Kempner: Last assignment for Equifax's ex? Survive Capitol Hill 


Speak really slowly and stall when testifying before hostile lawmakers on Capitol Hill, a corporate executive once suggested. But that won’t be an easy task for former Equifax CEO Richard “Rick” Smith this week.

Starting today, Smith is slated to be on the hot seat in multiple House and Senate hearings digging into Atlanta-based Equifax’s massive breach of sensitive data on 143 million — oops, now it’s more than 145 million — people.

Plenty of consumers are rightfully angry. So it’s likely to be ugly for Smith.

Politicians sometimes aren’t shy about jumping in when we fume at corporations that mess up or try our patience.

“Why do you hate the American people?” a lawmaker asked United Airlines’ chief in a hearing this year after the carrier had a paying passenger forcibly removed from a jet.

Or how about the time when CEOs of big automakers asked Congress for bailout money, but flew into town on private jets? “It’s almost like seeing a guy show up at the soup kitchen in a high hat and tuxedo,” a congressman said.

Or when Wells Fargo’s then-CEO showed up to talk about how his employees opened up fake accounts without the knowledge of customers. Said one lawmaker, “You ought to be ashamed of yourself.”

Or when a former pharmaceutical boss smiled and pleaded the Fifth when asked about big price increases on a crucial drug. 

I watched the archived advice of another executive who had been through the political chipper and lived to lecture about it.

“Once you see the theater of it, the intimidation factor kind of goes away,” Doug Curling said during a videotaped talk a few years ago at the University of Georgia’s business school.

Curling was second in command at ChoicePoint, another Atlanta-based data giant that was supposed to be really secure but couldn’t keep a fraudster from snatching consumers’ sensitive information. Curling and ChoicePoint’s CEO, Derek Smith, both got called to the Capitol Hill woodshed. That was 12 years ago.

“You should work very, very hard to be non-confrontational and try to get out of there as quickly as you can,” Curling would later tell his UGA listeners.

Giving donations to elected officials “does not get you favors” or prevent abusive committee questions, he said, but it may help land one-on-one meetings with lawmakers the day before a hearing “to do a little warm-up with them and help them to understand your view.”

Curling said he got advice from experts who specialize in prepping executives for time before congressional panels. They worked with him for three days straight, practicing a barrage of potential questions.

One tip they gave him: never sit on either end of a hearing table. People in those positions get questioned more.

When Curling testified, each senator had only five minutes to ask questions and get answers.

“So use the filibuster rule,” Curling advised our future business leaders. “Don’t be in a hurry to talk. … Try to eat the clock for five minutes.”

You should also be respectful, helpful and direct, he said. And have a paper with prepared questions and answers, for times when it’s really important to stay on script.

In his particular hearing, Curling said many lawmakers left the room after the first few minutes, dipping back in only when it was their turn to ask questions. Seeing that helped erode the intimidation factor, he said.

Equifax’s Smith is in a bit of a different position. He “retired” recently after the company’s continued bungling following disclosure of the cyber breach. So it’s not like Smith can make meaningful promises that Equifax will do a better job of protecting our information in the future.

He can try to prevent any further shredding of his and Equifax’s tattered reputations. 

That won’t be easy. Lawmakers from both parties may take swings.

“It has the potential to be a double pile on. I can’t imagine very many people defending this guy,” said William LaForge, a former longtime D.C. lobbyist and former Senate staffer who literally wrote the book “Testifying Before Congress.”

Lawmakers will try to root out the facts of what happened. But some also will jump at the opportunity for a bit of “showmanship,” said LaForge, who is now the president of Delta State University in Mississippi.

“There will certainly be crowing politicians.”

MYAJC.COM: REAL JOURNALISM. REAL LOCAL IMPACT.

AJC Unofficial Business columnist Matt Kempner offers you a unique look at the business scene in metro Atlanta and beyond. You'll find more on myAJC.com, including these columns:

Never miss a minute of what's happening in local business news. Subscribe to myAJC.com.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

Atlanta ranks 10th in population increase, U.S. Census Bureau reports
Atlanta ranks 10th in population increase, U.S. Census Bureau reports

Among the U.S. cities with the biggest jump in population, Atlanta ranked 10th last year, according to a newly released report by the U.S. Census Bureau. The city saw an influx of 13,323 new residents between July 2016 and July 2017, translating to about 36 people moving in each day. Nationally, at the top of the list, San Antonio registered the largest...
New bank law spurs both support and criticism in Georgia
New bank law spurs both support and criticism in Georgia

Some Georgia bankers joined U.S. Sen. David Perdue in praising this week’s rollback of the Dodd-Frank law’s restrictions on banks, although consumer groups criticized the measure. The new banking law, signed by President Trump on Thursday, loosens the restraints on banks that were put in place by the Dodd-Frank law after the financial...
Weak job growth in metro Atlanta last month
Weak job growth in metro Atlanta last month

Metro Atlanta saw weak job growth in April, although the unemployment rate dropped as thousands of people stopped looking for work, according to a report Thursday from the state department of labor. Although April is typically a strong month for hiring, the economy added just 8,100 jobs – less than half the average growth during the previous...
Delta plans to restart flights to Mumbai
Delta plans to restart flights to Mumbai

Delta Air Lines said it plans to restart nonstop flights from the United States to Mumbai next year. Atlanta-based Delta made the announcement in the wake of U.S. agreements reached earlier this year with Qatar and the United Arab Emirates.  Delta spokesman Trebor Banstetter said the new flights would be from Atlanta or New York. The...
Delta ranks near top in on-time performance for first quarter
Delta ranks near top in on-time performance for first quarter

Atlanta-based Delta Air Lines ranked near the top among U.S. carriers for on-time performance in the first quarter of the year, according to a federal report. For January-March 2018, Delta was No. 2 for punctuality with an 86.37 percent on-time arrival rate, according to the U.S. Bureau of Transportation Statistics. Alaska Airlines held the No. 1 spot...
More Stories