Life with Harper Lee: Writer offers warm portrait of famed author

In 2005, when biographer Charles Shields requested an audience with Harper Lee, the reclusive author of “To Kill a Mockingbird” not only told him no, but “hell no.”

She also instructed her friends to give Shields the brush-off.

It was a typical response from Lee, who, for more than 40 years after the publication of her Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, fended off almost every entreaty from the press.


In 2001 Marja Mills, who will appear at the Carter Center on Thursday, June 18, struck up a friendship when she profiled Lee for the Chicago Tribune. Three years later Mills moved to Monroeville, Ala., renting the house next door to Lee’s home, shared by her older sister Alice.

For 18 months Mills and the Lee sisters shared meals, took road trips, watched football games, sipped coffee and visited back and forth with the Lees’ extended circle of friends and relations.

While Shields was cooling his heels in the foyer, Mills was in the inner sanctum. Mills’ 2014 memoir, “The Mockingbird Next Door: Life With Harper Lee,” just released in paperback, tells the story of that remarkable access.

There are many things it doesn’t tell. It doesn’t dwell on the friction between Harper Lee and her hometown, which led her to boycott the town’s staging of a theatrical version of the novel; it also led Lee’s attorney to file suit against the town’s history center for selling unlicensed “Mockingbird”-themed coasters, plastic tumblers and seat cushions.

It doesn’t tell of the 2007 stroke that ended Lee’s independence and sent her to an assisted living facility in Monroeville. That stroke occurred two years after Mills returned to her Chicago high-rise.

And nowhere does Harper Lee suggest to Mills that she has the manuscript for an earlier book hidden in a “secure location.” Yet such a book, called “Go Set a Watchman,” was discovered by Lee’s attorney, Tonja Carter and will be published next month by HarperCollins in a first printing of 2 million copies.

The discovery was the literary bombshell of the year: a “lost” sequel to a landmark novel written by an author known for writing one book and one book only.

The new book follows “Mockingbird’s” protagonist, Scout, who returns as an adult to the fictional Maycomb — a thinly-disguised Monroeville.

A meticulously-reported story in the Washington Post (with help from Shields) suggests that “Watchman” is not a first novel but simply the first draft of “Mockingbird.”

Others have questioned whether Lee, now debilitated by the stroke, actually approves of the book being released. Carter has vigorously affirmed that Lee was excited by the discovery. Carter also traded barbs with Alice Lee about the veracity of Mills’ memoir, claiming that Harper Lee did not cooperate as portrayed. Alice Lee died last November at age 103.

Into this brier patch, Mills treads gently. About “Go Set A Watchman,” she says, carefully, that the “circumstances around this can’t help but color how I feel about this (book) coming out.”

But, she adds, “so many people have told me that they savor the idea of being able to read more about Scout — to read the thoughts of an adult Scout returning to Monroeville.”

She said she doesn’t know if either Lee sister read her book, but never heard a response. Mills will speak about these and other issues at the Carter Center, though she is reticent on some questions.

Would Harper Lee, who Mills last saw in 2010, approve of her “forgotten” manuscript appearing as a new book? Mills would prefer not to guess.

“I think people will read this with a generous eye, knowing that this was an early effort.”

Mills is emphatic about one point: Alice Lee and Harper Lee (who is known in Monroeville by her first name, Nelle), both generously let Mills into their lives, at a moment that stands out as the end of an era.

Her memoir “ends up being a chronicle of the last chapter of life as they had known it all those years,” she said. “For so long they had certain routines and rhythms of life. And they invited me along for that.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Living

CNN’s ‘This is Life With Lisa Ling’ season 5 tackles MS13, screen addiction, gender identity, “furries”
CNN’s ‘This is Life With Lisa Ling’ season 5 tackles MS13, screen addiction, gender identity, “furries”

Lisa Ling has a dream job for any curious, empathetic journalist: she gets to travel the United States immersing herself in different - often maligned or misunderstood - subcultures to try to understand participants’ motivations and psyches. Called “This is Life with Lisa Ling,” the CNN hour-long weekly series returns for a fifth...
‘Lizzie’ features some killer performances
‘Lizzie’ features some killer performances

The story of how Lizzie Borden was accused in 1892 of taking an ax and killing her father and stepmother has been fodder for films, TV shows, a rock musical and a child’s jump rope game. Although Borden was acquitted of the murders, the general thinking is that she got away with murder. So much notoriety created a challenge for screenwriter Bryce...
Kusama’s true medium might be expression of her state of mind
Kusama’s true medium might be expression of her state of mind

In the afterglow of the most Instagrammable art exhibition ever, “Yayoi Kusama: Infinity Mirrors” — a show that drew nearly 160,000 visitors to the Hirshhorn Museum and Sculpture Garden in Washington, D.C., last year, and is currently a popular draw at the Cleveland Museum of Art — you may have found yourself wanting to know...
A few thoughts over morning coffee
A few thoughts over morning coffee

A few thoughts over morning coffee… From the Feedback Department: Certain recent columns of mine have drawn a spike in reader responses, both pro and con. My comments on the fact that young teachers are and have been for quite some time ill-prepared to deal with the realities of classroom discipline prompted a former professor of education to...
Bluer skies herald autumn’s arrival
Bluer skies herald autumn’s arrival

It might sneak by you, but autumn officially arrives at 9:54 p.m. today — the autumnal equinox. Sunday will be the first full day of the season. Fall’s more visible signs are everywhere now: Goldenrods, asters and other fall wildflowers are in full bloom. Meadows sport a purple tint from blooming Joe-Pye weed and ironweed. Acorns, wild...
More Stories