Get Schooled

Your source to discuss and learn about education in Georgia and the nation and share opinions and news with Maureen Downey

Is goal of Nathan Deal, Legislature to privatize schools? A former superintendent thinks so.


Former Pelham City, Ga., superintendent Jim Arnold is not one to hold back. This piece is no exception.

(You can keep with Arnold  here.)

By Jim Arnold

In my years as a teacher and administrator, staff development meetings were unavoidable. Most of the content could have been more effectively and far less painfully delivered in the form of an email, but I suppose that would have meant the end of a job for whatever “expert” was making the presentation and somebody somewhere would not have been able to document the hours teachers had spent in professional development. There were those momentous occasions, far too infrequent, when a phrase or an example or a Great Truth was presented.

One such moment came from a presenter whose name I have long since forgotten. He was the successful coach of a big time college football program, and made, in an almost offhand fashion, a reply to a question about discipline. “What you don’t correct,” he responded, “you are teaching.”

Teachers know that to be true, but to hear it elegantly expressed by one familiar with the trials and tribulations of teaching was a momentous moment of shining inspiration. It doesn’t mean you have to correct a student harshly every time they make a mistake. There are positive ways to say negative things, but the truth is that what we do not correct, we teach, and not usually with positive results.  Failing to correct negative behaviors will always produce negative results.

Teachers have suffered long years of “reform” that usually goes with “we once again want you to do more with less.” Gov. Deal recently stated he wants to “transform education in Georgia.” I maintain he has already done so.

The governor has led efforts that have imposed the junk science of the valued-added teacher evaluation model with no research that supports or recommends the method, yearly cuts to the education budget totaling billions of dollars, constant denigration of the teaching profession and teachers, the blaming of teachers for societal issues through calls for “more accountability,” massive layoffs and reductions in force to the teaching profession in spite of increases in student enrollment, significant increases in class sizes, the loss of art, PE and music classes statewide and for students at all levels, furloughs, reductions in the number of days of school for students and teachers and legislators that have in both effect and reality balanced the state budget on the backs of students, schools and teachers for the last six years.

The governor's and the Legislature's collective efforts have demoralized teachers to the point 44 percent leave teaching within the first five years of their careers, and the number of experienced teachers retiring early (those with 10-25 years experience - the heart of our teaching corps) has grown significantly during Deal’s time in office.

This is not a coincidence.

Teacher Retirements - 10-25 years experience

2009    2010   2011    2012   2013    2014

2483    2999   3559    3577   4107    3979   =  17,484

All Teacher Retirements

2009    2010   2011   2012    2013    2014

5564    6425   7168   7051    7929   7072    =  41,209

So what’s the governor’s response to the coming shortage of teachers?

First, he proposes a 3 percent pay raise for all teachers. What he forgets to say is there are still 40 or so systems that haven’t eliminated furloughs and most of the rest are still suffering from his exponential expansion of austerity cuts to school budgets. In spite of his threat to “hold districts accountable” for the raises he proposes, his prior cuts to education mean those raises are not sustainable. He has also doubled down on his efforts to increase the use of public money for privatization and vouchers with the expansion of programs designed to further reduce funds for public schools.

Add to that his desire to create a state-run Opportunity School District with a superintendent that reports only to him, his proposal to “change” (another word for reduce) the way teachers are paid and how money is allocated to schools and districts and it’s easy to see Gov. Deal never met an ALEC initiative he didn’t like.

Legislators seems not to have noticed the fiscal irresponsibility of adding another state-run program to the budget, just as they didn’t seem to notice the austerity cuts that left schools and teachers -- you know, the ones that need to be “accountable” -- bearing the financial burden of those cuts. I remember one legislator from another state remarking, “Money does not guarantee success, but the absence of money guarantees failure.” Would that he were from Georgia.

What has been the response of teachers to all this? Not much. We show some concerted opposition to isolated issues. The insurance scam a couple of years ago and the ideas about fiddling with TRS didn’t fly politically because of teacher opposition, and the recommendations to the way teachers are paid and systems funded have been delayed until after the election year, but what about evaluations and budget cuts and merit pay and a continued misguided emphasis on standardized testing?

Teachers have managed to raise the grad rate in Georgia to 72.5 percent  and struggled time and again to do more with less, and have been rewarded with the threat of  more and more restrictions and reductions and restructuring. What you don’t correct, you teach. We keep electing the same people with the same anti-public education ideas to the same offices. What you don’t correct, you teach.

But wait a minute -- look at all the success these ideas from the governor have had in other states.  How about the state-run school district in Tennessee…oops.  Not that one. What about the fantastic success of charters in New Orleans...no, maybe not that one, either. What about the wonderful increases in school choice in Florida and their merit pay and increased academic success...OK, maybe not that one, either. What about the studies that say 83 percent of all charter schools perform equal to or worse than public schools?

What about the warnings that “VAMs typically measure correlation, not causation: Effects – positive or negative attributed to a teacher may actually be caused by other factors that are not captured in the model” and that “Ranking teachers by their VAM scores can have unintended consequences that reduce quality.” Well, maybe those groups just don’t understand real math. The American Statistical Association? What do THEY know about education and politics?

What’s important to know here is that the goal of the folks that make the decisions about education in Georgia is not school improvement or student achievement. Their goal is privatization. Period. The use of public money for private educational enterprises and further crony capitalism.

So what can teachers do against these insurmountable obstacles? If you are not of member of PAGE or GEA or GREA or BAT or GAEL or TRAGIC or all of the above, you are missing opportunities for information and support. Be vigilant, knowledgeable and aware. Let your legislators know of your support for public education and your opposition to the privatization of education. Phone calls and emails have an effect on legislative votes. Make your voice heard. What you do not correct, you are teaching.

Many people hear the tired old “I support teachers” line from their local career politicians and far too often fall for it. Look at their voting records. If they voted for vouchers, the expansion of charter schools, the expansion of the special tax credit, the governor’s austerity cuts or teacher evaluation using student test scores the “what they say” aspect doesn’t matter compared to “what they have done."

Ask your Legislators to sign the PAGE “I promise” pledge about not tying teacher pay to student test scores and to roll back standardized testing for Georgia students. That ought to give you a pretty good idea, if you didn’t already know, where they stand on public education.

When you cast your vote, remember what you already know about teaching also applies to politicians; if you’re not correcting it, you’re teaching it.


Reader Comments ...


About the Author

Maureen Downey has written editorials and opinion pieces about local, state and federal education policy since the 1990s.