Winner: Best ice cream in Atlanta | Best of Atlanta


Now that summer is here in full blast, we bet you have a few secret go-to frozen treats to help beat the heat. 

»RELATED: Atlanta ice cream shop ranked among Thrillist’s 31 best in America

Last week's Best of Atlanta poll was inspired by all things cool and tasty. 

Coming in first place, write-in nominee Berens Frozen Custard in Gwinnett has been making mouth-watering and taste-tempting flavors since 1976. All of their frozen custards are made fresh in-store several times throughout the day. Depending on your timing, you might even see the frozen custard being produced and churned fresh right out of the machines.

With the second highest amount of votes, it's fair to say that Butter & Cream Ice Cream in Decatur has one of Atlanta's favorite frozen treats and ice cream in town. As a small batch ice cream purveyor, they feature homemade ice cream, sorbet and sweet treats all made from scratch with the freshest of ingredients. Is your mouth watering yet? It should be. 

In third, the folks at Queen of Cream take ice cream very, very seriously. Sourcing their dairy locally, and using fresh, real ingredients for flavors, they are able to create some of the best ice cream around.

If you are a true ice cream lover, then you probably just can't get enough. Our other official nominees are also obsess-worthy: Jeni's Splendid Ice Cream (Intown), Honeysuckle Gelato (Intown), Sarah Jean's Ice Cream (Cobb), Four Fat Cows (North Fulton) and Fahrenheit Ice Cream (Gwinnett).

Do you prefer a creamy ice cream, decadent sundae, tangy sorbet or creative popsicle? Lucky for you, all of these can be found in just a short drive. 

Satisfy your sweet tooth with these OTP ice cream shops

If you need to brush up on the flavors of summer, here are 24 Atlanta hot spots to cool down with something sweet.

Read about our other Best of Atlanta winners and nominees here. 


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Atlanta Restaurant Scene

Mexican, health food concepts to open in new Whole Foods 365 stores 
Mexican, health food concepts to open in new Whole Foods 365 stores 

New locations of established dining concepts will be part of Whole Foods Market 365 stores when they open later this year in Buckhead and Decatur. Both the Decatur store -- to be located at 1555 Church St. and the Buckhead store -- to be located at 3535 Northside Parkway --  will feature an onsite restaurant, Loteria Grill, and...
Check out the menu for Root Baking Co., opening Thursday at Ponce City Market
Check out the menu for Root Baking Co., opening Thursday at Ponce City Market

Come Thursday, there’ll be a new place to get bread (and lots more) in Old Fourth Ward. Root Baking Co. is set to open its doors in the Central Food Hall at mixed-use development Ponce City Market.  Formerly located in Charleston, Root Baking Co. was founded in 2015 by husband-and-wife duo Chris Wilkins and Nicole Lewis. Their bakery and...
Get in the pumpkin spice season spirit with this running list of pumpkin products
Get in the pumpkin spice season spirit with this running list of pumpkin products

It’s pumpkin spice season, which, depending on your stance on the omnipresent flavor, is cause for celebration or frustration.  In that vein, here’s a list of new products you’ll either love or love to hate, beyond the famous Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte (which was released earlier than ever this year).  Keep checking back...
This loaded Atlanta cheeseburger will make you a turkey patty believer
This loaded Atlanta cheeseburger will make you a turkey patty believer

Is it sacrilegious to recommend a nonbeef burger on this holiest of hashtag food holidays, #NationalCheeseburgerDay? If it is, cast me out of burger church, because there’s a fabulous alternative patty being served in a delightful family establishment in southwest Atlanta. Recently opened in an unassuming strip mall on Martin Luther King Jr....
4 Atlanta burgers make list of 100 best burgers in the US
4 Atlanta burgers make list of 100 best burgers in the US

Atlanta does not scrimp on its burgers.   From the most over-the-top to those that cater to the veggie lover, Atlanta chefs have mastered crafting the juiciest, mouthwatering burgers, and one national critic has taken note.  Thrillist food critic Kevin Alexander took on a one-year quest across 30 cities to identify the most...
More Stories