Review: See Alliance’s ‘A Christmas Carol’ now, or it will haunt you

The next time you see a lonely soul, shut off from the warmth of the world, don’t judge.

Read closely the text of Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol.” Follow carefully David H. Bell’s magnificent Alliance Theatre treatment of the Victorian text. And you will see that the crusty, miserly Ebenezer Scrooge is a man with a broken heart.

But in life as in literature, man’s capacity for spiritual awakening springs eternal.

Even on the coldest days of winter, even when generous, good-hearted people have been evicted from their homes, even when hardworking families have sick children and very little to eat, there is light.

For 27 years, the Alliance has brought Dickens’ London to Peachtree Street. Bell’s treatment, with its integrated cast, haunting music, prop-laden stage and glitzy special effects, arrived around the time I started reviewing theater for this newspaper in 2001, and over the years, it has become a sentimental favorite.

Year after year, thoughtful directors (like the current Rosemary Newcott) refine and tweak. Actors come and go. Tiny Tims grow up. But the show never fails me. I’m always crushed by Belle’s jilting of Scrooge, by the Fezziwigs’ loss of fortune, by the Cratchit family’s pure love. And I’m always reminted by Scrooge’s 11th-hour transformation.

If you’ve postponed seeing this production, or haven’t yet seen David de Vries’ deliciously intimidating take on Scrooge, time is of the essence.

When the Alliance closes for renovation next year, it will produce its 2017-2018 season at temporary spaces across the city. Yes, Bell’s “Christmas Carol” will be staged at some as-yet-unannounced location in 2017, but never again on this stage. When the Alliance unveils the new Coca-Cola Stage in the fall of 2018, it will produce a new adaptation of “Christmas Carol” by Bell.

For now, let us bask in the splendors before us: the creme de la creme of the Atlanta theater community all tied up here under one big bow. (Literally, if you look at D Martyn Bookwalter’s set, with its soaring arched window, festooned with red ribbon.)

I can’t say enough good things about Neal Ghant (Bob Cratchit), Ann Marie Gideon (Belle and others), Joe Knezevich (Fred), Lowrey Brown (Young Scrooge), Bart Hansard (Mr. Fezziwig, Ghost of Christmas Present) and Minka Wiltz (in a variety of smaller but highly memorable roles, including a filthy junk dealer and street vendor hawking “fine Spanish onions,” of all things).

Ghant is the sort of actor who can arouse laughter without saying a word. (Just watch his expression when Cratchit beholds his newly generous boss man.) Hansard is indubitably the best person in the city to play the portly, frog-shaped Fezziwig. Brown’s prophetic profession that he is unworthy of Belle’s love is deeply moving. And Wiltz’s lilting and radiant operatic voice is never lost in the noisy din of London. (I hear you!)

And then there’s the pint-size Marco Schittone. The kid’s got Broadway credentials already, and may well be the most polished and articulate Tiny Tim I’ve witnessed. (And I’ve seen a lot.) Chris Kayser, who handed Scrooge’s sleeping cap to de Vries in 2014, is back as Marley, and he’s a cold, icy ghost to be sure.

De Vries, for his part, is fully transformed into a glowering and formidable Scrooge. His take is finely nuanced, never over-the-top. That is, until he becomes the bouncing, buoyantly happy, born-again child in the old man’s body.

Well played, and God bless you, everyone. You’ll be missed.


“A Christmas Carol”

Grade: A

7:30 p.m. Tuesdays-Thursdays and Sundays; 8 p.m. Fridays-Saturdays; 2:30 p.m. Saturdays-Sundays. Through Dec. 24. There will be no performances on Dec. 2, no 7:30 p.m. performance on Dec. 4, no performance on Dec. 7 and Dec. 9, no 7:30 p.m. performance on Dec. 11, and no performance on Dec. 14. There will be extra 2:30 p.m. performances on Dec. 21-23. $20-$72. Alliance Theatre, 1280 Peachtree St. N.E., Atlanta. 404-733-5000,

Bottom line: Last chance to see this masterful Dickens adaptation on this stage.

MORE: Theater review: Ralphie in pursuit of a BB gun, with song and dance

MORE: 7 locations in metro Atlanta and beyond for holiday light shows

MORE: Where to find holiday classical music performances in metro Atlanta

MORE: Atlanta holiday concerts: Dave Koz, Amy Grant, R. Kelly and more

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Living

When hate strikes in North Fulton, a community comes bearing gifts
When hate strikes in North Fulton, a community comes bearing gifts

Last Friday, not far from the place where six teens allegedly scrawled anti-Semitic drawings on Hilary Karp’s driveway, Erik Schefstad, his wife, Carson, and one of their two children came hoping to communicate a decidedly different message, and it blew Karp away. Actually, they came bearing many messages, about two dozen total that, taken together...
Festival preview: Tedeschi Trucks Band ready for its SweetWater 420 Fest closeup
Festival preview: Tedeschi Trucks Band ready for its SweetWater 420 Fest closeup

BY MELISSA RUGGIERI/AJC Music Scene The Tedeschi Trucks Band is renowned for its commitment to meaty, visceral concerts. Last summer, the 12-piece musical crew led by Susan Tedeschi and her husband, Derek Trucks, rolled into the Fox Theatre for a memorable night on its annual “Wheels of Soul” tour. It was also Trucks and Tedeschi&rsquo...
Concert preview: Bon Jovi returns to Atlanta fresh from Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction
Concert preview: Bon Jovi returns to Atlanta fresh from Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction

BY MELISSA RUGGIERI/AJC Music Scene Bon Jovi stole the show, as usual. At least that was the consensus following last weekend’s Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction ceremony, at which the enduring New Jersey rockers were finally granted entry into the Cleveland shrine. Between an expectedly uproarious introductory speech by longtime...
Charges could be announced in Prince opioid investigation two years after his death
Charges could be announced in Prince opioid investigation two years after his death

Authorities in Carver County, Minnesota, could announce charges Thursday in the investigation into the opioid-related death of legendary entertainer Prince two years after he died, according to news outlets. >> Read more trending news  Prince was found unresponsive at his Paisley Park home in Chanhassen on April 21, 2016, and was later pronounced...
For Barbara Bush, Georgia was a place of love and legacy

For much of her life, Barbara Bush had Georgia on her mind. Her 73-year marriage began in 1945 with a honeymoon trip to the Cloister at Sea Island; she and George H.W. Bush were back in 1995 for their 50th anniversary. Her literacy foundation has partnered with programs across the state, and she was instrumental in helping Morehouse...
More Stories