Jeff Schultz

This AJC sports blogger takes things seriously when he has to, but he really would rather not

Snitker was good but Bud Black may be Braves' choice for manager


I've weighed in on the Braves and the three biggest issues facing the team going into the offseason, the most important being the need for starting pitching (which wasn't supposed to happen).

Here's a link to that column.

But the hot topic right now is whether the team will keep interim manager Brian Snitker in the job, hire another internal candidate or bring in somebody new from outside the organization. So I figured I would give readers a chance to vote for one of six potential candidates, as well as share some of my thoughts on each:

• Bud Black: Many locked onto Black's candidacy as soon as he was fired in San Diego in June of 2015 after 8½ seasons. Black played part of his career with Cleveland and developed a relationship with John Hart, who was in charge of the Indians at the time and now is the Braves' president of baseball operations (and general manager John Coppolella's boss). He has won two World Series, one as a pitcher with Kansas City (1985) and one as the pitching coach for the Los Angeles Angels (2002). The Braves would try to sell Black as a smart pitching guy and therefore the perfect hire for an organization with young pitchers. But as a manager, Black had only two winning seasons with no postseason appearances in nine years with the Padres (he was fired in the ninth). His career  record: 649-713 (.477 ). Obviously won-loss records have a lot to do with talent and chemistry but can the Braves sell that? For what it's worth, ESPN's Jim Bowden lists Black as the "front runner" for the job. I'm inclined to agree.

• Brian Snitker: He went 59-65 as an interim manager, including 12-2 in the last 14 games. Is that good enough to sell the Braves that they should keep this as an inside hire? Not sure. Snitker was great, given the situation he stepped into but I believe Hart and Coppolella have been leaning toward bringing in somebody from the outside. Snitker made the decision more difficult but I'm not sure the late-season results have changed their mind.

• Terry Pendleton: He was always my pick from the coaching staff. Pendleton ranks as one of the greatest leaders and most respected players the Braves have ever had and would manage with the same fire that enabled the Braves to go from worst-to-first in 1991, when he was the National League's MVP. But Snitker's success may have eliminated any chance of the Braves giving the job to another internal candidate because it would be difficult to justify publicly.

• Eddie Perez: Many view Perez as a potential manager somewhere. He's a smart baseball man and knows pitchers. But I doubt he gets the job for the same reason Pendleton doesn't. The Braves haven't said anything about retaining Pendleton or Perez if a manager from the outside is hired, and it's conceivable neither would want to stay. Snitker is in a little different situation and at worst could return to being a minor league manager or kept as a coach.

• Ron Washington: It's a little surprising the Braves are interviewing him. That's not taking anything away from Washington as a manager -- he had four 90-plus win seasons and went to two World Series in Texas -- but he comes with a lot of personal baggage and he's 64 years old. This might be nothing more than a courtesy interview.

• Mark DeRosa: There have been no recent rumors of DeRosa's candidacy but the former player and current MLB Network analyst is held in high regard by the organization and was listed as a potential candidate shortly after Fredi Gonzalez's firing by multiple media outlets, including MLB.com's Mark Bowman. But this would be a pretty outside-the-box hire by an organization that doesn't generally make such moves and the Braves' brass seemed to make it clear Monday that they would not hire a "first-time manager." Given DeRosa has never even coached, I think he qualifies as a first-timer.

Some recent ramblings


Reader Comments ...


About the Author

Jeff Schultz is a general sports columnist and blogger who isn't afraid to share his opinion, which may not necessarily jibe with yours.