Critics concerned: Bill’s provisions look like win for Equifax


Less than seven months after revealing a massive data breach, Equifax appears to be poised for a big win in Washington.

A financial regulatory bill on the verge of Senate passage would give Equifax protection from some class action suits, while forcing government-controlled companies to at least consider using an Equifax-backed company to judge people applying for mortgages.

VIDEO: Previous Equifax coverage

Equifax revealed in early September that personal information of more than 145 million Americans on its computers had been accessed or stolen. In the weeks following that, the company faced a fusillade of criticism, a number of class action lawsuits and often-venomous questioning by members of Congress.

However, no legislative action has been taken to restrict the company.

The current proposals – as well as the lack of action to punish Equifax or enact new data protection standards since the breach – are indefensible, said Liz Coyle, executive director of Georgia Watch, a non-partisan consumer advocacy group. “People should be shocked that Congress has done nothing to hold Equifax accountable.”

Military members especially should not be deprived of their day in court, she said. “We send our troops to protect our rights as American citizens and we can’t even let a band of brothers come together to protect themselves?”

The language was proposed last week as an addition to broader legislation repealing parts of the Dodd-Frank financial regulatory law. The Senate is expected to pass the measure with bipartisan support later this week.

The Equifax language, which must still be formally incorporated into the broader bill,  would force Equifax and the two other major credit agencies to provide free credit freezes and free credit monitoring for members of the military.

But it would also protect the company from any class action lawsuits sprouting from those requirements.

The bill would also force Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to consider using VantageScore, a joint venture of Equifax and the other two agencies, Experian and TransUnion. The two mortgage giants have primarily been using FICO, a competitor of VantageScore.

In response to the news about the bill’s provisions Equifax issued a brief statement on Tuesday implicitly endorsing the measure and its supporters.

“Equifax shares the sponsor’s goal of helping consumers gain access to credit and having more control over their personal credit data,” said Meredith Griffanti. “Security freezes are one of the many tools available which enable consumers to better protect themselves against potential identity theft.”

She declined to address the provision that prevents lawsuits.

Equifax spent months after the hack lobbying Congress on issues such as credit freezes, requirements for when it must notify consumers after data breaches and what it described in its federal disclosure forms as “active duty credit services.”

Last year, the credit bureau also lobbied Congress on a bill authored by Cassville GOP Congressman Barry Loudermilk that would have curbed the use of class action lawsuits against credit bureaus such as Equifax.

That bill was shelved after the Equifax breach became known.

Although U.S. Sen. David Perdue was unavailable for comment Tuesday, he has co-authored credit freezing legislation similar to what is contained now in the bill and at least some of his suggestions are included. Perdue is a member of the banking committee.

Both Perdue and his Georgia GOP colleague Johnny Isakson have voted to advance the underlying legislation in recent days.

With Republicans in control of the Senate and some Democrats crossing the aisle to back the bill, the proposal – and most of its provisions – are expected to win approval. Still, the provisions affecting Equifax immediately drew scorching criticism.

In a conference call with reporters Tuesday, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., said it was not fair to give veterans the right to free credit monitoring and then forbid legal action if their data was misused.

“That is not a consumer protection provision,” she said. “That is an Equifax protection provision.”

There should be automatic penalties for permitting hackers to see consumer data, Warren said. “Equifax does not have incentives to take the necessary measures to protect Americans’ data.”

The company earlier this month reported an increase in profits.

MYAJC.COM: REAL JOURNALISM. REAL LOCAL IMPACT.

AJC Business reporter Michael E. Kanell keeps you updated on the latest news about jobs, housing and consumer issues in metro Atlanta and beyond. You'll find more on myAJC.com, including these stories:

Never miss a minute of what's happening in local business news. Subscribe to myAJC.com. 



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

Chevrolet announces all-new Chevy Blazer in Atlanta
Chevrolet announces all-new Chevy Blazer in Atlanta

Chevrolet unveiled the newest vehicle in its lineup, the Chevy Blazer, in Atlanta Thursday night, reviving the discontinued Trailblazer with a smaller version of the utility vehicle. Alan Batey, General Motors’ North American president, made the announcement at an event at The Fairmont in Atlanta, showing off a model of the mid-sized SUV, which...
Mayor Kasim Reed aides got late term promotions to Hartsfield-Jackson
Mayor Kasim Reed aides got late term promotions to Hartsfield-Jackson

Former Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed’s administration transferred two employees from City Hall to high-paying positions at Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport in the final days of Reed’s term. Both worked closely with Reed, one as an executive assistant to the mayor and the other as a scheduling coordinator, and both were promoted to the...
Hiring in metro Atlanta powers state in May; unemployment rate down
Hiring in metro Atlanta powers state in May; unemployment rate down

May was a good month for hiring in metro Atlanta as the region saw solid job growth and an unemployment rate falling to its lowest point since 2001. About 12,400 jobs were added, according to the state Department of Labor. But the most-cited economic number is typically the unemployment rate. In most years, that rate holds even or rises from April...
Kempner: Trump and non-Trump business partners agree on refugees, jobs
Kempner: Trump and non-Trump business partners agree on refugees, jobs

I met a Trump supporter and a not-Trump supporter the other day. Funny thing: they were getting along. Even when they were talking politics. It turns out they have a lot in common. Chris Chancey and Luke Keller are friends and co-owners of an unusual and growing for-profit Georgia staffing agency that specializes in placing refugees. Amplio Recruiting...
Porsche announces investment in Croatian electric car company

German car manufacturer Porsche announced Wednesday it has purchased a 10 percent minority stake in Rimac Automobili, a Croatian manufacturer specializing in electric sports cars and electric car parts. The investment is the latest move by Porsche towards an increased focus on the electric car market. Porsche, which has its North American headquarters...
More Stories