Consumer groups slam Equifax over security breach arbitration clause

Consumer watchdogs criticized Atlanta-based Equifax on Friday for its offer of a package of credit and identity theft protection services in the wake of a giant data breach, because of fine print they say could limit consumers’ recourse in the event of dispute.

Consumer groups say a clause in the terms of use bind them to arbitration, giving away consumers’ right to a trial.

On Thursday, Equifax reported a breach exposed the personal information, including Social Security numbers, of 143 million U.S. consumers. In response, the company said it would provide a free one-year package of credit monitoring and ID protection, which CEO Rick Smith called an unprecedented step.

The terms of use for the TrustedID Premier service said “all claims, disputes, or controversies raised” by consumers or the company “shall be finally settled by arbitration.”

“By consenting to submit your claims to arbitration, you will be forfeiting your right to bring or participate in any class action,” the terms state.

Many consumer groups worry that clause meant victims of the hack couldn’t sue or join a class-action case against Equifax for the cyber breach.

In a statement, Equifax disputed that. The company said the arbitration clause and waiver for class action cases “applies to the free credit file monitoring and identity theft protection products, and not the cybersecurity incident.”

Corporations in many industries have pushed to move disputes with customers to arbitration rather than the courts.

Lawsuits are costly, take longer and in many cases, businesses have an upper hand outside the traditional justice system, an investigation by The New York Times found.

Consumer Watchdog of California said in a news release that the offer may violate California law, and asked the state’s attorney general, Xavier Becerra, to investigate.

Eric Sneiderman, the New York attorney general, called the clauses “unacceptable and unenforceable,” on Twitter. He later said, after Equifax released a statement to clarify that the terms do not apply to the cyber-attack, that his office is “continuing to closely review” the situation.

Liz Coyle of Georgia Watch, a consumer advocacy group, said the clauses are buried in fine print few will read in a time of distress.

“Nobody reads the fine print. It’s really outrageous,” she said.


AJC Business reporter J. Scott Trubey keeps you updated on the latest news about economic development and commercial real estate in metro Atlanta and beyond. You'll find more on, including these stories:

Never miss a minute of what's happening in local business news. Subscribe to

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Business

Porsche announces investment in Croatian electric car company

German car manufacturer Porsche announced Wednesday it has purchased a 10 percent minority stake in Rimac Automobili, a Croatian manufacturer specializing in electric sports cars and electric car parts. The investment is the latest move by Porsche towards an increased focus on the electric car market. Porsche, which has its North American headquarters...
Delta CEO opposes idea of state takeover of Hartsfield-Jackson
Delta CEO opposes idea of state takeover of Hartsfield-Jackson

Delta CEO Ed Bastian said he opposes a state takeover of Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport, as Georgia’s legislature plans a committee to study the idea. “Atlanta is the largest, most successful airport in the world, and anything that would harm that in terms of trying to move it for political gain between the city and state...
AMC Theatres announces $20-a-month rival to MoviePass
AMC Theatres announces $20-a-month rival to MoviePass

AMC Theatres, the world's largest movie theater chain, has unveiled a $20-a-month subscription service to rival the fledgling MoviePass. The theater chain on Wednesday announced a new service to its loyalty program, AMC Stubs, allowing subscribers to see up to three movies a week for a monthly fee of $19.95. That's more expensive than the $9.95 monthly...
SunTrust aims to spread name with airport branch, ATMs
SunTrust aims to spread name with airport branch, ATMs

By opening a branch and ATMs at the world’s busiest airport, SunTrust hopes to gain national visibility. The Atlanta-based bank has a new contract to operate a branch and 16 ATMs at Hartsfield-Jackson International in the first quarter of 2019, replacing Wells Fargo ATMs. And with the Super Bowl headed for Atlanta next February, SunTrust plans...
Atlanta-based Interface in $420 million purchase of German company
Atlanta-based Interface in $420 million purchase of German company

Atlanta-based Interface has made a $420 million deal to buy a German company that is a leader in the global flooring market. Interface is acquiring Nora Systems, a move that the company said should dramatically expand its market reach to new categories. The two companies are more “complementary” than competitive, said Jay...
More Stories