Kempner: Trump’s ‘genius,’ or Tax Law 101?


The word “genius” was brutally maligned this week. It deserves an apology from Rudy Giuliani.

The former New York City mayor labeled his buddy Donald Trump a “genius” because he apparently used nearly $1 billion in business losses to avoid paying any federal income taxes, possibly for years.

I’m sure Trump is a smart cookie.

The billionaire presidential candidate has shared with us that he used tax laws “brilliantly.”

But I don’t understand why losing a billion dollars is genius. (Heck, I’m pretty sure I could do it, given a chance.) Or how listening to accountants suggest what looks like a Tax Accounting 101 maneuver is a sign of capitalistic brilliance.

Others can hash over politics. From a solely business perspective, nothing so far indicates Trump did anything differently from what other businesses would do after suffering a nearly catastrophic failure. (As Trump did in the 1990s with his casinos and the Trump Shuttle airline.)

In fact, as my colleagues have written, Delta Air Lines hasn’t paid federal income taxes on billions of dollars in profit in recent years because of past losses, and it’s just one example.

Sure, it’s weird to have a modern presidential candidate who didn’t pay federal income taxes. It makes some people think something fishy or at least unethical is going on, at least as Hillary Clinton would have us believe.

Looking to maximize tax breaks isn’t just a Trump thing. It’s what lots of Americans pursue.

It’s why it seems like roughly nine out of every eight Americans are accountants or tax preparers. It’s why every Dec. 31 police have to direct traffic at Goodwill centers as people rush to get in tax breaks by donating old Beastie Boys t-shirts, Kiss albums, TV trays and a tidal wave of vases.

There’s no denying the tax code is a mess that has become undecipherable for many Americans. Federal tax laws and regulations encompass more than 10 million words. That’s a whole lot of tax loopholes, switchbacks, tricks and treasures for special interests or anyone with enough time and money to dig.

But Trump’s people may not have needed to do much mining to come up with a strategy highlighted in a New York Times story suggesting he could have used $916 million in losses to sidestep paying federal income taxes for nearly two decades.

“Any student who has taken an intro to tax class should know that a net operating loss can be carried forward to future years,” said Bridget Stomberg, a University of Georgia accounting professor.

“It’s basic,” said Dorothy Brown, an Emory University law professor and scholar in tax policy. “None of this stuff is particularly groundbreaking.”

She told me that if tax attorneys didn’t know to pursue this kind of move, they could be sued for malpractice.

So both Brown and Stomberg seemed confused about where the “genius” and brilliant words apply.

“I don’t think anything about this reflects savvy as a businessman,” Stomberg said.

When there are hairy, complex tax issues, most big business leaders aren’t feverishly scouring tax codes in the middle of the night, creating new tactics on their own. That’s what people like Trump pay their accountants and tax attorneys to do.

“If there’s a genius, it is not the guy who signed the return, but the person who prepared the return,” Brown told me.

Of course, we can debate the justness of a system in which we’re all supposed to pay our fair share unless we have the money to figure out ways to pay less. (Or we make so little that we get a full pass.)

Stomberg told me there’s a rational reason to let business owners use legitimate business losses to reduce their taxes over many years.

“Economics is lumpy. Business goes through cycles.”

The tax provision, she said, is designed so it doesn’t deter businesses from taking risks.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

All-new Chevy SUV, the Blazer, debuts in Atlanta
All-new Chevy SUV, the Blazer, debuts in Atlanta

Chevrolet unveiled the newest vehicle in its lineup, the Blazer, in Atlanta Thursday night, reviving the defunct SUV with a smaller version. Alan Batey, General Motors’ North American president, made the announcement at an event at The Fairmont in Atlanta, showing off a model of the mid-size SUV, which features a slimmer, more athletic front...
UPS, Teamsters reach tentative labor agreement
UPS, Teamsters reach tentative labor agreement

UPS and the Teamsters union have reached a tentative agreement on a new five-year labor deal, which if approved could alleviate the risk of a strike. The settlement in principle of the national master UPS agreement is subject to approval by UPS local unions. Yet to be resolved are supplemental agreements, according to the Teamsters. The final deal...
Wes Moss: How to head into retirement with no mortgage
Wes Moss: How to head into retirement with no mortgage

“Should we pay off our mortgage before we retire?” This is among the most common questions I get from clients and “Money Matters” listeners (tune in from 9-11 a.m. Sundays on WSB radio (News 95.5 and AM 750 WSB). I most recently heard it from a couple who are on their final approach for retirement. Let’s call them Rose...
Chevrolet announces all-new Chevy Blazer in Atlanta
Chevrolet announces all-new Chevy Blazer in Atlanta

Chevrolet unveiled the newest vehicle in its lineup, the Chevy Blazer, in Atlanta Thursday night, reviving the discontinued Trailblazer with a smaller version of the utility vehicle. Alan Batey, General Motors’ North American president, made the announcement at an event at The Fairmont in Atlanta, showing off a model of the mid-sized SUV, which...
Mayor Kasim Reed aides got late term promotions to Hartsfield-Jackson
Mayor Kasim Reed aides got late term promotions to Hartsfield-Jackson

Former Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed’s administration transferred two employees from City Hall to high-paying positions at Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport in the final days of Reed’s term. Both worked closely with Reed, one as an executive assistant to the mayor and the other as a scheduling coordinator, and both were promoted to the...
More Stories