Meet Alex Guthrie, the Atlanta street musician in the Jennifer Hudson ad

Alex Guthrie in the AJC studio November 16, 2017. CREDIT: Rodney Ho/

Posted Tuesday, November 28, 2017 by RODNEY HO/ on his MyAJC Radio & TV Talk blog

There’s a reason you know that Geico gecko or Flo from Progressive. Insurance companies have a lot of money to spend on advertising.

And thanks to ubiquitous American Family Insurance ads, Marietta singer Alex Guthrie has been seen by practically every American who has a TV over the past seven months. He was the street musician at Woodruff Park in downtown Atlanta who was shocked when Jennifer Hudson strolled up and began dueting with him.

For Guthrie, a 23-year-old full-time musician with a soulful feel, this was an opportunity of a lifetime. And he has been touring ever since, including a stop at Eddie’s Attic December 1. ( Tickets here.) And he will open for the Bleachers and another “Idol” alum  Kelly Clarkson for Star 94.1’s Christmas concert at the Coca-Cola Roxy Theatre December 12. ( Tickets here.)

Star 94.1 program director Tony Lorino is a genuine fan, which is why he added Guthrie to the bill: “I think he’s super talented. He’s got a future and an acoustic singer songwriter style that works well for this station. We want to support him any way we can.”

American Family Insurance’s ad agency BBDO did its best to keep the secret from Guthrie and obscure what the ad was about from the get go. In an interview, Guthrie said a friend earlier this year passed along an audition opportunity for Guthrie. The ad was seeking an R&B-leaning street musician in their early 20s.

Guthrie naturally had no clue what this was about but he got through auditions and was told  to show up early morning at Woodruff Park March 9.  “It happened really fast,” he said. He had no context in terms of how his performance would be used but he figured it was a commercial of some sort. “I can’t stress how low my expectations were,” he said.

Ahead of time, he was told what to prepare: a straightforward cover of a 1978 R&B hit “Lovely Day” by Bill Withers. “They drilled it home: no runs, no vibrato, just consistency,” he said. [This was apparently so Hudson could predictably blend in with him.] On site, he did several takes, then was told to do it one more time but the producers insisted he sing the entire song through no matter what happens.


Why? Well, just 26 seconds into his rendition, Hudson walked up to his right and joined in. At first, he thought it was an intrusive extra. You could see him turn momentarily and look away.  He said at first, he thought, “Hmm… that looks like Jennifer Hudson with a short haircut.” Then his brain clicked in and he realized, yes, that is Jennifer Hudson.

He said the impact of the ad was far greater than he expected. He has been able to book more and bigger gigs. And surprise: “Jennifer Hudson has stayed in some contact with me. She’s kind of a mentor, offers me advice when applicable.”

And folks occasionally notice him in the vaguest sense possible: “People will say, ‘I recognize you. You’re that guy from that thing!’ ”

The Lassiter High School graduate and son of a mortgage banker had two much older siblings Cameron (37) and Nikki (36) who were into music. They exposed him to a lot of older tunes by Marvin Gaye, the Beatles, the Doors and Greg Allman, to name a few. His brother would create CD mixes and Guthrie would jam to them.

In middle school, he realized that being a musician drew the ladies. So using YouTube, he began learning how to play the guitar. His first chords? “Stairway to Heaven” by Led Zeppelin. “I learned that and was hooked,” he said. At age 14, he started a Led Zeppelin cover band called Shattered Silence. That didn’t last and besides, he didn’t exactly sound like Robert Plant.

During high school, he heard a Traveler’s Insurance featuring the Ray LaMontagne song “Trouble” and fell in love with the song. You may recall the ad of the dog who can’t seem to find a safe place for his bone.


At age 17, he began performing regularly at Suburban Tap’s weekly open mic night for two years. There, he met fellow musicians and folks who helped him book other gigs. After a semester at KSU, he tried out for “American Idol” but didn’t make it past the producer round. He remembers “Idol” impresario  Nigel Lythgoe ripping into him, saying he wasn’t soulful or particularly good looking. Ouch! “I just choked,” he admitted. “I was trying too hard.”

Instead of quitting music, Guthrie quit school and doubled down on the music. Except for some real estate photography on the side, he now performs 150 to 200 times a year. “I’m a starving artist,” he said. “I make enough for rent and ramen.”

He had actually met another “Idol” before Hudson this past January: season 9 runner-up Crystal Bowersox. They had shared a bill at a Seaside, Fla. festival. They had mutual friends and became friendly as well. “We hit it off,” he said. “We talked music, hung out, played some Ray Lamontagne. I’ve seen her since at the City Winery. She’s been really sweet, a good friend to have.”


Alex Guthrie

7 p.m., Friday, December 1, 2017


Eddie’s Attic

515-B North McDonough St.



Star 94 Christmas concert with Kelly Clarkson, the Bleachers and Alex Guthrie

7:30 p.m., Tuesday, December 12, 2017


Coca-Cola Roxy Theatre

800 Battery Avenue Southeast, Atlanta

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Living

Concert review and photos: Bon Jovi romps through classics at Philips Arena return
Concert review and photos: Bon Jovi romps through classics at Philips Arena return

BY MELISSA RUGGIERI/AJC Music Scene Ten songs into a two-hour-plus romp, Bon Jovi went back to the very beginning. Amber lights created a halo around David Bryan’s curls as he tapped out the signature opening of the band’s first hit, 1984’s “Runaway.” David Bryan, in his usual spot. Photo: Melissa Ruggieri/AJC...
Vinyl siding gets an upgrade
Vinyl siding gets an upgrade

Homebuyers who relocate to the Atlanta metro area from colder climates are often surprised to find that few builders finish their houses’ exteriors with vinyl siding. While the colorful outside option has a loyal following in other parts of the country, the South has been slower to follow suit. And for years, there’s been one good reason...
How a fringe idea to solve the opioid crisis turned mainstream
How a fringe idea to solve the opioid crisis turned mainstream

The idea that a someone who’s not a medical professional could reverse deadly drug overdoses by injecting victims with an antidote was once fringe. Now it’s widely accepted - and got even stronger backing this month with a rare announcement from the U.S. surgeon general. Jerome Adams urged Americans to consider getting trained to administer...
‘Moderate’ drinking guidelines are too loose, study says
‘Moderate’ drinking guidelines are too loose, study says

A sweeping international study of alcohol consumption has found no overall health benefits from moderate drinking and calls into question the U.S. guidelines that say men can safely drink twice as much as women. The threshold for low-risk drinking, the researchers found, is about seven beers a week for men and women alike. The new report, published...
Unorthodox life inspires Charles Frazier’s ‘Varina’
Unorthodox life inspires Charles Frazier’s ‘Varina’

Varina Anne Banks Howell Davis, first lady of the Confederate States of America, was no pushover, no delicate Southern belle, no simple and refreshing glass of sweet tea. North Carolina author Charles Frazier, best known for his 1997 breakout hit, “Cold Mountain,” describes Varina’s life as full of woe. She was “beaten up&rdquo...
More Stories