communication,” recalled sitting on a panel at a conference where “every paper was about the movie.” She even wrote one herself.

The experts’ conclusion: “This is really not the way to educate people about sexual harassment,” Dow said.

According to Dow, Crichton, as with “Rising Sun,” put a memorable twist on an issue ripped from the headlines in a way that entertained readers and moviegoers. That’s what good fiction writers do.

It was also a total jerk move.

“As a polemic, I don’t like what it does,” Dow said of “Disclosure.” “It sort of pushes aside the people who overwhelmingly suffer this problem.”

George F. Will took a different view of Crichton’s novel, ceding it was “not deathless literature” but nonetheless worthwhile.

“Crichton’s premise — that there is no difference between the sexes regarding abuse of power — may or may not be true,” Will wrote in 1994. “But it certainly is a provocation to ‘victim feminists,’ whose premise is that the world would be pretty much perfect if it were scrubbed clean of all vestiges of patriarchy.”

Despite its mixed reception, the film is among the highest-grossing movies about sexual harassment of all time. “Disclosure” took in $83 million domestically, making it the 14th top-grossing movie of 1994 — less than “Nine to Five” did, especially when you account for inflation, but it also took in an additional $131 million internationally. (Box Office Mojo doesn’t list the equivalent figure for “Nine to Five.”)

And “Disclosure” has a lot of company among role-reversal movies. “Horrible Bosses” (2011), in which Jennifer Aniston plays a dentist aggressively courting her male hygienist, earned $118 million domestically. “Working Girl” (1988), in which Sigourney Weaver sleeps with Harrison Ford before she punishes him for sleeping with Melanie Griffith (whom she also punishes) took in $102 million and netted five Oscar nominations. “Tootsie” (1982), in which Dustin Hoffman — himself now accused of sexual harassment — dodges the unwanted attention of a colleague while in drag, made $177 million.

For a widely seen film to tackle men harassing women at all, it seems, the woman might have to really be a man.

Compare that list with “North Country” (2005), a hard-hitting movie about men harassing women in an iron mine, starring Charlize Theron, that earned $25 million; or Neil LaBute’s “In the Company of Men,” an art-house hit about rogues torturing a deaf female colleague that took in $3 million.

Nowadays, when male entertainers and politicians are routinely 86-ed for exposing themselves to women, locking women in offices with secret buttons, courting underage girls and/or hiring ex-Israeli spies to cover their tracks, this imbalance seems like a problem.

Of course, movie theaters aren’t necessarily for learning. If mainstream movies’ obsession with harassed men is out of step with reality, at least we can look to real life — like the resignations or firing of people including Harvey Weinstein, Matt Lauer and Sen. Al Franken, D-Minn., for lessons.

As Dow put it, “I don’t think that we’ve ever been able to count on, or will be able to count on, Hollywood to educate us.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Living

Patience pays off in this cohesively contemporary home
Patience pays off in this cohesively contemporary home

MEDINA, Wash. — Nearly brand-new and admirably game, Graham Baba Architects had just one commission under its creative belt when opportunity knocked, urgently, all the way from Kentucky. Lisa and Terry Davenport, then living in Louisville with their four children, were moving to Medina. They’d bought a promising 1965 rambler on a serene...
Golden Lace, a champion for pollinators
Golden Lace, a champion for pollinators

Four years ago, I wrote about a Golden Lace patrinia a new plant to most gardeners and one that is thrilling beyond compare for anyone who loves pollinators. Now after four more years of experience, I can say it is a must-have plant, it is truly like having ‘wild kingdom’ packed in a four-foot-tall yellow blooming perennial. Botanically...
5 steps to rehab your raised beds
5 steps to rehab your raised beds

Time is the arbiter of what works in a garden and what doesn’t. It’s why anything new requires at least a decade to discover its weaknesses. The great raised bed failure is right around the corner as the older wood products and shoddy construction destroy structural integrity. Just a few winters can find your boxes collapsed from rot and...
Declutter your house like a professional organizer
Declutter your house like a professional organizer

Few things are worse than coming home from a long day only to find that your house is a mess and in need of a deep clean. It’s all too easy to let unopened mail pile up, neglect sticky kitchen counters and forget to unload the dishwasher before making a new mess. If there’s one person who knows how to handle these common pitfalls, it&rsquo...
Murphy-Harpst Children’s Centers: Two women’s legacies live on
Murphy-Harpst Children’s Centers: Two women’s legacies live on

On Monday night, hundreds of longtime Atlantans gathered at Flourish in Buckhead to remember the late Carey Carter in fun, fitting style. No funeral for the hairstylist and philanthropist everyone loved. Instead, his close friends Liz Lapidus, Tony Conway, business partners Perri Higbie and Mitchell Barnes and Saks Fifth Avenue’s vice president...
More Stories