Review: Chai Yo brings Thai fine dining to posh Buckhead

There’s no need to look around for Thai starter staples like a green papaya salad or satay when the Nam Prik Ong platter is an option. You dunk this spread of crispy lotus chips, curly cue pork cracklings and fresh cucumber slices into a chunky dip of chiles, ground pork and roasted tomatoes. Between bites, you sip on sparkling lychee sake, perhaps a Thai lager or even the nonalcoholic Lemongrass Lily served in a coupe glass.

It’s not only a fine way to start off an evening at Chai Yo, but a reminder that a chef’s willingness to push boundaries is exactly how a cuisine — and a dining scene — evolves.

Chai Yo does precisely this in dusting off ingrained ideas about what Thai food should be. Here, it’s about exploring possibilities. The outlook is as fresh as the food.

<<An evolving Buckhead battles for luxe bucks

Chai Yo Modern Thai certainly embraces the modern in its name. A new concept from DeeDee Niyomkul, the young chef and force behind Tuk Tuk Thai Food Loft, and whose parents gave Atlanta spots like Nan Thai Fine Dining, the now-defunct Tamarind and the temporarily closed Tamarind Seed, Chai Yo is contemporary in look, feel and flavor.

Open since January in Two Buckhead Plaza, Chai Yo fits in just fine next to glam neighbors Umi, Atlas, Chops Lobster Bar, Seasons 52 and King + Duke in the heart of see-and-be-seen Buckhead. Marked by wood, clean lines, Zen-inducing back-lit sculptures and artwork, the space is stylish but still calm and comfortable whether you are seated at the bar with a view into the kitchen or parked on a long banquette with colorful patterned silk pillows that separate dining parties.

<<Review: Wicked Sushi in Buford

<<Where to find the best chicken salad around Atlanta

Most dishes — and even drinks — at Chai Yo are as composed as the space. Take, for example, the Saku Sai Kai. The appetizer brings a rustic log serving platter that holds five round tapioca dumplings filled with shrimp and chicken and topped with bits of red chile peppers and crushed peanuts. Credit the chile peppers that these dumplings are more like fireballs, which is why you need to chase them with a wad of cooling bibb lettuce upon which they rest.

The Lemongrass Lily is one of a number of nonalcoholic beverages (these “refreshers” are listed on the lunch menu but are available during dinner service) that impress not just for the presentation — frothy egg white topper with a few dashes of bitters and served in respectable glassware — but the effort to create a lineup of teetotaler drinks that are balanced, beautiful and reasonably priced at $6.

Chai Yo is not just about looks. Niyomkul keeps things relevant and lively, incorporating ingredients from here and techniques from now. Think back to that tasty Nam Prik Ong and the decision to include a Southern snack like pork cracklings into the mix.

She also disses authenticity when she gives a decidedly non-Thai protein like beef cheeks some non-Thai cooking treatment (a sous vide bath) to turn out the melt-in-your-mouth Neau Panang entree. The beef cheeks sit in a lap-it-up, rich red curry served in a charming mini chafing dish. The same dare-to-be-different attitude can be said for including octopus in lemongrass salad, although results met with less success: The grilled octo came out rubbery. It was still more memorable than the Lobster Tom Kha coconut soup and vegetarian spring rolls that hold more garnish than substance.

It is far less of a pocketbook stretch to peruse the appetizer section of the menu than the mains. The beef cheeks hold value, but lobster curry was a waste of $45 since peanut drowned out all other flavors. Lamb chops were of steakhouse quality, but the accompanying dipping sauce was mouthpuckeringly sour. Duck Leg Stew brought a drab brown braised leg over jasmine rice, which surprised, considering the numerous other decorated dishes coming from the kitchen. Neither tea egg nor tofu helped to dress it up or bring cohesion to the dish.

Pad Thai traditionalists will find a version with eggs that are used as a crepe base upon which cellophane noodles et al. are piled. Although generous in portion, as most Chai Yo dishes are, tamarind permeated the entire dish, with citrus and sour notes commanding everything.

The seared Chilean sea bass, though, was a surprise delight. The white fish was fresh, moist and flaky, complemented by a light, almost delicate, crab fried rice, wilted bok choy and a garlic-cilantro-black pepper sauce that I spooned onto every bite.

The fish also cost $42.

Then again, when we go to Buckhead, we know the drill: Expensive real estate equals expensive plates. What’s unexpected — and unacceptable at a restaurant of this price point — is not fixing its restroom locks even when the staff knows they are broken. Doubly so when those restrooms are unisex. In the least, putting a sign on the door stating that the lock is broken would give patrons a heads-up when their pants are down, an embarrassment that occurred to two people in my party.

It’s a level of hospitality I would have expected from a place that otherwise attends quite well to the needs of its patrons. Sometimes, the waitstaff can overly attend, as when a server came by the table at least six times during one visit to top off water glasses the size of chemistry vials.

These complaints aside, I’m encouraged by Niyomkul’s undertaking. As with dining ventures from other children of immigrant restaurateurs in Atlanta, the food coming out of Chai Yo feels at once personal to her, approachable for diners, relevant to this place and time and still respectful of the cuisine from the motherland. That’s an accomplishment, and one not nearly as easy to achieve as phoning a locksmith to fix the loo.

Chai Yo Modern Thai

Overall rating: 2 of 4 stars (very good)

Food: upscale, contemporary Thai

Service: gracious and attentive

Best dishes: Saku Sai Kai (tapioca dumplings), Nam Prik Ong (northern Thai-style chile dip), Neau Panang (Panang beef cheeks), Pla Kra Tiem Prik Thai (Garlic sea bass)

Vegetarian selections: Pho Pia Thod (spring rolls), curries and Tom Kha (coconut soup) can be prepared vegetarian.

Price range: $$$$

Credit cards: all major credit cards

Hours: Lunch: 11:30 a.m.-2:30 p.m. Mondays-Fridays; dinner: 5:30-10 p.m. Mondays-Thursdays, 5:30-11 p.m. Fridays, 5-11 p.m. Saturdays, 5-10 p.m. Sundays

Children: not recommended

Parking: paid parking garage ($2 valet with validation)

MARTA station: Lenox

Reservations: not necessary

Wheelchair access: yes

Noise level: medium

Patio: no

Takeout: not recommended

Address, phone: 3050 Peachtree Road NW, Atlanta. 404-464-7980

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Food

What's all this rain doing to the 2018 vintage? It depends on where you are.

Mother Nature seems to be playing her usual tricks this spring. Cool weather and seemingly incessant rains dampened spirits here in the mid-Atlantic, with flooded cities in the headlines. Perhaps it's the wine nerd in me, but the other day as I was squeegeeing the dog, I wondered what effect this weather was having on vineyards. The 2018 vintage is...
Buss up shut: The Caribbean roti with a catchy name
Buss up shut: The Caribbean roti with a catchy name

There are many styles of roti - none of which should be confused with the fast-casual chain Roti Modern Mediterranean. In places serving the food of Trinidad and Tobago, you're bound to find paratha, also called "buss up shut" (the vernacular for "busted-up shirt"), apropos of the bread's remarkable resemblance to a torn shirt....
A tiki restaurant is coming to Virginia-Highland
A tiki restaurant is coming to Virginia-Highland

A Hawaiian tiki concept licensed from a rock star is coming to Virginia-Highland. Tiki Iniki is set to take over the space at 1044 Greenwood Ave. previously occupied by Illegal Food, What Now Atlanta first reported. Todd Rundgren and his wife, Michele, opened Tiki Iniki in 2013 in Princeville, Hawaii. Rundgren is best known for hits such...
The Whiskey Project opens today in Roswell and other metro Atlanta dining news from the week
The Whiskey Project opens today in Roswell and other metro Atlanta dining news from the week

Here are the stories that made a splash in the Atlanta food world this week. Sweet potato curry, lime cream, spiced pecans, micro greens on the menu at The Whiskey Project The Whiskey Project is opening for dinner service tonight at 5 p.m. in Roswell. Located at 45 Oak St. in the the former home of the now-shuttered Oak Street Cafe, The...
Beer Pick: Wild Heaven Watermelon Blend Emergency Drinking Beer
Beer Pick: Wild Heaven Watermelon Blend Emergency Drinking Beer

Credit: Reid Ramsay/Beer Street Journal Father’s Day weekend is ahead of us, and warm weather is upon us.   Wrecking Bar Brewpub’s Seventh Anniversary Weekend kicks off today. And many more area breweries will be hosting Father’s Day events on Sunday.   But Wild Heaven will be celebrating...
More Stories